[Spoilers] I can't help but feel dissatisfied by Au Hasard Balthazar (1966)
I trust that some of you guys are big fans of this movie and would like to enlighten me about it
So lately I've been trying to slowly make my way through most of Sight and Sound's most recent top 50 films list, and for the most part I understand the films' acclaim. Many of the ones I've seen so far are now among my favorite movies, and most others that I didn't enjoy as much (Passion of Joan of Arc, Man With a Movie Camera, The Rules of the Game, Battleship Potemkin et al.) are clearly impactful and/or meaningful movies.
So tonight I popped in Au Hasard Balthazar and I'm somewhat disappointed in how disconnected I felt from the film. I'll start off by noting that I'm not a Christian, which may have contributed to my disconnect. I also have seen no other Bresson movies before this one. It appeared to me that in this particular movie, Bresson made efforts to draw as little emotion out of his actors as possible. The camerawork was rather bland, which also seemed intentional. There wasn't much dialogue, and when there was it tended to be relatively uninteresting (unless I missed something). For these reasons and others, I came to the conclusion that Au Hasard Balthazar's main goal was to convey a type of spiritual or philosophical message.
But what message am I missing? Balthazar was surrounded by extremely flawed humans for his entire life, up until the day he eventually kneels down in a field and dies in (relative) peace. The screentime is almost entirely dedicated to these humans demonstrating their flaws to the audience.
What is the idea behind Bresson's movie? Is he saying mankind has a tendency to hurt innocent things like Marie and Balthazar? Were there deep biblical comparisons demonstrated in the movie that I am ignorant of? Any input would be greatly appreciated.
Posted Feb 19, 2016, 8:09 AM UTC
I'll treat this as a CMV, but since you haven't posted it there I'll add the caveat that I don't really like to tell people to change their opinion - the best anyone can hope for is that you may, in a few months, give it another go and try again.
With some filmmakers or writers or performers, when something different is done it can often seem lacklustre at first. I've felt the same way about Fellini, Bunuel, Bergman, Kieslowski and any number of writers on first try. They don't meet your traditional criteria, so you have to rethink how you approach the medium. Often once you've done so, when you return to them the full impact of the work hits you. I'm not saying that's necessarily what happened to you here, but it may be the case.
Bresson's approach to directing actors was to get extremely naturalistic performances. To those accustomed to more showy performances, this can seem a little blasé at first. From Ebert's review of AHB:
Bresson's most intriguing limitation is to forbid his actors to act. He was known to shoot the same shot 10, 20, even 50 times, until all "acting" was drained from it, and the actors were simply performing the physical actions and speaking the words. There was no room in his cinema for De Niro or Penn. It might seem that the result would be a movie filled with zombies, but quite the contrary: By simplifying performance to the action and the word without permitting inflection or style, Bresson achieves a kind of purity that makes his movies remarkably emotional. The actors portray lives without informing us how to feel about them; forced to decide for ourselves how to feel, forced to empathize, we often have stronger feelings than if the actors were feeling them for us.
He continues:
Given this philosophy, a donkey becomes the perfect Bresson character. Balthazar makes no attempt to communicate its emotions to us, and it comunicates its physical feelings only in universal terms: Covered with snow, it is cold. Its tail set afire, it is frightened. Eating its dinner, it is content. Overworked, it is exhausted. Returning home, it is relieved to find a familiar place. Although some humans are kind to it and others are cruel, the motives of humans are beyond its understanding, and it accepts what they do because it must.
I think if you view the film in terms of its imposed limitations, and allow the natural emotion (not the forced emotion of a John Williams score, or a big James Cagney performance) to come through, the film's power will shine through.
Again, I've felt disappointed as you have with great works felt frequently. I've been blown away by Tolstoy's Anna Karenina and shrugged my shoulders at Chekhov's best short stories. The latter, however, I now regard as some of the best literature ever written. Part of that is on me - my life experiences, my approach to the work, my artistic sensibilities.
I fully agree that perhaps I've come across Bresson at the wrong time in my life. The inherent evils of humanity that he demonstrated in Balthazar, luckily for me, didn't seem realistic to my worldview.
I'll have to chalk it up as a movie I'll revisit at some point in the future. I'm sure I'm also being unfair to it, being that I was introduced to it through a "Great Films List" that undoubtedly sets an unfair expectation. I also went in expecting something different, being that this is a 1960s French film, much like Breathless which I very much enjoyed for its style and attitude. It might be a bit of a ham-fisted analogy, but I think I went in expecting a Cormac McCarthy and instead got a Nietzsche.
You should definitely let some time pass (I'd suggest a year) and then revisit it. On second viewing, I suspect you'll either discover (a) it resonates for you and you'll better appreciate the film's strengths, or (b) you'll have the same problems, but will hopefully better understand why you think it's not the masterpiece it claims to be.
I'm always fascinated by Ebert's change of heart regarding La Dolce Vita, largely because at first it didn't quite work for me but now I regard it as my favourite film.
Initial: http://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/la-dolce-vita
Retrospective: http://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/great-movie-la-dolce-vita-1960
I do myself love me some Gooseberries :x