Senior U.S. Supreme Court Associate Justice Antonin Scalia found dead at West Texas ranch
mysanantonio.com/news/us-world/article/Senior...Posted Feb 13, 2016, 10:27 PM UTC
Posted Feb 13, 2016, 10:27 PM UTC
This is almost certainly a death blow for conservatism in America. My opinion is that it officially died 50 years ago. But that's just conjecture. Look, I'm not saying every single idea he had was good, but the Supreme court represented a real check on the executive and the legislative branches. If we get a Democrat president, Democrat congress, and Democrat supreme court this 2016 then say goodbye to "rights".
Hell even without a 2016 Democrat win you might as well kiss them goodbye. For a right is nothing but a privilege that a clever legislator has not figured out a way to make it illegal yet.
I wouldn't see it as much as a check, unless it logically followed its obligations. In practice it acts as a path of least resistance for progressive idealism. Unless the Supreme Court is loaded with traditionalists/textualists it tends to sway heavily towards progressives. The 80's resurgence of conservatism allowed for a temporary loading of the courts, which was a massive setback to progressive idealism.
This is the primary judge who refused to wave a magic wand and create law out of thin air and leftist dogmatism. Gun rights will almost certainly be abolished with his death and the only way to prevent it will be to rightfully impeach the Supreme Court for no longer being "in good behaviour" and making up laws as they go along like "the 14th Amendment legalized gay marriage in the 19th Century and we've just now realized it!" Obama is certainly going to appoint someone from his far left dogma school of thought.
The Supreme Court was never supposed to be able to make law - at all. Unfortunately, they've been doing exactly that for decades now. Scalia was one of the first to strongly, publicly, and vociferously challenge these criminals' behavior.
Clearly there are times that call for an "interpretation" or "inference" that can not be decided from the "original" meaning of the law. For example, we have internet blogs now - something that wasn't anticipated when "freedom of the press" was invented. It is a more reasonable inference to believe that "freedom of the press" was designed to protect the free exchange of ideas and publication, and not solely printed media even though there wasn't anything except printed/handwritten media at the time. This isn't the same as judicial activism, this is reasonable behavior in the face of empirical technological changes to society. There's no real reason to believe that a person's right to be "secure in papers" doesn't apply to email as it does to printed messages - as they both fulfill the same function - allowing people to exchange written communications with one another.
The original meanings of "freedom of the press" and "secure in papers" are still being applied by applying them to electronic communication because these concepts were invented not to protect printing presses and the mail system - but their meaning was, in fact, to preserve freedom of communication between the citizens. If "secure in papers" was created with the logical reasoning that frequent interceptions of communications would make the mail system too slow, then you would be right to argue it might not apply to email - but it, in fact, was invented to prevent the government from unreasonably spying on your communications and, hence, the original meaning is still preserved when applying it to email.
However, saying that "gay marriage is now legal" would attempt to wed sociological changes to technological ones where no such change exists. "Progressives" base their foundation on the big lie that what they view as "sociological progress" is basically the same as empirical, physical, technological progress (even leftists like Chomsky admit this), and, therefore, the Constitution may change as new ideologies are indoctrinated by the corporate media. This simply isn't true, nor is it reasonable.
I'm sorry but that's bs. Gun rights have nothing to do with scalia, and this inane republican attempt to try and paint him as some bastion of freedom is ridiculous. I just came across a quote where it said if anyone is innocent, but the prosecution is able to xinvict him by following the letter of the law, that state should still execute that person solely bc thales laws were followed. What kind of imbecile is inspired by another imbecile who says these words.
I didn't paint him as a bastion of freedom - I painted him as someone who interpreted the Constitution as it was passed by congress.
I'm only in favor of totalitarianism that doesn't cloak itself in corruption, propaganda and lies. I regard shadow totalitarianism as the purest evil there is. Scalia properly recognized that the Supreme Court pulling rabbits out of their hats like legalizing gay marriage and permitting abortion was shadow totalitarianism.
Expanding personal liberty at the expense of state power is pretty close to the exact opposite of any kind of totalitarianism.
Do you have even the vaguest sense of irony?
Expanding State liberty at the expense of Federal Control is the opposite of Totalitarianism.
Human rights also apply to the rights of cultures to preserve themselves - they are not solely individual rights.
To say "I know best for everyone" and institute that law without authority as the Supreme Court has done multiple times, such as with abortion and gay marriage, is totalitarianism. The Supreme Court has no authority to create laws the American people did not enact.
[deleted]