r/DIY•
thinkmcfly

Need help - how do I properly fix this subfloor?

help

So when we bought our house 2 years ago, we noticed a weird spot in the middle of one of the rooms. Stupidly, we did not think much of it at the time. It's gotten worse over the past year, and my wife wanted me to fix it before turning the into a nursery. So today, I tore up the carpet and found this ...

http://imgur.com/a/MYPBt

It looks like the previous owners had a chandelier put in the dining room (or did it themselves), and instead of needing repairing drywall decided it was a great idea to cut through the subfloor of the upstairs bedroom. They used 2x4s to put a "cheater" board in to fill in the hole with a scrap piece of 3/4" plywood. One of the 2x4s failed, and looks like it everything was being held up by a diverter for the HVAC return (the sheet metal shown). That's now destroyed and will need to be fixed as well.

So, my question is - how do I fix this right? I'm thinking the only correct, safe was of doing this is replacing a large enough section of the subfloor so it spans across the floor joists.

Posted Feb 27, 2016, 4:02 PM UTC

1612
ChrisSlicks•

I'm thinking the only correct, safe was of doing this is replacing a large enough section of the subfloor so it spans across the floor joists.

Correct. I would pull back the carpet entirely to see what you can work with. It might be easiest to replace the entire sheet of plywood if it minimizes the number of cuts you have to make.

Is the sub-floor a single layer of 3/4" ?

3
thinkmcflyOP•

Is the sub-floor a single layer of 3/4" ?

Yes

2
PhazeChange•

Super easy and that stuff is dirt cheap. If you do need a cut and don't have the tools, where you buy from will likely cut for you if necessary if you bring the measurements.

3
thinkmcflyOP•

Yeah, I have all the tools. Not really worry about the cost or effort - I've replaced a water damaged subfloor in a bathroom before so I know what I'm getting myself into. Just want to make sure that what I'm doing isn't overkill.

1
dedcakes•

I personally think this is the easier route than patching with 2x4s from underneath. I've done this after finding holes patched with tin sheets under carpet and old wood floors.

1
plywooden•

I would just do the same fix as previous owners but use 2" screws, not nails, and use as long a 2x4 as you can get in the hole and center it under the hole.

I have been doing remodeling and repairs for 17 ys.

1
thinkmcflyOP•

The problem is I'm going to have to make the hole bigger to be able to repair the diverter.

2
plywooden•

Oh, I see. You could try to cut the subfloor back to the center line of the joists on both sides of the hole, then add 2" x ? boards in between existing joists to support the unsupported edges of the new subfloor piece.

I hope that makes sense.

3
thinkmcflyOP•

Yeah, that's what I'm thinking - similar to step 6 here: http://www.diyonline.com/servlet/GIB_BaseT/diylib_article.html?session.docid=851

1
ajdabbs•

Sounds like you have a solid head on your shoulders seems whatever fix you come up with will be far better than the previous

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
thinkmcflyOP•

I am going to double-check it, especially considering there is duct tape (!?) on the box.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
all_american_stout•

looks like a great spot for a hidden safe!

1