soupyquinnRight Tentacle Man of the Kochtopus•

So the government gives a loan, then sends government agents to collect.

CAPITALISM!!!

32
insincere_fondueFilthy Bourgeois Member •

Even banks don't imprison you. This is a debtors prison, one of the reasons that started the French revolution; not exactly the most capitalistic times.

15
wellactuallyhmm•

Debtors prisons are inherently anti-capitalist.

4
nakedtime313•

I saw that and had to throw my two cents in. The absurdity of that comment was mind blowing.

6
esterbraeOP•

Please dont bother voting the the thread, r/news is a lost cause.

I'm instead asking why it is so common for people to shit talk capitalism and most people simply nod and ignore it, or at worse agree vaguely that some kind of "-ism" is to cause for their problems.

OTOH, impugn the government's hand in any given problem and the socialist wolves bare their fangs, while the average person leaps to the defense of government in the abstract.

Has public education indoctrinated us into a herd mentality ? Where is the common sense in the world ?

21
springbreakbox•

In a word: altruism. Capitalism cannot be defended on altruistic grounds, and that is the dominant philosophy in many spheres of culture.

http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/altruism.html

20
bilcox•

"I help starving children" - best person ever

"I help starving children, for profit" - most evil person ever

19
adelie42•

Seems more like:

"It is tragic that there are starving children in the world. Somebody should do something about that! " -Best person ever

"I built a network where nobody ever needs to go hungry and the entire arrangement is mutually beneficial to everyone involved" -Literally Hitler

16
SimpleManSC•

The irony is that the profit motive can incentivize the "evil" person to do a good deed they otherwise wouldn't have done. Maybe Literally Hitler would never have fed starving children otherwise but since he can make a buck he does it.

At the end of the day the starving children are better off than before but because the intention of Literally Hitler wasn't "correct" it is not a preferable outcome.

1
esterbraeOP•

Insightful, thank you

4
ZombieAlpacaLips•

that is the dominant philosophy in many spheres of culture.

It is? I'd say people look admirably upon those who give generously to others, but I wouldn't say it's a "dominant philosophy". Maybe we expect parents to truly sacrifice for their children or spouse, but it doesn't go much further than that.

I think the main problem is that people can't see the difference between giving someone your coat and giving someone your neighbor's coat.

4
JustDoinThings•

I think the main problem is that people can't see the difference between giving someone your coat and giving someone your neighbor's coat.

That is still altruism? So two parts:

If you work for money you are benefiting society through your work. This is the most effective benefit because society pays you for your work - thus what gets done is valued.

Liberals have no conception of that. If money is involved its evil.

They believe you have to do good for others altruistically. AKA give to others for nothing in return. Since there is no market and pricing system giving them guidance lets just let the benevolent leader take our money and spend it.

So yeah that is your part. Still the same philosophical source.

The reason this occurs is because the government needs to control your philosophy and morality and make government GOOD, private BAD to ensure your support otherwise government collapses. Government propaganda and control of the schools created this problem.

1
wellyesofcourseThe government is my safe space•

Wow, I'm surprised that someone can link ARL and it not get downvoted into oblivion, even on SSS.

2
sensedata•

People may say that in theory, but empirical evidence suggests that might equals right force-fed via ex post facto justification is the dominant philosophy.

2
soupyquinnRight Tentacle Man of the Kochtopus•

I think there's three main issues at play here. First is the school indoctrination which you pointed out. 18 years (assuming a BA) of hearing capitalism is bad is going to tend to make people think capitalism is bad.

Second is the fact that this new generation is living in a post cold war time. They aren't growing up reading about gulags happening "right now in the world". If they learn about them at all they are seen as relics of the past. Cuba is seen as "quaint."

Finally, there are some real, big grievences people have with the current system. Because a large part of their grievences are about crony capitalism, actual capitalism gets caught in the crossfire. This is compounds by the first two issues.

16
robberday•

We don't have to read about gulags.

We're reading about our own Government sponsored black sites and the torture they perpetrated. Independently of Communism, Socialism, or Capitalism governments establish these prisons.

12
Euphemism•

It is amazing to me that so many people refuse to see the common denominator of the issues, regardless of political affiliation, color, sex or creed...

as was said..

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/eb/c5/2c/ebc52c6f3ae429145ef11795ff98831f.jpg

9
nidrach•

A state will always materialize. There will always be a hierarchy. That's the nature of human cooperation. 15 people can do stuff more efficiently than 15 one man operations. The only thing you can influence is the nature of the state, the structure of the system. Outside of that is only cold darwinian logic. The many stomp out the few.

4
5cBurroAyn Rand's buttplug•

Could you elaborate on the difference between capitalism and crony capitalism?

3
HerrBBQThe Arachno Crapitalist•

Crony capitalism is government-granted monopolies, money in politics to get favors, preferential treatment, incorporation and other government sponsored forms of non-liability, etc. It's basically when certain businessmen either influence or are influenced by the government for a mutual benefit, which fucks over consumers, employees, and other businesses that don't play the game.

9
nidrach•

It's basically the only form of capitalism that has ever existed outside of thought experiments.

-3
soupyquinnRight Tentacle Man of the Kochtopus•

I think the person before me did a good job, but to put it simply, capitalism is the free exchange of goods and services in the context of private property rights. Crony capitalism is the government handing out economic and regulatory favors to established interests and/or in exchange for straight up bribes. Basically it comes down to free market or not free market.

And I don't think you should be down voted for simply asking a question

3
esterbraeOP•

Because a large part of their grievences are about crony capitalism, actual capitalism gets caught in the crossfire.

I agree; I think many socialists do their profit-taking under the guise of capitalism. If you deliver taxes directly to your friends, its obvious graft. Award them a juicy overpriced contract, and the issue is harder to discern...

1
DRAAIIIIINNNNIDGE•

It sucks because before it was a default sub it was pretty objective.

Then they let the trash in...

5
adelie42•

Same way people ignore and dismiss threats of violence from liberals and communists. No matter how often there is follow through, it is so often just talk that nobody cares, the same way once a child starts whining about how unfair something is you simply stop listening.

3
leftboot•

Capitalism involves a free market society, which prompts individuals to seek out work to stay alive and prosper. That can put fear into certain individuals so they 'shit-talk' it. This helps them justify many immoral acts done by their masters who have promised them refuge from the fear that they have to seek out work to stay alive and prosper. I'm somewhat new to this but that's my understanding.

6
springbreakbox•

Studying the book/collection of essays "Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal" was many times more valuable than my (State school) university degree in economics; and is such an apt title.

6
Jattopotamus•

I surprised to see some of the responses to that comment. Some very pro-Capitalist comments with actual upvotes.

6
LiveFree1773Somalian Koch Nobility•

It was r/news, if it had been r/politics it would be a different story.

3
godless_communism•

Well, because capitalism isn't usually accountable to those with little power and money. And one of the main features of democracy is that its goal is to make elites in society accountable to the people at large. It's possible that capitalism and democracy are headed for a divorce. I don't know if you think this is a good or bad thing.

5
esterbraeOP•

I think very similarly, except I would reverse the position of capitalism and democracy in each of your sentences.

I think it is a good thing, because democracy seems fairly easy to manipulate into tyranny.

2
SubhumanShit•

Your beef should be with the government.

But then he would have to admit that it's the government which is ultimately bad instead of evil Capitalism like he's thought his entire life.

You mean since his first semester in college. Last fall.

LOL

4
ShiningBrightKnight#ResistRoads•

It's the truth though.

Socialism and there brothers of edgy-communism get weeded out as these people get older. After they get a job, they just become Democrats. Because they realise the world isn't fair when their taxes become higher the more they earn. Which would be a deal breaker to anyone who wants to be something more than a part time job assistant in some restaurant/work desk.

2
jphert12I eat proletariats for breakfast•

Cuz it's the new hip thing to do, bruh.

3
nidrach•

It was the new hip thing in 1880.

2
MaunaLoonaThe One Free Man•

It's virtue signaling. "I'm a good man because capitalism is evil and I sympathize with the plight of the working class."

2

Why would it ever be unacceptable to "shit-talk" any economic system?

1
esterbraeOP•

I just feel like capitalism is little more than free association and voluntary action.

Blaming it for bad things seems disingenuous at best, or evil at worst.

2