Prediction Thread - A Conclusion of Sorts

#The Summary

Hey everyone, I have some news that some of you may be disappointed to hear - though I assure you that the feeling is mutual. Regretfully, u/TheKandyCinema and I have made the decision to shut down the prediction threads prematurely this season. I am sorry.

#The History

As many of you know, I started running these threads last year to pass the time when I had too much of it to spare. It was a fun project that ballooned into something unexpectedly popular - it was a great experience and I had the opportunity to interact with many of you in the process which made it very rewarding. This season, I had a lot less time on my hands thanks to a new job in my field, and was fortunate enough to to recruit the services of u/TheKandyCinema to shoulder some of the load and importantly to set up the google surveys. Without him, I would not have been able to run it at all.

Unfortunately (well...fortunately if I'm honest) my job has become increasingly demanding, and every time I have said "I'm sure it will calm down after this next deadline!" I've been wrong and I foresee it worsening from here. Sufficed to say, I no longer have time to run these threads nor post results in anything resembling a timely manner, and my co-host is in a similar boat.

#The Immediate Future

That has lead us to the necessary conclusion to shut it down for the season. As regular participants likely already know, I'm already way behind on the standings updates (January is mostly done, but not yet posted despite being a month late, and February's haven't even started to be analyzed), and the updates to date have been relatively bare-bones by standards of last season.

So here's the plan: The results from the 63 games that have been run will be posted, I'm just unable to provide a timeline for now. Probably near end of season if I were to guess. The 19 games which remain in the regular season will not have prediction threads (not from us, at very least), HOWEVER it would be anti-climactic to leave on such a dead note. Instead, there will be a prediction thread this week (likely tomorrow) which will be available for 7 days. In it, there will be a handful of predictive questions pertaining to the rest of the season which will have high point values, hopefully capable of making something to "fight for" to win the season and potentially mix up the front runners.

#The Long-Term Future

I will not be hosting this game next season as I don't foresee being able to make that time commitment. It sounds as though TheKandyCinema feels the same, but he's welcome to correct me on that.

Assuming I am/we are relinquishing hosting duties, I will leave it up to our fantastic mods who have helped out a lot along the way to decide the fate of this game next season. Should someone step up, I'm happy to help get it set up and organized, and pass on what I've learned/assets I've developed - don't hesitate to PM me. But I'm not the one you should be "asking" for the role, that's up to you and our mods. Just be warned it will likely take a whole lot more time than you might expect.

So with that, I want to thank u/TheKandyCinema, u/WordsNTricks, and u/Valentine96, in addition to the very long list of dedicated players in the community. It's been fun, and please keep an eye out for our final prediction thread tomorrow ;)

Posted Feb 28, 2016, 6:47 AM UTC · edited

2030
aschwan41Darth Vader•

Aww, I'm going to miss this! I'll help in any way possible!

7
Omega613OPPrediction Alpha•

Thanks, I appreciate that and for all your predictive efforts. But this is the only avenue for now.

3
MrPilg0r•

:(

6
Omega613OPPrediction Alpha•

You've been a consistent and long term player, thanks :)

4
mandm4s•

I may be interested in doing it next year! I'll send you a PM. I'd make it mostly done by a program so it (hopefully) wouldn't be as time consuming.

5
Omega613OPPrediction Alpha•

I wrote a program this year too, though a pitfall we may have created was structuring the points (esp. for the bonuses) in such a way that one still had to write/designate specific functions for each game. So a suggestion would be to foresee and avoid such issues to alleviate some of the work. Though creating an answer key is often a large timesink too if you don't do it as you go (which I mistakenly did not). Lastly, you might also be able to be more clever with the data validation from users - slight errors and format typos (eg. for save% someone put "93.0" and another puts "0.930") take some time correcting.

Again, you're welcome to PM me for some help/advice for getting the ball rolling, but you'll have to discuss with the mods about actually being the person (or one of a couple) who's running it - not me. I would recommend waiting until ~August/September-ish before anyone volunteers, just to be certain that your forseeable schedule can compensate.

Otherwise, thanks so much for playing and for offering your help (prior to just now).

3
mandm4s•

I definitely have some ideas on how to do it in a way that it would work without too much extra work. Using a SQL database to store all raw data (which would include the username, date of the game, and # of points they received that game) then getting monthly scores, or other results is as easy as doing a few SQL queries.

In terms of formatting I'd probably just make it very clear that if you can't type something the way that the question asks then you will not receive points for it. Harsh, yet easy enough for the user and much easier for me.

I'll message the mods for sure! I'm a student so I already know that I'll be incredibly busy next season. I think I can make time for this though.

Thanks for keeping it together for so long as it is. I've really enjoyed paticipating in the game!

3
TheKandyCinemaPrediction Beta•

If anyone wants to continue this next year and would like to go the Google Forms way, I have a template along with some add ons you may need.

It was really fun to do this and I thank Omega for giving me the chance.

5
aschwan41Darth Vader•

I'll do it.

3
marleyman3389•
3
Omega613OPPrediction Alpha•

As one of our most consistent players, many thanks and good luck this season. If someone's running it next season, expect me to be going head-to-head >:)

2
BeBopBats•

Well, this is sad news but I totally respect your decisions. Thanks for all your hard work! It was fun while it lasted.

2
Omega613OPPrediction Alpha•

Appreciate it. And it's already sounding likely that it will be running again at least by next season, and I'm sure the fresh perspective will do well. Thanks for playing, I know you been on my scorecard for a long time :)

2
_bobbykelso•

Though it's upsetting this can't continue, I am glad it's for a good reason. Congratulations on your success!

2
Omega613OPPrediction Alpha•

That's very kind, thank you. And worry not, I'm sure it will continue next season under new management!

1
FuzzumzDoc Emmett Brown / Marty McFly•

It was very fun while it lasted. Thanks again Omega for starting this. Thanks to KandyCinema and the mods for helping out.

2
Omega613OPPrediction Alpha•

Any time, and thank you for many, many predictions over the past couple seasons! Hopefully I can keep pace with you next season, though I'm lacking your veteran experience ;)

1
braken•

Welp, it was amazing fun while it lasted. Thanks for all of the time and effort that went into keeping these going, it's been something that I actually rush (happily) to get done every game day, and I'll definitely miss it.

2
Omega613OPPrediction Alpha•

Thanks for those kind words, and for being such a long-term player. I'm pretty confident that it will be up and running next season, so picture this as being more like an early offseason, haha.

1
KarlKarlsson•

Thanks for running it Omega!

2
Omega613OPPrediction Alpha•

Any time. I had plenty of fun too. Thanks for playing!

1
DrSayer•

Shit I loved this game

2
Omega613OPPrediction Alpha•

I'm confident it will return next season, but thank you for playing!

1
DrSayer•

Yay!

1
kakaflockaHan Solo•

I thank you for your service, Omega.

Now, take a nice long vacation without updating those standings!

2
Omega613OPPrediction Alpha•

Early offseason! Ha. Thank you too, you've been a long-term and consistent player, which was always rewarding for me to see.

1
DangleFest_•

Was thinking about how it could be programmed for a project that reads from a database... Going to look into it, maybe a group collaboration would work. or even if we can pool enough together just get it up and running on a site of it's own

2
Omega613OPPrediction Alpha•

For sure. Maybe not quite how you're envisioning it, but as it stands the Google surveys collect everyone's data into a spreadsheet/csv (1 for each game). Then I have written a program which assembles them all in into a database of sorts - a 3D array with everyone's predictions, including the front-most 2D array containing the scores earned. Some of the challenges were (1) to eliminate duplicate names (intentional and unintentional) and prioritize the most recent submission on a given day, (2) recognize a submitter that's already in the database and add data to their portion of the array (or create a new one for new players), and (3) try my best to compensate for common typos while processing the data. That might be easier to accomplish for some people, but new for me (esp. in Matlab).

A number of other challenges or inefficiencies also arose, hence why it ended up being such a time consuming portion of the project. However someone with far more programming experience than me has already shown interest in running it next season, so I definitely agree that a (better-made) database would be an ideal way to go.

1
DangleFest_•

oh wow, you guys really put lots of effort into it! Thanks again for making it happen this year. I was thinking possibly a login for users and a dropdown menu or suggestions of the players in the game to avoid typos. Of course not sure how much time I have and I'm sure there's many more skilled programmers out there. I think that there is unlimited potential for this but it comes down to time commitment. If I can help whoever takes lead on the project I'll do my best

1
Ass_Stephens•

I never participated in those threads but I still appreciate the effort you guys put into them.

Regardless, thanks for the content and good luck at your new job Omega

2