r/duelyst•
FirebatHS

How do you feel about Vet?

Vetruvian Op?

A lot of people that come in to my stream have been complaining about Vetruvian possibly being overpowered and saying that they would like to see nerfs. I honestly am pretty new to this game still, so don't know how I feel either way from a balance standpoint, but I do know that I think Vet is by far the most fun class to play for me. I love the blast mechanic and I love Time Malestrom, and so I am wondering if its just twitch chat that is BabyRage about Vet, or if the community really doesn't like it.

Why Vet is the Coolest Class

Also before you comment check out this sick Vet game and look at how cool the class is!

Video Link

(I am still an amateur player, so sorry if my game is riddled with misplays).

Posted Feb 12, 2016, 10:58 AM UTC

4972
Malvoli0•

I'm also kinda new to the game, I mostly just quest up to S-rank and then play gauntlet for the rest of the month. I am still gathering cards to start competing seriously so take what I say with a grain of salt.


There is no doubt in my mind that Vetruvian is the most powerful faction both for tournament play and the ladder. They are over the top in terms of numbers, but numbers can get fixed. However, I believe they have a deeper problem which asks for a rework of certain cards rather than just a number nerf - they are very boring to play against. The reason for this are 2 cards which are toxic by design - Scion's Third Wish, and Time Maelstrom.


On Third Wish: We all know numbers on Third Wish are wrong (it gives too many stats and it costs a mere 3 mana), but I think blast shouldn't come out of hand at all. Blast deals AOE damage from across the map, meaning it is an ambitious type of mechanic that threatens to create a lot of value for you if it's not dealt with quickly, it's sort of like a value type win condition. You can avoid being blasted by trying to distance yourself 3 lanes from the blast unit, but with the field being only 5 tiles wide that's often not viable to do. So you are left with rushing to take a grip on the Vetruvian and beat them in melee range. However, when you take into account blast can come on any unit at any given time, and that it can even come with a rush unit for a mere 5 or 6 mana out of hand - it becomes virtually impossible to play around it. It becomes both a very fast tempo play that removes one or 2 of your units and/or deals face damage and leaves a blast minion, threatening to gain even more value on the following turns if it is not removed. Even in the best case scenario, if you managed to remove the blast unit after the fact - you went about even in terms of mana/card expenditure. That's if you are lucky, if you are unlucky, you don't have a response and you are now losing the game. Things get even uglier when we consider "bad" scenarios, such as third wish being played on turn 2 by a P1 Vetruvian. It's almost considered a misplay to take the mana tile in front of you as P2 because your minion will get blasted together with taking face damage. My point is that it cannot be beaten with tactics, it can only be beaten with other cards, and when I say "beaten" I mean going even with it at best. In reality, on average, every time Vetruvian plays a Third Wish you fall more and more behind. By the time they played the third or fourth one, you are probably done.


On Time Maelstrom I know it feels like great fun to chain 3 turns in a row and win the game, but there is always one person who isn't having fun - the guy on the other side watching the show without being able to do absolutely anything about it. In a fast paced tactics game that goes back and forth it's not a good idea to let a player take multiple turns. In Magic the Gathering, these potentially game breaking effects exist because there is always an option to counterspell the opponent and ruin their plans. In Duelyst there is no interaction of this sort, and thus having plays which thwart efforts of players to play around each other's potential turn with tactics negatively affects gameplay. Similarly to Third Wish, playing against Vetruvian after 9 mana turns is like this: "I will play this and position like that, and it will work but if he has Time Maelstrom I am fucked, so I just hope he doesn't have it, because it is not possible to play around that card"


Now that I've said all that, there are ways to reduce the impact these cards might have on you, but they mostly revolve around - trying to remove everything on the board Vetruvian has at all times. This is once again a boring solution that narrows down on the Tactical depth of an otherwise relatively complex game. Always throw every removal at them until you are out of those and then ... well fuck. I firmly believe the game would be more fun if these cards were completely reworked to do something else. Of course, this means some of their other cards should get buffed to compensate. I would like to see a fine balance between Star's Fury and Blast threats comeback, conga lining until they put a blast minion on board, I enjoyed that.

TLDR Vetruvians are op, but before anything else boring to play against because of two toxic cards "Third Wish" and "Time Maelstrom". These reduce the tactical depth of the game. Rework them into something different and weaker, and buff other Vet cards.

35
Nyter•

"I'm kinda new, I just quest up to S-rank"

....

29
SuperSpartacus•

S-rank isn't a very difficult goal to achieve...you can do it with starter decks

-27
RireMakarControl Magmar for life•

Forgot to say it when I read this earlier -- this is very well put. Echoes all my feelings more eloquently than I could have put them, especially on the Third Wish issue.

1
smurfscaledustmancer•

I completely disagree on Time Maelstorm being "toxic" or broken. It's 9 fucking mana. It has to do something amazing for that cost.

Also can we please stop comparing Duelyst to MTG when it comes to playing around cards. Interrupt effects don't exist in Duelyst, if they did nobody would risk playing a 9 mana spell if the enemy could simply counter it for less. On the other hand positioning on a board doesn't exist in the same way it does in Duelyst. They're just different games.

Cards you cannot play around exist in Duelyst, and that's part of the game. Spiral Technique is 7 mana 8 damage you cannot play around. Lyonar spamming Sundrop Elixir and then Twilight Sorcerer to spam it even more cannot be played around.

And I would argue Time Maelstorm isn't even part of the above since if you expect it and have a decent board state, there are ways of positioning yourself so that your general is protected. Also Archon Spellbinder and Kenshrai Fanblade exist. Good luck casting a 10 mana Maelstorm when there's only 9 mana available.

-13
TheBhawbIGN: Bhawb•

Its 9 mana because you get an entire fucking free turn. If you play TM, you get a free turn with whatever you have on board, before you can take a normal turn and use your 9 mana like normal, but now with an objectively better board condition and up to 2(+1 replace) new cards.

10
erik4848•

I never looked at it like that but youre quite right, it's 9 mana for 2 extra cards, another replace, 9 mana back the next turn, and you can swing the entire board back into your favor.

1
Denice1984•

I agree with u. Time maelstrom is an awesome card that makes Vet cool. I wouldnt be playing Vet if not for this card. If they gonna nerf it then im gonna quit the game. Anyway how u gonna nerf time maelstrom? its already 9 mana for goodness sake. Also 9 mana card must do something that looks OP otherwise why would anyone play a 9 mana card. Dont fall into the hearthstone trap where nearly all 8 to 10 mana cards are unplayable because they dont do sh1t.

-5
iVariable•

I think you are looking at the card in the wrong way. It might cost 9 mana but it also gives you 9 mana back after you use it. So realistically the card is "9 mana - reactivate all exhausted units, draw two cards, replace one additional card and gain 9 additional mana"

2
[deleted]•

Not sure why you're being downvoted. People do tremendous things for less than 9 mana that are virtually always better than Time Maelstrom unless you can repeat it, and yet somehow TM is "Toxic"? Please. In a game as tempo/aggro/synergy heavy as duelyst, TM is far from a problem.

-5
smurfscaledustmancer•

The problem with Vetruvian is that most of its class cards, even the ones that used to be staples, are either underwhelming or not viable in the meta. Dervishes and post-nerf Portal Guardians are so cool but they absolutely can't keep up at higher level. This makes Vet players rely on Third Wish plus whatever high value Neutral minion is available, making the matchup vs them boring and predictable.

Is Third Wish too strong and unfun to play against? Probably, but the fact is that the rest of the faction cards are not that great. Vetruvian is my favourite faction but the current Meta lists lack the personality and the diversity that this class should be filled with.

PS - I think I met you on ladder once when you were still ArchonFirebat, you were playing Arcanyst Vet and totally rekt my OMA Songhai. Good game.

19
FishEC•

OMA?

1
Aeroswoot•

What strange said. Its a thing apparently.

1
Mr_Ivysaur•

I actually hate it. If they start on left:

Turn 1: Drop a random creature behind

Turn 2: 3rd Wish

If you do not have a long distance dispel or removal, it is GG. Not to mention that they punish you for trying to get that mana spring.

Playing against them is just a polarized match. Or either you win because you manage to draw removals, or either you lose because you didn't. And when you think that you are playing around 3rd Wish, they use Star's Fury.

Personally, what I hate most is because most of the good cards are expensive. Time Maelstrom, Star Fury, 3rd Wish, Rashar's Course... All Epic and Legendaries. So that saying "if it is OP, why don't you play it?" does not work here.

It is a fun class, because structures and buffs. I played a lot. But when people playing competitively, it become less interesting and much more frustrating.

14
Catniss_DB•

The problem isn't pretty much only Third wish (games rarely last to where Time Maelstrom is the make or break card for winning/losing.)

And third wish isn't even the biggest issue (though it's a pretty big one.)

It's the complete lack of ANYTHING useful that's faction exclusive in their faction cards. (outside of 3rd wish of course)

It's seriously sad that they need to rely almost exclusively on neutral cards since none of their faction cards are worth a dick.

The problem is if they make it cost 4, it will kill the entire faction. If they nerf the damage or remove blast, it kills the faction.

They need to focus on fixing the faction cards, then rebalance 3rd wish at the same time.

13
RestInPeaceInPeace•

If they use third wish they can reach end game easily. It's the best mid game tempo card.

Time Maelstrom is the best end game card, use it when you have a card on the field and you win.

1
Catniss_DB•

Thank you for ignoring everything I said and stating the obvious.

Time Maelstrom is literally a dead card until turn 9, and even then you need to be in a position on turn 9+ where you can actually afford to drop 9 mana for a big finisher. Otherwise it's an overcosted 2 card draw / 1 cycle. And no, you don't "win" as soon as you play it with a single creature fielded. You win if you have a solid body on the field, TW in your hand, and multiple cards in hand to finish your opponent, if he's even in danger by then. It's a very specific setup that is fueled by TW being unbalanced, not time maelstrom.

Third wish IS busted right now, nobody is debating this. However, it is also the ONLY faction card Vet has that can compete with the other factions right now. If they change it without adjusting the Vet faction cards to be in line with the strength of the other factions', then Vets will be quite literally unplayable. They have nothing that competes with the other factions besides TW and to a lesser extent TM.

0†
Astralweeks2131•

Time maelstrom is just as OP as 3rd wish. Even if you don't have much board you can replace an extra card, draw an extra 2 cards and completely reposition the board, For FREE!

In hearthstone this card would clog up your hand at 9mana cost, but the replace mechanic means this is not an issue in duelyst.

1
Catniss_DB•

"FOR FREE"

You mean for the cost of your entire mana pool?

The ONLY time TM is a real threat is when it's used in combination with TW, or when you're already in a position where you'll win the game in a turn anyway.

I don't know about you, but I'm in diamond right now and AT BEST games end with one or two minions on the board. (Unless you're against abyssian) The only time I've found TM useful is when I have 2 TWs in hand, and am able to reposition my single remaining unit to where I can one shot an entire row or kill the general.

Maybe if dust devils weren't so garbage, TM might be super powerful in tandum with the spawning stations. However, until they make structures immune to being insta-gibbed by just about everything, I'll stand by TW being the much larger issue than TM.

-2
FearAndArrogance•

I have been playing since Dec and have been S-rank every month if that lends any credibility. I am finding this vet meta to be the most boring meta yet and that is why I don't like it. Of all the top tier meta decks that have come and gone, it seems to me that Vet right now is the most draw dependent on both sides. Does Vet draw their third wishes and does their opponent draw their silences / removal. The positioning aspect of vet counterplay isn't even interesting because it is just play in a diagonal every turn even if the board is clear because vet can rush third wish from hand.

8
StillEternity•

Vetruvian right now is a double-edged sword: Third Wish is a game-defining card, but it's one of the few strong cards Vetruvian has left.

I'm also fairly new, but I did some research on Vetruvian since they seemed so interesting to me and Time Maelstrom was the very first Legendary I opened: What I found is that they've suffered a handful of nerfs in the past and now are mainly relying on the strength of Third Wish to carry them.

I don't even really think Time Maelstrom is much of a problem: You need 9 Mana first of all to even play it, and it's useless unless you already have some semblance of a board.

Third Wish feels bad to be on the receiving end of, that I won't really argue against, especially when you're a new player and you don't have the best cards to fight it/get taken advantage of by poor positioning, ect. but if the Devs decide to nerf Third Wish, I really hope they have some good compensation for Vetruvian, otherwise the class will shoot from near top to near bottom.

6
Denice1984•

Yes, this is exactly how i feel as a Vet player as well. As a Vet player i admit that third wish is slightly broken. But i really hope they think about how to nerf it properly. Nerfing it too much would make Vet unplayable, making my favourite class unplayable may make me leave the game for good. I really enjoy Vet, i hope they dont destroy it.

1
Aeroswoot•

Im in the same boat. The thing is, Vetruvian has been nerfed so many times. I think that it has gone through the most nerfs out of any class. If they havent, then they sure are close. I just want to see where they can put Vet. But I disagree that vet isnt fun to play against. There are plenty of ways you can play against vet, since they generally have a hard time with board control.

1
_smashthings_•

Hi, multi S-rank & tourney player here. I took Vet to S this season with 85% wr.

Personally I don't have too many issues with Time Mael. While powerful its 9 mana cost card and if we don't want games to last 40+ mins we need cards that can quickly close out games.

Also, while triple time mael can be insane I think people frequently under-estimate the cost of the card; namely that if you run three copies you spend most of the game drawing and then replacing it, which obviously impacts the potency/consistency of your early & mid-game. Its not a "free win" as some might suggest.

As for 3rd wish, I don't like it. Not only is it hard to play around (moving in diagonals helps vs the blast but not vs the stats. moreover diagonal movement weakens you to Stars fury) the vet decks centre their strategy around the card, which only adds to the frustration.

At top level I don't think the card is as powerful as many argue (is it really that much more powerful than Sonhai's Inner Focus?) but it is a card you have to spent the entire game playing around, and that can be both difficult and exhausting to do.

For example, feeling forced to clear all minions because if you don't 3rd wish wrecks you is not fun and far worse still can be really hard to do at times (e.g. T sorc has 6 health)

In short, I'd like to see a change such that not all the power is centralised in 1-2 cards. If they nerf 3rd wish next patch I'd like to see something added. A buff to dervishes, perhaps.

5
Fluffcake•

I don't think time maelstroem is a real problem, it is inevitability, and will kill you if you let the game go on long enough.

Third wish however, is problematic, the threat of blast from hand completely dictates how the game is played out, and will often lead the game in a direction where time maelstroem becoms the win condition. It also overshadows everything else in the faction, it snowballs extremely hard and fast. It is pretty much game over if played on turn 2 and sticks around for more than a turn.

3
KingGorlak•

As some one whos played for less then a week and is only rank 15. My problem with third wish is that blast by itself is a sick buff, but to also give a minion 3/3 makes it really beefy. If you cant remove it the turn after he gets its out. Its basically an auto loss. I think you are just getting to much value for 3 mana. Either it should cost 5 mana or it should inly give +1/+1

3
LeprechaunJinx•

I'd even be fine if rather than give +3/+3 it gave +3/+1 or no bonus health at all. My problem with Third Wish is the sudden beefiness that comes with that bonus 3 health in conjunction with the damage. Even if I can get a minion back to deal with their Blast I can't trade with it well with that much bonus health.

5
Bloodblue•

Vet shows the limits of the shallow board game. Blast, range and frenzy aren't well thought out and really all characters should have individual movespeeds and ranges.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
UnoProMaster Race•

Vetruvian is actually a class which I really didn't mind having at the top of the meta for quite a while. The reasoning for this is that the mechanics of blast, aswell as cards such as Star's Fury and Rasha's Curse, means that positioning of minions and general is constantly of massive importance. Whilst positioning is always really important a lot of the time the difference between potential positions is very minimal and as long as you can block mana tiles and not get kited for no reason you are doing alright. This can be especially true vs vanar who lacks reliable aoe. Against Vet it's no longer as simple not worrying too much about positioning because my lyonar opponent only has 5 mana (6 mana: minion + holy immolation). The existence of any Vet minion means that we are constantly having to position around a possible third wish while also considering the possibility of a potential Star's Fury. The frequency which Star's Fury currently turns up in decks is something I consider to be really positive and healthy for Vet. Alot of decks run 1 or 2 with some skipping it all together. The low frequency of Star's Fury creates interesting situations where a smart player can make a small concession to third wish if they believe it to be worth lowering the value of star's fury. This may be because a bad Star's Fury could lose them the board or may be the only way for an opponent to get a surprise lethal. If Star's Fury was good enough to still be a 3x then I think it would actually be quite a bad thing as positioning against Vet would become a frustrating guessing game between playing around Star's Fury of Third Wish. However in its current state it allows players to make a small concession to third wish in order to lower the percentage risk of a loss in a winning or drawn position.

My problem with Vet comes from third wish rather than the actual power level, as I said Vet in general is a healthy faction which allows lots of counterplay and involves making lots of tiny important decisions. However third wish currently represents an overwhelming part of Vetruvian's power. This creates an unhealthy environment where the power of a Vetruvian deck scales incredibly hard with how many third wishes are drawn. The power of Vetruvian needs to be spread out across class cards rather than centralized in third wish. I'm not happy to see that current Vetruvian decks are basically just Vetruvian's good spells + neutral minions as the low card pool means that we already see the same neutral minions over and over.

I know some people complain about time maelstrom but I have no problem with it. It is very strong and has no downside once you are at 9 mana but that is no easy feat, especially in the current meta. I do not believe that third wish should be nerfed without other class cards in Vet being buffed in compensation.

2†
Malvoli0•

All the fun aspects of positioning that you describe is something that the faction lost with the January rework actually. Star's Fury is such an inferior threat compared to 3rd wish, that you just can't afford to play around it. Yes, Old Star's Fury and Third wish were overpowered, but in terms of numbers only. If they dealt with those differently, I believe Vetruvians would have kept the fine balance between the Star's Fury and Blast threat, and you would still have conga lines and all the cute positional quirks. Right now it's not even about blast minions anymore, much less Star's Fury - it's just about Third Wish itself. Vetruvians have a lot of potentially fun mechanics that are all nullified by that one card.

I agree with you that if Third Wish needs to be changed, other Vetruvian cards need to get buffed.

2
StrangeAndGlorious•

I suggest you make the "blast" power only apply to Vet creatures. that would not only balance it, but it would be consistent with other faction buffs.

2
Denice1984•

I like this idea. For instance, only "dervish" minions can have blast. But sadly i think there are huge downsides to this idea, creativity of players would be limited because of this & its also not very intuitive that a buff can only be used on certain type of minions.

3
StrangeAndGlorious•

I'm not saying limit it to dervishes, Just Vet creatures.

There are already several cards that have additional effects based on the stats of the target. I don't see one more being a problem.

1
CrescentBlaze•

I don't think Vet's really that troublesome, it's more that the class doesn't have the best internal balance, ideally you'd want most of the faction cards to at least have cases in which they are usuable.

1
shuffleorboogie•

I wrote about Scion's Third Wish here as that's the overpowered aspect of this faction. On the other hand, Vetruvian has too much underpowered/underutilized cards and strategies that need a little push from the developers' side. I'm gonna make a post on that this weekend probably, in hope I can get an opinion out before changes are done.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
StrangeAndGlorious•

The question that i would ask is: What are the cards in the other factions that are as good as 3rd wish?

1
Denice1984•

How is this question helpful? I would rather have 5 semi-OP cards in my class, than just 1 super OP card in my class. This is why its not smart to compare class cards with another class card.

-1
StrangeAndGlorious•

The answer to the question is that there are no other single card as good as 3rd wish. Nothing even close.

I'm sorry, but I feel that when you have a card that good, something needs to change.

1
Twitchkun•

yes there are cards that are close. Deathstrike seal on an early ranged minion can easily control the board the same way TW can. The same argument applies with no being able to draw answers. Also killing edge is very similar to TW.

0
StrangeAndGlorious•

How come those cards don't rule the dominant decks?

1
Denice1984•

Simply because a card is broken is not enough to justify nerf. We need to ask whether the class as a whole is broken. Example: if a class only has one super broken op card but every other card is unplayable, then the class itself would likely be unplayable because of the lack of consistency / over reliance of that one broken card. It doesnt make sense then to nerf this broken card and further make the class even more unplayable. Im not saying third wish is not OP, im just saying thats the wrong question to ask.

-1
StrangeAndGlorious•

I'm glad you agree that 3rd wish is OP.

What, in your opinion, justifies a nerf?

1
Denice1984•

In my opinion third wish is definitely slightly broken. And the facts dont lie, ladder and tournament results dont lie. If third wish is not broken, Ladder wouldnt be swarmed with Vet players and third wish x3 wouldnt be auto include in all Vet decks. There is also a reason why its pretty impossible for Vet players to win if all 3 third wish are the last 3 cards of the deck. However, I would say that although third wish is OP, its OPness is definitely being exaggerated in the community. Probably a slight nerf like Blast would hit your own minions / general would be sufficient nerf. Any bigger nerf would make Vet unplayable class, most likely even more unplayable than Abyssian. Also I am myself a Vet player, and I would definitely be sad if Third wish is nerfed.

1
Rookwood•

For me, Songhai was much more oppressive. I felt like no matter how you played against Foxhai it didn't really matter. The game depended on them getting their cards or not.

Vet is different. It feels more like playing against a deck that is full of ironcliffe guardians with range. That sounds op and it is a little or they wouldn't dominate the meta like they do, but there is still room for counterplay and if you can get ahead on them you can take the game.

Of course they also have the 9 mana "I win" card which I think is the more op card. You have to counter them AND beat them quickly. They are definitely a little unbalanced and as others have said they have some fundamental issues with their faction as a whole.

1
H3llycat•

I still hate Vanar more. Goddamn fenrirs.

1
DucktalesLoLs•

What's a vetruvian? The only classes I know of is songhai, abyssian, vanar, magmar, lyonar, and third wish.... I'm confused...

1