Supersnazz•

This is a great case. The legalities of shooting a dead man, with the belief that he was alive, has always been a common theoretical case.

14
sennais1•

Just sounds like a Pink Panther-esque conundrum.

1
Salindurthas•

This reminds me of a wonky ethics/law question, which is even murkier. From memory (violence discussed ahead):

  • There is an old couple in an abusive relationship, where the husband will often threaten the wife with a gun that he leaves deliberately unloaded, however he will often pull the trigger of the gun.

  • The son of this couple wants his mother to die, so he secretly loads the gun.

  • While arguing, a few intriguing things happens:
    * The husband fires the gun (thinking it is unloaded), but misses.
    * Another man attempts to commit suicide by jumping off the top of the couple's apartment building.
    * The bullet from the missed shot goes out the window and kills the man who jumped from the building.

  • The man who jumped was in fact the son of this couple (presumably he felt guilty, but I guess we can't know now).

The question is, who is responsible (or should go to jail) for what crimes?

EDIT: fixed a typo.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Salindurthas•

Husband goes on trial for attempted murder (of wife)

Attempted murder? But he didn't even try to kill her!

Indeed, what if he didn't even keep ammunition in the house? (I think this is part of the original problem, but I forgot it when noting it down).

manslaughter (of son)

But the son was going to fall onto the concrete and die anyway! The son was also the person responsible for the gun being loaded!

2
RaptorsOnBikes•

I suppose it's worth considering that the son may not necessarily have died - it's entirely probable, but suicides do fail. But being shot sealed the deal.

But that's an even bigger hypothetical which I don't know if would be considered valid.

1
Salindurthas•

Turns out in the original problem (I forgot this detail), there was a safety netting installed to protect some painters who were working on that side of the building.
The son would probably have survived the fall, despite intending to commit suicide.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
Fallcious•

Negligent discharge of a firearm? Reckless endangerment of life?

I believe a responsible gun owner is meant to consider a gun loaded at all times, and therefore would be at the very least considered negligent if the firearm went off when he was waving it around.

2
dat303•

Um this is the opening scene to Magnolias

2
Salindurthas•

Indeed it is! I was unaware.

1
dat303•

Still a great question though.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
Salindurthas•

You seem to misunderstand the facts.

Why would he attempt to kill himself even though the bullet missed?

The man jumping is not the husband.

I did make a minor typo that made it easier for your misreading to occur. I have fixed that now.

1
VoteRonaldRayGun•

He doesn't realise it missed,. He jumped before the gun shot thinking he had already caused his mother's demise. Also the father isn't dead, the son is.

1
runamuckalot•

I'm confused, who fired the first shot?

2
Alaric4•

Same guy. But I believe that one was found to be an accident as they wrestled over the gun.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1