TheManWhoPanders•

Mrs. Clinton has argued that $15 might be too high for employers in low-wage states, causing them to lay off workers or make fewer hires. There is no proof for or against that position. There is solid empirical evidence showing that moderate increases in the minimum wage do not harm employment.

I want to know what world you have to live in to think that more than doubling the minimum wage is "moderate". He's literally against a $12 minimum wage.

136
TitoTheMidget•

I feel that the NYT is entirely too NY-centric on this one.

$15/hr is a fine minimum wage for New York, where the cost of living is such that $12/hr just won't cut it.

But, that's what state and local minimums are for. What about states like Wyoming, where MIT's living wage calculator for one adult has the living wage at only $9.93/hr? It's not until you get into single-parent households (which will always struggle), or households with multiple children that $15/hr is necessary to cover living wage expenses in states like that. $12/hr seems like a much more reasonable federal number for these reasons, with higher cost-of-living states having higher minimums.

In the state and county I live in, $15/hr is pretty good money that can afford an above-average quality of life. I make a little over $15/hr at my job, and according to MIT's calculator my wage is enough to support a 2-adult, 1 working household. My wife works only part-time, also at a little over $15/hr. If we were both working full-time we would be making more than enough to support a 2-parent, 3-child household. In my area of the country, I have little doubt that a $15 federal minimum would lead to more job loss than it would economic mobility. $12/hr, however, is a reasonable wage that most people here can afford to live on, with disposable income left over.

89
TheRootsCrew•

Agreed. $15 nationally is just too high...which is why states and cities and towns build upon whatever the federal rate is.

$15 could not happen in parts of the midwest

28
[deleted]•

$15 in 2022 is probably closer to $13 today. $12 in 2022 is probably closer to $10 today. So it's at least somewhat important to keep the dollar amounts in perspective.

But there are really curious things happening state by state. Some crazy natural experiments are going on right as we speak.

For instance, New Hampshire repealed the minimum wage. Massachusetts set it at $10/hr. Vermont, Rhode Island, and Connecticut at $9.60/hr. But Maine is set at $7.50/hr.

Meanwhile Quebec is set at $10.75CAD/hr, which 3 years ago was really high, but due to currency markets is now only worth only $7.85USD/hr. And New Brunswick is set to $10.65. Pretty much the same story.

So this is basically one large, regional economy, with massive minimum wage disparities. Within a 90 minute drive, you can experience nearly the entire extremes of state minimum wage laws in America, often in the same commuter market.

One would think that being in the Boston Metro, the fact that NH relatively recently repealed its state minimum wage would have little affect on actual wages.

But the result has been kind of startling. Back in 2003, there were about 2,000 NH workers receiving minimum wage, roughly half men, half women. That number stayed steady until the great recession, when it popped up to about 4,000. Today it stands at about 6,000, and is roughly 1/3 men, 2/3 women, according to BLS.

Meanwhile, the labor participation rate is high compared to the US generally (this is true of all of New England), but it has dropped in NH over time, as is the national trend.

But the really bizarre thing is that Massachusetts has only 12,000 workers being paid minimum wage. A much smaller percentage of total employment. So even though NH minimum wage is 28.5% cheaper than MA minimum wage, a larger share of employers are paying exactly minimum wage in NH than MA. And like I said before, the bulk of NH's population is in the Greater Boston area.

The same holds with Vermont. But Maine, where minimum wage is only $0.25 higher than NH has a more similar percentage of workers at minimum wage.

Frankly, I'm not quite sure what all of this means. And it's just a cursory exam of the stats, there's no causal argument I'm making here.

But something strange and probably unpredicted is going on as minimum wages between states grow further and further apart.

27
A_Soporific•

It's because no one wants to bury the issue by pegging it to inflation or a consumer price index. They want the points from fighting it out every seven to ten years.

Additionally, if the market wage is higher than the legal minimum wage then no one would be paid the minimum wage. It's a price floor, not the starting point of all wages. If it is "too low" price floors are irrelevant to the market. If it is too high it causes all sorts of problems.

15
Commodore_ObviousSchilling ist mein Geschäft, und das Geschäft läuft gut.•

$12 in 2022 is probably closer to $10 today.

$12 in 2022 is equivalent to $10 today if we assume 3.1% annual inflation.

Edit: If we use the inflation rate expected by TIPS investors (1.03% for 5-year), $10 today is equivalent to approximately $10.63 in 2022.

9
Jericho_Hill#StickyLivesMatter #SupportTheMods•

It's actually a bit of a high end estimate adjusting for inflation. Its closer to about 14.3 dollars , in your first paragraph example.

Its also not unusual, the pattern you see. Jobs are not distributed equally, nor are job types.

8
theskepticalheretic•

But something strange and probably unpredicted is going on as minimum wages between states grow further and further apart.

Is it really that strange considering the ideologically-based labor policies put in place by the various states' elected officials coupled with the local differences in market environment between states?

3
WhyYouAreVeryWrong•

Heck, forget the midwest, $15 minimum wage couldn't even happen in eastern Washington state.

Downtown studio apartments are, like, $325/mo and 3 bed/2 bath homes sell for ~$100k. A couple working $15 minimum wage at Burger King can afford a large home home, two cars, a boat and annual vacations with costs there.

13
theskepticalheretic•

Downtown studio apartments are, like, $325/mo and 3 bed/2 bath homes sell for ~$100k.

As a New Englander, these prices aren't believable to me, but I know they're pretty close to the truth.

6
Chiptox•

You are absolutely right. I bought a fixer-upper 3 bedroom 1 bath on an acre here for $85k three years ago.

A full-time federal minimum wage job would cover my living expenses right now (no mortgage, I bought the place with cash). Never mind $15 an hour or even the WA state minimum.

For what they pay for places like this elsewhere you could have a freaking mansion with acreage and outbuildings. Horses. Maybe a nice Kubota tractor. Those people are my neighbors.

I struggle to understand just how people struggle making it here. It's so damn cheap you almost have to be willfully retarded with absolutely no marketable skills to screw it up. But you know, Spokane is gonna Spokane. So it still happens.

2
araguay•

My first job, as a software engineer, paid $25k ($12.50/hr). This job required a university degree and was skilled labour that not just anyone could do. It paid $12.50.

For where I was, this was a bad salary for what I did, but a perfectly fine salary at the low end. It wasn't the most comfortable, but I not only survived debt-free, but was able to save ~100 a month.

How? Because this was in the midwest, where rent split halfers on a 2br apartment was $300. Where I sucked it up and rode the bus. Where my grocery bill was <$100/mo.

$15/hr minimum wage is perfectly fine for New York. But it frustrates the hell out of me that the current political climate thinks that $15/hr as a minimum wage is anywhere near reasonable in middle-of-nowhere Kansas or somesuch. $15/hr full time is $30,000/yr. Factor in the more expensive CoL in NYC and you're at the equivalent of $60k there. Then factor in the fact that low-CoL places tend to have lower taxes, you get full time $15/hr minwage in the midwest approximately equal to $70k/yr in NYC.

The idea of there being one country-wide minimum wage is absurd. If there has to be one, it should be a floor for the lowest min wage, not the NYC/SF/DC min wage.

3
HandjobSally•

Just curious, how long ago was your first job. No offense but I've never heard of a software engineer making that type of money.

2
araguay•

It was in 2010. Never work at an indie game dev studio

6
derleth•

And, of course, if we went to a $15/hour minimum wage, the cost of living would jump, leading to a $30/hour minimum wage, and so on. It just never ends. Wage-price spiral, every single time.

-1†
TitoTheMidget•

And, of course, if we went to a $15/hour minimum wage, the cost of living would jump, leading to a $30/hour minimum wage, and so on.

There is no evidence of a causal link for this from past minimum wage increases.

19
derleth•

There is no evidence of a causal link for this from past minimum wage increases.

But it must be true! It's one party's political dogma!

8
Rufus_T_Firefly_•

I'm in AZ right now. $15 minimum wage would be well above a living wage. But we still have people protesting outside the McDicks to raise it to $15. Anytime that I bring up that $15 is a lot in some places I get downvoted to hell.

24
throwmeaway898989•

People flood into that area for the "high wages" compared to back home and then complain.

6
Rufus_T_Firefly_•

Lol, who the fuck is coming here for high wages other than Mexicans?

4
Hadrianunlimited•

this is exactly the cause of urbanization for the last 300 years

5
Zeppelin415•

I want to know what world you have to live in to think that more than doubling the minimum wage is "moderate". He's literally against a $12 minimum wage.

That's what makes crazy about all of this. I've read the studies, and to my knowlege the statement "There is solid empirical evidence showing that moderate increases in the minimum wage do not harm employment" is true; a hard case against Republicans. So when that argument is made to build a case for doubling the minimum wage I just think damn. Democrats could have won, but they got so greedy they lost all credibility.

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
adidasbdd•

$15 per hour is $600 per week or $2400 per month. That is less than $30,000 per year after taxes. A full time employee deserves to not live in poverty.

-13
WhyYouAreVeryWrong•

That's not poverty in many regions. I felt rich at $17/hr in Eastern Washington before I finished my education. (Bought a 3 bed house for $80k, rented out one room to a friend, had tons of money to spare.)

It's absolutely poverty in SF, Seattle, or NY. But in the midwest, eastern washington, western pennsylvania? $15/hr would be insanely good for an unskilled job.

The really ugly part is that $15/hr makes machines way more appealing.

30
adidasbdd•

I don't mean that 30k is poverty, I meant that 15K (current salary if you get full time hours at minimum wage) is. Also, do you really think that we are employing people today because we just need people working? If machines are more efficient and make sense financially, we should absolutely invest in mechanization. It is better for everyone. The ultimate goal is to be more efficient, not make up jobs for people, that is demeaning.

0†
WhyYouAreVeryWrong•

I don't mean that 30k is poverty, I meant that 15K (current salary if you get full time hours at minimum wage) is.

Oh, I'd agree with that. My example of Eastern Washington is at a $10 minimum wage, and it's an extremely low cost of living area, and it actually isn't a huge problem. I think $15/hr would be a massive disruption here and cause huge issues, but $10 works pretty well, so I can see a $10 minimum wage working federally.

Also, do you really think that we are employing people today because we just need people working? If machines are more efficient and make sense financially, we should absolutely invest in mechanization.

Yes and no.

The issue is that machines drive down human value in some markets. By forcing the cost of humans up, that just makes it so that in some markets people cost more to hire than they're worth, so machines become a better choice.

I agree with the general concept of more efficiency. In an ideal world, we'd replace half our jobs with machines in the next decade, and see similar reduction in prices, and people could work 20 or 30 hours a week instead of 40. Maybe a universal basic income that is the equivalent of 10-20 hours a week at minimum wage or something like that.

But in practice: (A) we're not there yet (B) our existing political systems would never allow that in the US

so the end result is, in our current climate, if we raise the minimum wage and it massively upticks mechanization, we'd just have a bunch of unemployed people on the streets.

The move to mechanization has to happen slowly, or it'll be very painful.

13
25ncblr•

15,000 a year is poverty where?

Cost of living matters in these discussions. I've lived as a student comfortably on 2000 USD a month in many places (including Scandinavia). Had extra to travel, eat out, drink, buy clothes, etc. Obviously if you have dependents it's a bit different.

I'd imagine Zurich on 2000 USD a month would be very rough, but I'm not sure the list is that big.

1
HelloAnnyong∂Economy/∂HumanAction is undefined•

A full time employee deserves to not live in poverty.

It is possible to agree with this statement but still worry that a $15/hour minimum wage would plunge more people into poverty than it would pull out of poverty.

18
adidasbdd•

It is good to worry about such things. It is also important to understand that 60 years ago that majority of women did not work. When we talk about unemployement, I don't know that it is possible to separate the people who are looking for work and the people who do not want/need to work. If we can be more efficient with less people working, we should do that. We shouldn't be wasting money of keeping people employed just because we need to fill employment quotas. We need meaningful progress, and if that is impossible, we need to address that issue.

3
HelloAnnyong∂Economy/∂HumanAction is undefined•

When we talk about unemployement, I don't know that it is possible to separate the people who are looking for work and the people who do not want/need to work.

Wat. Of course it's possible. This is why U3 and 1 – labour force participation rate are two different numbers. Unless I'm not parsing this sentence properly, it sounds like you're unaware of the difference.

When economists say a $15/hr minimum wage would probably increase unemployment among the people it's trying to help, they mean exactly that: it would increase the unemployment rate, i.e. the number of people who need jobs being unemployed. This is what unemployment means.

This doesn't address my point in the slightest, anyway.

11
kznlolpowerful but unloved•

A full time employee deserves to not live in poverty.

$30k a year isn't even close to poverty outside of possibly expensive cities like New York.

11
adidasbdd•

Read the down comments, that is not what I meant. You are reading it wrong

0†
JonnyRichterPrice floors don't real!•

$15 per hour is $600 per week or $2400 per month. That is less than $30,000 per year after taxes. A full time employee deserves to not live in poverty.

That's exactly what it sounds like you said, i.e. $30,000 is not that much money.

4
ComradeCash•

You do know that $30,000 per year, even before tax, is more then the median and average wage in most of Europe?

8
adidasbdd•

Sauce?

2
adidasbdd•

https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=AV_AN_WAGE - here is mine and I don't see it supporting your statement

2
ComradeCash•

Ups, sorry, I looked at the disposable income statistic. But it's still above the average income of many European nations.

4
flyingdragon8Retro Neoclassical Kanyesian•

A full time employee deserves to not live in poverty.

Nobody deserves to live in poverty. And MW is not the way to cure poverty.

6
Swordsknight12•

I'm pretty sure that if you are working full time you are getting benefits as well as the reality that cost of living is different across the country but what do I know.

1
derleth•

You're not full-time, you're 32 hours/week. See? You have a full eight hours a week to fit in a whole other job!

Of course you don't get benefits at 32 hours/week. Don't be stupid.

2
adidasbdd•

Ok- if you are working full time at 7.50 per hour. You are making $15,000 a year before taxes (you will likely get money back because you get paid so little) But you get benefits, so what is your point exactly?

1
JonnyRichterPrice floors don't real!•

Deserves has nothing to do with it. Many small businesses can't afford that but they need help or they literally can't be in business.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
adidasbdd•

Their current prices are based on costs and then they add in an acceptable amount of margin to afford to do business and make an acceptable profit. Costs go up, prices go up. The one thing if Bernie's plans become popular, employers will not pay nearly as much for employee healthcare. Larger companies have entire departments that handle healthcare related work that would no longer be necessary.

0
JonnyRichterPrice floors don't real!•

You live in a fantasy world. If businesses could just "raise their prices" they would already be doing it. If they raise their prices purely due to an increase in cost, their margins go down due to a decrease in sales. That's IF they're still able to sell enough to stay profitable.

The one thing if Bernie's plans become popular, employers will not pay nearly as much for employee healthcare

Do you know what sub you're in? This kind of dribble won't fly here.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
adidasbdd•

LOL- you are absolutely paying payroll taxes

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MyOnlyLifeAnimal Spirits•

Yes you do pay taxes at that level.

Source: That's how much I made first year out of college 4 years ago while living in Chicago. Also IRS.

3
miscsubsOP•

My first RI, guys, so please forgive and correct me for mistakes.

NY Times Editorial board joins the economically challenged crowd and calls Clinton to adopt the $15/hour minimum wage increase championed by Bernie Sanders.

There is no doubt, however, that the longer it takes to get to a new minimum, the higher it should be, and that by any political or practical calculation, 2022 is a long way off.

Well, there is doubt. This assumes an ever increasing standard of living and discounts things that affect a person's ability to purchase their basic needs. Hypothetically, what if healthcare is completely free by then? Should the minimum wage still increase? What if we find a never-ending energy source that is almost free? Should the minimum wage still increase? More realistically, what if we go into a deflationary cycle in 2020? Should minimum wage still increase?

Mrs. Clinton has argued that $15 might be too high for employers in low-wage states, causing them to lay off workers or make fewer hires. There is no proof for or against that position.

Without going into a million papers on either direction, this article states:

The D.C. Chamber of Commerce released a poll of business owners in which more than half of the respondents said they would cut jobs if the minimum wage rose to $15.

And that's in DC which is probably much better equipped to handle such a high minimum wage than most of the country. I mean shouldn't we be at least a bit concerned? Maybe the NYT Editorial board could have waited a year or two before endorsing the idea.

A $15 minimum wage would put the US on top of the minimum wage chart by PPP by about 20% over the current leader, San Marino with $12.55. This is a huge increase and will disproportionally affect some industries (restauranters to begin with) than others. I thought we were all for small businesses and mom-and-pop shops. Apparently, not at NYT HQ. Sure, for some monopsonies, the minimum wage would stick (although even that's contentious) and the monopsony would transfer the increased cost of labor to its customers and sharehol--- hahaha no they wouldn't transfer it to their shareholders who am I kidding.

We haven't even talked about automation, inflation, and disruption to the existing businesses yet.

And some words from people who know economics more than I do:

http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/papers/2014/06/19_hamilton_policies_addressing_poverty/state_local_minimum_wage_policy_dube.pdf

Also the comment history of u/besttrousers.

65
vShockAndAwevSupply don't real•

Agree with the rest of the post but I just want to point out that

The D.C. Chamber of Commerce released a poll of business owners in which more than half of the respondents said they would cut jobs if the minimum wage rose to $15.

is a conflict of interest (let's dispel with this fiction that a $15 minimum wage will be good for business by boosting demand) and therefore businesses have every incentive to say they will cut jobs whether they would actually do so or not. The Chamber of Commerce is a biased source, too.

71
wumbotarianArbitrageur in the rare pepe market•

Also stated preferences don't necessarily line up with revealed preference.

59
he3-1•

Does not prax.

  1. People act.
35
grevemoeskrPhysics 101 don't account for air. Hence, physics is bullshit•

Numbers? BURN THE HEATHEN!!!

14
brberg•

I have a theory, which I've made no effort whatsoever to verify, that many business owners actually believe this, because they look at their books and see that they have this much monthly profit, and the minimum wage hike will cost this much, and HOLY SHIT THAT'S LIKE HALF MY PROFIT. But they're not taking into account that they can raise prices because everyone else is in the same boat.

7
crunchdumpling•

If every business owner can raise wages because she'll be able to raise prices to compensate - aren't we back in the same situation where the minimum wage doesn't have enough purchasing power?

You should only raise the minimum wage if you think it will divert more profits to labor instead of management.

(IANAE, please correct me if this doesn't make sense)

8
WorldLeader•

Unless some people get higher wages and other people get let go, in which case the change in purchasing power of the community is sort of a wash.

2
TheLegendOfGoku•

But they're not taking into account that they can raise prices because everyone else is in the same boat.

That depends on the demand elasticity though, which isn't going to be same for every employer/business owner. Someone who serves primarily to low income workers may increase, in lieu of rise in min wage but someone who serves to an income category which hasn't witnessed a drastic wage increase may not be able to raise prices if the elasticity is more than unitary.

1
miscsubsOP•

I agree it's a conflict of interest and I didn't want to use that quote as evidence. It was more a statement of caution against the editorial board's assertion that there is no evidence for or against a much higher minimum wage, so well, let's go ahead with it anyway yolo!

10
black_ravenous•

(let's dispel with this fiction that a $15 minimum wage will be good for business by boosting demand

I see people talk about this demand boost all the time. Is there any source, no matter how terrible, that shows this is true? It's getting ridiculous how often it is repeated.

10
vShockAndAwevSupply don't real•

It's just plain old vulgar Keynesianism. Just pretend that this money is just being stored under business' mattresses rather than being utilized, pretend the Fed won't react if AD picked up substantially, pretend that even if both were the case that it wouldn't negate the growth impacts through higher inflation (in the same way printing money when the economy is operating at or near full capacity doesn't boost RGDP growth for much time), etc.

It's a very intuitive way of thinking about the economy that is perpetuated by shitty news reporting (GDP growth due to consumer spending, consumer spending generates 70% of the economy rather than 70% of the economy being used for consumer spending) and politicians.

11
LowlifePiano•

I'm having a lot of trouble figuring out how an upward supply shock boosts demand. Is the logic behind it that people will have more money, therefore they'll spend more and boost business? Because even the most Keynesian economist out there won't argue that prices are that sticky.

8
black_ravenous•

The logic is that low-income households have a larger marginal propensity to consume. So when we give John Poor $1, he spends all of it and it cycles through the economy. When we get Bob Rich $1, he only spends $.10 and "hoards" the rest.

Obviously, there are a lot of issues with this model, but that's generally how I see people describe the mechanism.

16
HelloAnnyong∂Economy/∂HumanAction is undefined•

Is there an error in this reasoning? IANAE. But I'm trying to understand the strongest case for this idea. Although I don't think many people have a model in mind when they put this idea forward...

Say employers have price-setting power. Then a minimum wage increase could increase employment (if not set too high). Wages and employment would increase, which would increase demand for the good produced? If the increase is high enough, the resulting increase in price might even be greater than the height of the supply shift.

1
ExUnoPlures•

let's dispel with this fiction that a $15 minimum wage will be good for business by boosting demand

It doesn't? Oh.

5
xaquiBmostly lurks•

Apparently "let's dispel with this fiction" is the freshest new meme on BadEcon

4

For some businesses it won't, yet the new minimum wage will impact them all.

1
Trepur349TPP $hill•

Great R1.

Only thing I'd ad is further emphasis on this point:

And that's in DC which is probably much better equipped to handle such a high minimum wage than most of the country.

per the brookings institute article you mentioned, DC would be the city in America best equipped to handle a high minimum wage. So much better probably understates this.

Congrats on the good R1.

14
besttrousers"Then again, I have pegged you for a Neoclassical/Austrian."•

Great R1!

10
wumbotarianArbitrageur in the rare pepe market•

Under both proposals, the increase would be phased in over five years, which means 2022 at the earliest, assuming that legislation to raise the minimum becomes law in 2017, the first year of the next president’s term.

Because all the social planners know the market clearing wage for 2015 is actually the wage we will have in 2022.

This phase in is absolutely stupid. It's bad enough that $15 (why not $15.01? Why not $14.99? Or, since we think in whole numbers, not $16 or $14?) is pulled out of people's asses so why do these idiots want to phase in price controls? How does that make it better?

There is no proof for or against that position. There is solid empirical evidence showing that moderate increases in the minimum wage do not harm employment.

Just because past empirical work doesn't strongly support the classic hypothesis of disemployment in the face of small minimum wage increases doesn't mean a new minimum wage (especially more than doubling the federal minimum wage) won't either.

Where's your structural model? If only we had a name for a critique of using past correlations to predict the outcome of economic policy without taking into consideration the changes in behavior given that new policy...

Historically, a robust minimum is one that equals at least half the average wage for typical workers, recently $21 an hour.

~~What does this even mean? So we need a minimum wage roughly equivalent to the average hourly wage (which is, IIRC, $24/hr)?

Why? How do you know? How will this not have disemployment effects? A minimum wage of $21/hr is $43,680/yr (40 hr work weeks @ 52 weeks a year).

This is about the same as the average salary of an undergraduate with an economics degree.

So a "robust" minimum wage is equating the productivity of a 16 yr old with that of a college graduate.~~

Misread this. NYT says we should have $10.50/hr minimum wage given their number.

Worse, Mrs. Clinton’s stance misses the big picture, which is that the risk in keeping the minimum too low is bigger than the risk of raising it too high. 

You heard it from the well off editorial board at the NY Times: no income is better than some income; unemployment is better than employment.

One reason a third of Americans today live in or near poverty is that many jobs in the United States do not pay enough to live on.

"The reason people are poor is because they don't make enough money to not be considered poor."

Tautologies are tautological.

Economic obstacles are not standing in the way of a $15-an-hour minimum wage. 

Supply and demand don't real.

50
Tertullianitis•

Historically, a robust minimum is one that equals at least half the average wage for typical workers, recently $21 an hour.

This just kills me. "Based on historical precedent, the current minimum wage should be about $10.50. So we should all just get on board with making it $15.00! That's only 43% higher. No big deal right?"

33
130911256MAN•

I think we are all under the impression that with a strike of a pen, the minimum wage will be changed to $15. The truth is that the $15 target will take 5 years of gradual increases to be reached. By then, the NYT argues, businesses have had enough time to adjust.

1
TokyoJokeyo•

But why can't we just call it $10.50 today and tie it to inflation, and still phase it in over five years if you want? It's ridiculous to not only pull a number out of thin air, but then pin that number to five years from now and assume inflation (surely predictable!) will smooth things out.

10
DrSandbagsDow Jones Propaganda Index•

Nothing in that article suggests they want a minimum wage equal to the current average wage.

15
wumbotarianArbitrageur in the rare pepe market•

The "robust minimum wage" stood out to me. I don't know what it means, aside from saying "this is the minimum wage we ought to be at" but concede $15 is a better federal goal.

Honestly maybe that was a red herring. But it was there.

6
Fenris_uy•

Historically, a robust minimum is one that equals at least half the average wage for typical workers, recently $21 an hour.

Why are you ignoring the "at least half" part? If current average wage is $24 a robust minimum is everything that is $12 or higher by that definition. But that doesn't imply that they have to be equal.

14
wumbotarianArbitrageur in the rare pepe market•

Holy poop, i misread that.

It would be about $10.50/hr using that number. $12/hr is half of $24/hr which is what I know of.

Completely misread that, my bad.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
jazzninja88•

To be clear, I definitely don't agree with a $15 federal minimum wage. But I do agree that any increase ought to be phased in over a period of time depending on the size of the increase, not for market clearing purposes but for the sake of smoothing the shock.

Do you disagree?

11
wumbotarianArbitrageur in the rare pepe market•

I absolutely disagree.

If we someone cook up that the PC market clearing wage for 2016 is $15/hr then setting the minimum wage to $15/hr tomorrow should have no disemployment effects.

Phasing it in means you won't be hitting the market clearing wage for 2016 until 20XX. How do you know the market clearing wage for 20XX will be the same for 2016?

Furthermore you're implicitly admitting that whatever minimum wage you want will have adverse affects if you think we need to "smooth out the shock".

21
jazzninja88•

Any policy change constitutes a shock, and when shocks can be smoothed over time, they are easier for people to deal with. For instance, even a removal of the minimum wage would cause uncertainty for employers for whom it is binding. Even in that case, I'd argue phasing in would be better.

Also, you went back to this whole idea of market clearing, which I said was not an argument for phasing since a minimum wage is obviously not meant to clear markets.

19
wumbotarianArbitrageur in the rare pepe market•

Any policy change constitutes a shock, and when shocks can be smoothed over time, they are easier for people to deal with.

Yes but that shock need not be negative.

For instance, even a removal of the minimum wage would cause uncertainty for employers for whom it is binding.

Huh?

Even in that case, I'd argue phasing in would be better.

I mean, I could see a relatively short term price control phase in, say, 6 months. Not 6 years.

Also, you went back to this whole idea of market clearing, which I said was not an argument for phasing since a minimum wage is obviously not meant to clear markets.

Monopsony models tells us otherwise

(Labor-search doesn't, but no one really makes that argument here)

11
[deleted]•

Maybe it is clearing in some markets where a monospony exists.

3
mjucftThe communist daughter•

There are fixed costs in the short run -- the long-run average cost curve is below the short run average cost curve. By phasing it in the firms are able to adjust capital accordingly.

Solve a short run profit maximisation problem, then solve it in the long run. There's a difference in labor demand.

9
wumbotarianArbitrageur in the rare pepe market•

That's definitely true, I hadn't taken that into consideration. But I don't think 6 years is a good idea either.

If we really want to rely on monopsony models then we should focus on the market clearing wage for t, not try to guess t+6.

6
130911256MAN•

You are talking to someone who is fairly right-wing. Of course he's going to disagree.

-1
wumbotarianArbitrageur in the rare pepe market•

Wouldn't a right winger want a long phase in period?

3
vShockAndAwevSupply don't real•

Worse, Mrs. Clinton’s stance misses the big picture, which is that the risk in keeping the minimum too low is bigger than the risk of raising it too high.

Yeah, pricing low skilled people out of the labor market and denying their ability to obtain more skills and experience necessary to advance in the job market (college aside) is a pretty big deal. This is why I'd like to keep minimum wages somewhat lower than where Dube recommends.

11
Ludendorff•

Fuck it, put it where Dube recommends, but don't put it at $15.

1
Hk37Supporter of the jelly bean standard•

I think they're saying that people don't have enough to live on because they can't get a good-paying job, not because they're lazy or they waste all their money on luxuries. It's basically a rejection of the, "they can't be that poor, they have fridges and Internet!" argument that gets bandied about by some political conservatives.

4
besttrousers"Then again, I have pegged you for a Neoclassical/Austrian."•

Where's your structural model?

Diamond-Mortensen-Pissarides?

3
wumbotarianArbitrageur in the rare pepe market•

DMP shows that the market clearing wage is always half the median (average?) wage?

6
besttrousers"Then again, I have pegged you for a Neoclassical/Austrian."•

I'm sure it can with the right calibration ;)

5
wumbotarianArbitrageur in the rare pepe market•

Alright now Kydland-Prescott

5
Trepur349TPP $hill•

why do these idiots want to phase in price controls? How does that make it better?

I'd argue that advantage of phasing in the effects is it gives businesses more time to adjust.

3
vShockAndAwevSupply don't real•

There's a difference between giving businesses an adjustment period in order to mitigate menu costs, and an incremental phase in, which would obscure disemployment effects.

6
Trepur349TPP $hill•

But wouldn't phasing it in allow businesses to raise prises simultaneous to the rise in wages? Rather then the shock of having a large increase in both simultaneously?

I could be mistaken, I'm not an expert.

2
mjucftThe communist daughter•

I believe the following three things:

  1. $15 minimum wage will have substantial disemployment effects

  2. Higher minimum wage would cause the long run AS curve to shift in

  3. The minimum wage should be $15.

These beliefs are not contradictory. The NYT is stating 3 and claiming that there is a high degree of uncertainty regarding 1 & 2. It's all perfectly reasonable.

24
besttrousers"Then again, I have pegged you for a Neoclassical/Austrian."•

The minimum wage should be $15.

Given #1, doesn't it make more sense to push for policies that would increase earnings without a disemployment effect?

I agree that getting everyone should earn at least $15 is a worth goal. However, I think that increased funding for education and subsidies, combined with a moderate minimum wage, is the way to go.

25
mjucftThe communist daughter•

Sure. I support $15 ceteris paribus.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
delazeur6•

But why $15 and not $12? Why $15 and not $20?

I don't really understand why minimum wage should be scaled to "living wage" when cost of living varies so much regionally. The purpose of minimum wages is to protect workers against monopsistic employers.

It's particularly interesting to me that the calls for $15/hr come from the far left, when I would expect the far left to be more interested in dissociating the ability to feed/house/clothe oneself from full-time employment.

8
mjucftThe communist daughter•

But why $15 and not $12? Why $15 and not $20?

15 seems to be what we are coordinating on. We could play the "why not $0.01 plus or minus?" game for every government policy.

4
AveTerran•

The purpose of minimum wages is to protect workers against monopsistic employers.

I don't know about the truth of this, but I've seen it repeated (here, for example) that the minimum wage was instituted as labor protectionism, not from monopolies, but from lower-wage workers.

3
delazeur6•

That's interesting, although monopsony is part of the reason employees would be threatened by lower-wage workers.

In any case, I should have written that the purpose of minimum wages should be to protect workers against monopsistic employers.

3
ThereIsReallyNoPunMy internet works with long and variable lags•

RELEVANT FLAIR!!!11!

6
flyingdragon8Retro Neoclassical Kanyesian•

EITC + NIT !!!!!!!

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MonkRome•

$15 minimum wage will have substantial disemployment effects

There are several studies that show that it would not be substantial at all, as long as the increase is graduated over time and not unreasonably fast. It would have an impact, but it would be a minor fractional impact, compared to the benefit. You would have to raise the minimum wage to an unreasonable amount to cause significant unemployment (raising it to $30 would certainly have a huge impact). When the country does institute an increase it is graduated over time minimizing much of the impact to nearly nothing. Yes if you went to $15 from $7.25 without stepping up it would have an impact, but that is not what we do.

the minimum wage has little or no discernible effect on the employment prospects of low-wage workers. The most likely reason for this outcome is that the cost shock of the minimum wage is small relative to most firms' overall costs and only modest relative to the wages paid to low-wage workers.

http://www.integrityflorida.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Minimum-Wage-Policy-and-the-Resulting-Effect-on-Employment-final-.pdf

http://www.nelp.org/content/uploads/City-Minimum-Wage-Laws-Recent-Trends-Economic-Evidence.pdf

http://s4.epi.org/files/2015/we-can-afford-a-12-federal-minimum-wage.pdf

http://www.iie.com/publications/briefings/piieb15-2.pdf

http://blogs.piie.com/realtime/?p=4700

http://s2.epi.org/files/2014/importance-study-design-minimum-wage-debate-final.pdf

http://cepr.net/blogs/cepr-blog/update-13-states-that-raised-minimum-wage

http://cepr.net/blogs/cepr-blog/states-that-raised-their-minimumwage-in-2014-had-stronger-job-growth-than-those-that-didnt

I'll stop here but there are a few dozen other studies I know of that handle this issue that I would be happy to provide if you are interested.

-4†
vShockAndAwevSupply don't real•

Newsflash: Far-left think tanks advocate far-left position.

I clicked on two of those links and immediately saw issues. The first states that there is plenty of evidence minimum wage has no disemployment effects. An actual fair representation of the literature is that moderate minimum wage increases lead to very little, perhaps statistically insignificant disemployment effects.

Another one stated we can afford a $12 minimum wage by 2020. Considering we're talking about a $15 minimum wage, and perhaps sooner than 2020, I don't think that's relevant to the point.

16
wumbotarianArbitrageur in the rare pepe market•

It's ironic because monkrome is replying to one of our lefty members.

6
MonkRome•

Sure, my point was not to say it does not exist, just that impact is minimal. I'm too busy to peel through the research today, getting ready to travel and finishing some stuff up at work. But from what I recall an incremental increase in minimum wage from $7.25 to $15 over a 7 year period is likely to cause something like a 1/10 of a percent - 3/10 of a percent impact on unemployment over that whole period. Hardly something to worry about, especially since capitalistic economies adjust well over time. It would be a bigger problem if we did it abruptly.

0†
vShockAndAwevSupply don't real•

If the unemployment rate shot up .3% from a minimum wage increase, that would be pretty damn significant considering ~4% of the labor force is paid minimum wage. And I'm rather skeptical of your sources given that you cite groups like the EPI which are notorious for lying with statistics.

But anyway, I'd really look at Dube's estimates as near the upper-bound given that he's substantially pro-MW and I'm incredibly concerned the people hurt by it are the ones who need an income/job experience. Considering he doesn't advocate for a $15 anywhere in his cost-benefit analysis, the chance of $15 being the right number nationwide (think how it would impact rural Alabama, Puerto Rico, etc) is virtually zero.

7
duuuh•

Let's go with 0.3% and do some back of the envelope math.

There are about 120 million people employed in the US, so an increase of 0.3% in the unemployment rate is about 360,000 extra people out of work.

There are about 3 million people making minimum wage. Since the extra unemployed will come from those people, the conclusion is that if you're making minimum wage, the increased minimum wage will result in a ~12% chance that you're going to lose your job.

Does that still sound so good?

5
DrSandbagsDow Jones Propaganda Index•

Today, 21 states still do not have minimums higher than the federal level, and of the 29 that do, none have minimums high enough to cover local living expenses for an individual worker.

That's a faulty premise. The average family income of a minimum wage earner above the age of 24 is double the poverty line. And if one is a single earning MW earner, there are a multitude of government assistance programs that are less distortionary to the labor market and whose burden is shouldered much less by the poor (progressive taxation vs. raising store prices).

21
[deleted]•

The average family income of a minimum wage earner above the age of 24 is double the poverty line.

Got a source for that?

4
DrSandbagsDow Jones Propaganda Index•
9
OmegaSeven•

Isn't this more of an issue with the poverty line being a useless and out of date metric?

14
vShockAndAwevSupply don't real•

Or that most minimum wage earners aren't their household's source of primary income, which is one of the many reasons economists would prefer a more targeted approach to dealing with workers in poverty over a minimum wage hike.

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

What do the r/badeconomics people think about the idea that many minimum wage job holders are employed by a monospony (or a cartel of employers acting like a monospony) and that existing wages aren't market clearing? A minimum wage increase should reduce the market power of these monosponies and increase output as wages are closer to equilibrium.

18
besttrousers"Then again, I have pegged you for a Neoclassical/Austrian."•

That's the best argument for a minimum wage.

16
miscsubsOP•

Page 7 and 8.

The industries that employ MW employees seem to be fairly diverse. Moreover, even if the industry is not diverse, the function the MW employee does might not be specific to the industry (i.e. office admins).

Also just because an employer is a monopsony doesn't mean they will accept the MW increase without going to automation or just cutting labor and distributing the work to the other employees.

With a modest increase, you're probably right but where the cutoff is -- I don't know how you determine that.

14
besttrousers"Then again, I have pegged you for a Neoclassical/Austrian."•

The industries that employ MW employees seem to be fairly diverse. Moreover, even if the industry is not diverse, the function the MW employee does might not be specific to the industry (i.e. office admins).

Furman and Orszag have some interesting work showing it might be due to firm level rents: https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/page/files/20151016_firm_level_perspective_on_role_of_rents_in_inequality.pdf

12
vShockAndAwevSupply don't real•

I don't think the literature supports that position, we should see employment growth with modest minimum wage hikes if that was the case, yet the vast majority of studies show no or slight negative effects. Inelastic supply/demand is therefore, IMO, the most useful way to model the impacts of minimum wage increases, at least at a state or federal level.

9
besttrousers"Then again, I have pegged you for a Neoclassical/Austrian."•

Inelastic supply/demand is therefore, IMO, the most useful way to model the impacts of minimum wage increases, at least at a state or federal level.

How do you reconcile this with the data on immigration shocks?

8
vShockAndAwevSupply don't real•

Good point, hadn't thought of that tbh. Now I'm just confused.

8
besttrousers"Then again, I have pegged you for a Neoclassical/Austrian."•

The way I reconcile them is to assume that there are some monopsonistic firms and some competitive firms in the economy, such that there's no substantial aggregate change in employment numbers in response to small MW increases.

6
KennanFrenchPursuing a made-up degree in space economics•

"Monosponies" has got to be the most adorable typo ever

8
SubotanGender Gap Guru•

yaaas queen yaas

4
SnapshillBotPaid for by The Free Market™•

Snapshots:

  1. This Post - 1, 2

^(I am a bot.) ^(Info ^/ ^Contact)

2
futileses•

This is why we can't have nice things!

0
Paul_Benjamin•

Isn't a nominal minimum wage just asking to be inflated away?

Indexing, even at a rate of <1 x CPI, seems required for this to not be political lipservice.

Never mentioned is how much unions benefit from higher minimum wages. People stay in jobs longer and are more worried about losing their 'good job', both key factors when deciding to allow someone to gouge your pay packet. It's as if they've bought a candidate or something...

-2