PSP-1001 Analog Cap Replacement - Mixed results
Hey guys, I just wanted to follow up on the post by u/spentthedayonreddit (https://www.reddit.com/r/3DS/comments/44spty/i_replaced_my_cstick_with_a_psp_analog_stick/) and share my experience with replacing the rubber c-nub with the PSP-1000 analog cap. Like many of you I love my N3DSXL, but can’t stand the rubbery nub. However, after doing the swap I didn’t like it and went back to the original nub. I’m making this post because a lot of you are just ripping your nub out, which does damage it, and you may not like the final result.
First off, there is no need to rip out the nub. I personally wouldn’t rip something out without knowing I wanted it to be permanent. I followed this guide: https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Nintendo+3DS+XL+2015+ABXY+Start+or+Select+Button+Replacement/41074 It was really easy and only required removing 11 screws. Stop at step 8!! After that you just need to remove the three screws holding the nub in there. It comes out easily without ripping anything and you can easily put the nub back without damage.
On to the swap… I tried it with 3 different PSP caps and all the results were pretty much the same. I bought the same PSP caps that OP bought (https://www.reddit.com/r/3DS/comments/44spty/i_replaced_my_cstick_with_a_psp_analog_stick/czsmirq). First, the shape of the nub rest on the 3DS doesn’t exactly match the shape of analog stick setting. So, you might have to set it at an angle. I think OP set his at a 45 degree angle. Others have done it parallel with the 3DS (https://www.reddit.com/r/3DS/comments/44spty/i_replaced_my_cstick_with_a_psp_analog_stick/czsyx45). You can tell based on the texture on top, which make either a diamond or square shape. http://imgur.com/hbq69Dc I tried it with different caps at 45 deg, parallel, and in between. Every time the ridges on the inside of the cap (shown in red) deformed to fit on the 3DS. More importantly though, in all cases I found the cap had significant wobble in the direction of the long end of the PSP cap. When it was set at 45 degrees, the wobble was way less, but still noticeable. Here’s a video from that angle. https://youtu.be/OXtYqFEB5rw The problem persisted even after I filed down the ridges to make the cap sit as flush as possible. I think this is because of the curved shape of the 3DS setting (http://imgur.com/bGtqAyL) For some people, this won’t be an issue. I tend to be a perfectionist and it really bothered me. It also made smooth diagonal movements much harder e.g. aiming in Resident Evil. Finally, when the cap was parallel it did make contact with the upper screen when it was closed, but not when it was at 45 degrees. There wasn’t a lot of pressure, but I’d be worried about long term effects.
Finally I just wanted to say this isn’t meant to be a knock on u/spenthedayonreddit’s post. What he did was awesome and I’d love to see more like it! It's meant to say I didn’t have the same results and also for others to share their success/failure. And for people unsure about doing this, it might be helpful to have an idea of the success rate, because for all I know, it might just come down to Chinese quality control.
TLDR: the PSP cap sounds great in theory, but in practice it didn’t work out that well.
Posted Feb 23, 2016, 7:45 PM UTC
I've done the mod on both a n3DS and n3DS XL with great success. Used the Insten PSP 1000 cap in black. I play like 3-4 hours of MH4U daily and it's infinitely better than the nub it has replaced. I'm pretty sure that the people having wobble issues just aren't seating the cap properly. If you look on the flipside of the PSP cap there is a small track to align the cap properly. Or at least my caps have it.
I don't think it's an alignment problem, because I tried various ways. The seat of the nub looks kind of like a diamond on top of a circle. When you set yours in, did the tracks follow the sides of the diamond or the points? It's kind of hard to explain, but I tried with the parallel vs 45 degree thing. http://imgur.com/Z9iatoy
Mine wobbles pretty heavily as well, I use the 45° angle in your picture. It makes the too look like a bunch of diamonds.
hey man not to undermine your predicament, but I just wanted to let you know that (from your video with the wobble) mine does not have that MUCH movement... that is a pretty crazy amount of movement.
Mine does tilt ever so slightly, but its not near that much... I find it interesting the vastly different experience between people getting the same exact PSP nubs on the same N3DS systems is happening.
I'm glad it worked for you! I was able to get the wobble down by more than half after I filed down the ridges on the inside, but then the cap didn't stay on as tightly. It seems like most people at least have very small amounts of wobble. I'm too picky and was hoping for none at all.
Would you mind sharing the link for where you got your cap from? It might be helpful to others wanting to do it. I suspect that there's quite a bit of variation in the manufacturing. Also, if you set yours at 45 deg or parallel.
Ya sure! I got it from Amazon and I have it set at 45*
Truthfully this could just be batch by batch variations of the same product. Products can change drastically depending on the lot they are from. This likely isn't a problem for the psp and works within the psp's specifications. For the n3ds, however these minor differences could be drastic. I would try getting the same product again but from a different source.