What is the optimal voter turnout?

That might sound like a somewhat wired question, but I wonder, if any research has been done on that topic.

I mean, although newspapers usually ask for higher turnouts, I'm pretty sure that 100% voter turnout is not the social optimum.

Considering the opportunity costs of going to vote (i.e. what else you could have done during that time instead) and the diminishing marginal utility of each voter (e.g. the odds of 11, but not 10 votes resulting in the overall favourite candidate getting elected are far higher then the odds of 1001, but not 1000 votes resulting in the favourite candidate getting elected and the difference in democratic justification of a state with 11% vs 1% turnout being bigger then the difference of a state with 90% vs 80%), I'd expect far less then 100% voter turnout to be optimal.

Does anyone know of any good papers on that topic?

Posted Feb 24, 2016, 3:57 PM UTC

07
aintnevercomingdown•

I think you are overthinking this. The optimal voter turnout would be 100% of eligible citizens, because the aim of democracy is for the government to reflect the wants of people.

3
ComradeCashOP•

But far less then 100% are enough to give a relatively good reflection of what the people want and the question is, if you really also need the rest of the people to go to vote, or if it would be better to have them do different things (working, enjoying themselves, ...) instead.

1
aintnevercomingdown•

I see what you're getting at, but it just doesn't make sense. You've kind of answered your own question here -- even if you are able to get a 'relatively good' reflection, that is not (by definition) 'optimal'. Its 'relatively good'. 100% voter turnout is optimal; that is the answer to your question.

2
ComradeCashOP•

100% would be optimal, if you view democracy as the highest goal of all. If you treat democracy as only means to an end, other values will probably do better and that's what I'm thinking about.

1
TheAcidKing•

If i understand correctly, you are asking if there is a percent of the population that is most likely to deliver the most informed vote.

This is a question that is impossible to answer in the form that you pose it because it relies on knowing what percent of the pop will make an informed decision and what percent won't in addition to how likely each of those groups is to vote. That data would be near impossible to obtain. The short answer is the optimal turnout is 100%.

This is for two big reasons. First of all this is how collective action works. Most Americans for example agree on many more questions than our polarized political climate let on. The problem is that very few people vote or get involved so their completely reasonable views do not get expressed by the gov't. The second reason is uninformed voters tend to be much more active voters because misinformation can really fire up an uninformed population.

Sorry if I've been too specific towards the US but its what I know.

1
ComradeCashOP•

I'm sorry, if I expressed myself unclearly, but I'm not asking for a turnout that is more likely to deliver a more informed vote, but one that maximizes total welfare, by trading some accuracy in representation for increasing productivity by having some persons doing other things instead during the time frame that would otherwise be used for voting.

I'd guess the most difficult part here is assigning an accurate value to accuracy of representation.

1
limited-papertrail•

I think the optimal voter turnout is that which produces the optimal outcomes over a sufficiently long timeframe.

If we could run history in simulation and see every branch of the tree over a thousand years, optimal turnout might be 1 person per election (that person voting for the correct candidate according to our simluation).

But we can't do that.
In which case I think somewhere >90% is optimal. I think the opportunity cost of voting in general elections is more than made up for by the psychological investment in democracy that people receive from the action.

And I think that distributing vote access and weight evenly among all people regardless of age, IQ, education, religion, etc, is the safest and most effective way to achieve the best outcomes that we currently have.

(in fact, I strongly support removing all age restrictions, and "crime restrictions," and registration-laws from voting to further this cause of egalitarian democracy).

In party primaries however, I don't think that all votes should be necessarily weighted the same. I think the closed caucus system is a good way of making sure that party activists have the largest impact (they are the people who have actually formed the party!).

So I think the ideal turnout for general elections is different than for primary elections. Optimal turnout in general elections should be >90% of the US population, and in primary elections it would be maybe 10% - 50%, depending on the election and candidates.

1