Healthcare Reform to Make America Not Whole Wheat but Great Again
donaldjtrump.com/positions/healthcare-reformPosted Mar 3, 2016, 1:28 PM UTC
Posted Mar 3, 2016, 1:28 PM UTC
I like how Obama is characterized as "the most partisan and divisive president in American history."
Seems like a bold claim considering that the election of an earlier president literally caused half the country to secede and led to the bloodiest war in American history.
Whenever people (including myself) get down about the presidential election or the direction the country seems to be going in, etc. I point out/remind that James Buchanan literally did nothing as states seceded so it could always be worse
They both came in on a train for their inauguration. COINCIDENCE? http://www.thedailysheeple.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/obamalincoln.jpg
The biggest issue I see with this plan is no mandate = no coverage for pre-existing conditions.
If there are regulations that insurance companies can't reject people for having expensive pre-existing conditions, health insurance costs will simply spiral out of control as healthy individuals opt-out. The only way it works is if there is a mandate so everyone has to have coverage.
Not surprisingly, pre-existing conditions are not mentioned at all in Trump's health care plan. So under this plan, I would expect the number of uninsured to rise. This would be a big step back.
You can make insurance companies cover pre-existing conditions without a mandate... you just have to accept that insurance will be more expensive for everyone else who does have insurance. [edit: see below u/jsmooth7's comment why even then you probably need other provisions (if not a full mandate) at best to contain skyrocketing costs.]
Even with the mandate, the insurance cost might end up going up but at least you're bringing in more people to pay for it. At least then you're pretending to do something to contain the cost of covering pre-existing conditions. Trump's plan doesn't even pretend.
You can make insurance companies cover pre-existing conditions without a mandate... you just have to accept that insurance will be more expensive for everyone else who does have insurance.
Unfortunately you get a feedback cycle that goes something like this:
Add people with pre-exisiting conditions --> Average risk goes up --> Costs goes up --> For the healthiest individuals in the plan, the insurance is no longer worth the cost. They drop the plan --> Average risk goes up --> Cost goes up --> ... and so on
It doesn't just make it a little bit more expensive. It basically makes the whole thing fall apart.
Two points on this;
Some cost-sharing response to individual risk is a good thing, the optimal is somewhere between ACA's age & tobacco only and the GOP proposals which soak the chronically ill.
The risk adjustment part of the ACA just takes funds from plans with low-risk individuals, and gives it to plans with high-risk individuals. This just redistributes the risk, but it doesn't change the overall average risk in all health care plans. So even with risk adjustment, you could still have the same problem of rising costs as healthy individuals opt-out.
The ACA also has the reinsurance and risk corridors component, but those were temporary and are ending in 2016. They were only put in place to ensure insurance companies didn't set high premiums during the first few years due to uncertainty.
(I could be mistaken about all this though, because I feel like you probably know a lot more about this topic than I do.)
Isn't the significant reason why the individual mandate is necessary is to avoid taxpayers paying the costs of uninsured people?
Every GOP candidate (including Trump) has supported forming a federal high risk pool which would reinsure excess risk largely eliminating this problem. This is basically covering the risk adjustment features of ACA in sections 1341-1343.
If I'm not misunderstanding the issue (it is possible), there is some empirical support for this particular point if one considers Medicaid to be the "federal high risk pool." See Clemens (2015) (NBER working paper version here) for example.
Yes and I probably should have made that clear. The states that tried to cover pre-existing conditions without a mandate in the 90s seem to have faced skyrocketing costs. There might be ways to contain the premium inflation using some kind of a government guarantee or continuous coverage requirement (sort of a soft mandate) but none of these are even considered in Trump's plan.
You can make insurance companies cover pre-existing conditions without a mandate
I mean you can... but in a very short period you're going to have bankrupt insurances companies as you've created a system where people only try to buy health insurance after they become sick.
At what point does it become obvious that the private health insurance system can't both act like a market and provide the kind of universal coverage that single-payer systems provide in other countries?
Whenever talk turns to health care or guns I'm amused at how far apart the American and Rest-of-World Overton windows are.
In the latest debate he mentioned, "-we should keep pre-existing conditions." I think what he posted is more of an outline on his position.
Can someone explain to what "Whole Wheat" has to do with anything?
It's a reference to Hillary saying she wants to make America whole again. Trump mocked her for it
tbh I think Trump's endorsement of regulatory harmonization across all 50 states to increase insurer competition is probably his only positive contribution to the election, and I think is the best healthcare policy on both sides of the debate.
Can someone explain why I'm wrong? It seems as though regulatory capture and it's resulting high barriers to entry have stymied the incentive to reduce costs.
There are already states that allow this. It turns out the high barrier to entry is often not regulatory for the most part. New entrants to an insurance market face big challenges and startup costs. The most obvious one is negotiating with the providers. Without a footprint in a state, insurers have little leverage versus the providers and they need to spend a lot of money before they can sell a single plan.
Allowing insurers to work nationally is not a bad idea (though its skeptics will have reasons) but it's nowhere close to being a silver bullet.
The only issue I have with this is what happened with credit cards - all the banks bought off - I mean "lobbied" - South Dakota to basically have no regulations and now every bank that issues credit cards sends their offers from there.
What's to stop Aetna, UnitedHealthCare, and the like to find some small easily bought off state legislature, cut regulations to ribbons, and move their address there?
Nice to see Trump protecting us from the robots.
Not that anyone takes the Donald's policies seriously around here but I think it's still worth a discussion at least for the sake of informing people.
So let's start with the RI:
Citation needed. The bulk of ACA didn't come in effect until 2014. Also, while the ACA did increase the federal budget and anecdotally, some people's premiums went up, an "incredible economic burden" it is not.
Healthcare is already rationed in the US. Moreover, maybe ironically, ACA might have reduced rationing. More importantly, the ACA removed one of the biggest rationing barriers: Insurance companies denying people due to pre-existing conditions.
Excuse my language but this is the same shit both parties say and it's a bunch of bullshit, in my opinion. It assumes there are no trade-offs to whatever policy you're proposing. The US has 29 million people without insurance (about 10M illegals). So there is not a very significant amount of people you can increase access to to gain economies of scale. This means you have to pick something. You might lower the quality (paying less to doctors, hospitals). You might ration care. But you can't increase access, reduce cost, and improve quality baring an economic miracle.
OK fine.
Then modify the existing law that inhibits my doctor accepting insurance from North Dakota. OH WAIT THAT LAW DOESN'T EXIST. I'll go Rubio here but just removing lines doesn't make problems go away.
What is the cost of this? For people who get insured through their job, most of the cost is already on the company. For people who get individual coverage, this could really reduce the tax base of the country due to the high costs of these plans.
OK fine but HSAs don't quite work for people who don't even save for retirement.
Yeah of course this is a good idea, but how? Are you going to have hospitals print menus? Is there going to be a government-maintained list of procedures and their expected cost in each state? Also, why does the consumer care about this anyway? The insurance company pays for the treatment for the most part. What's the incentive for the end consumer to look for the best prices?
I doubt importing drugs from other countries will make a significant dent in healthcare costs, but I don't know enough about the pharma industry. Generics are already cheap. Specialized medicine is protected by IP. Our per-molecule cost is comparable to most Western countries anyway. Where are the savings?
It might not, but then why do we have the law anyway?
Not necessarily a bad thing. Just a decrease in tax revenue.
Make them opt-out like some 401(k) plans.
Absolutely. I know a doctor that has a flat fee of $250. Does not take insurance. His patients love him. Always a full waiting room.
Currently, the consumer doesn't. Asymmetric information. Can we change this attitude, and should we?
Its not a law is an absence of a law. Financial services that are not chartered by the federal government require chartering in every state they operate, which in turn makes it impossible to offer identical services in every state (unless the states have a compact for regulatory reciprocity).
Insurance is not federally chartered, an insurer cannot register with the federal government and trade in every state.
Retirement is a (relatively) predictable cost, healthcare is not. Unlike retirement people massively underestimate their future health costs and because investments in health capital have an unknown cost that is realized far in the future people simply don't make those investments without being forced.
If you want HSA's to be the cornerstone of the healthcare system that may work but people must be forced to contribute.
He would be expensive then, average cash price of a PCP visit nationally is $204 this year.
Its not a law is an absence of a law. Financial services that are not chartered by the federal government require chartering in every state they operate, which in turn makes it impossible to offer identical services in every state (unless the states have a compact for regulatory reciprocity).
TIL. Do you think this would be a good policy?
I don't know enough about this policy to go one way or another. Just pointing out that we have other mechanisms in place to go off of.
The guy must be good.
It would reduce geographic variance in cost but would not reduce average cost or total expenditure. But yes, it would be a good policy.
Is that for one visit? What sort of services would be provided and how long would contact be? Seems to be too high?
I don't know the full history, but we don't have a single law. Some states already allow insurance from other states. Most don't. This is per-state basis. See here. AFAIK, the main reason for the laws to exist is the states' ability to regulate the insurance industry. Trump's plan will definitely not contain a Federal agency to regulate insurance at the Federal level, and even if did, it wouldn't pass in the GOP Congress.
Besides, for the states that removed this restriction, they fell short of their goals.
I googled around a bit and found this. In 2010, premiums were $840B, and about a quarter of it was paid by employees. If you include the individual market (which has increased since then due to ACA), the decrease in tax revenue is quite high unless I'm misunderstanding his proposal.
People with jobs can already get HSAs, this proposal says extend it to individuals. So there is nothing to opt-in unless you want it to be like Medicare and be a tax. Again, if people can't (don't/won't) save for retirement, I'm sure they can't (don't/won't) save for HSAs either.
If there is a way to make the consumer of healthcare more responsive to the price, sure, I'm all for it. I just don't see it in this plan. If HSAs were immensely more popular, sure this could help.
That's my point. 401(k)s that are opt-out are significantly used more. There's no reason I can think of HSAs wouldn't follow the same pattern.
That still doesn't take out the problem of those who can not afford to have an HSA.
In regards to the first point about the economic burden, I have two notes. First, if you're stuck going from temp job to temp job as a starting out white collar worker, trying to maintain the now mandatory health insurance coverage is a gigantic pain in the ass. The law only allows for ONE gap in coverage; multiple gaps and you're dinged for the tax, even if they're only small gaps between jobs, creating a situation where you have to scramble to get coverage between jobs. Not fun.
Secondly, the proof of coverage requirement for tax filing is creating a huge pain in the ass for groups of the population, such as students who live far away from their parents who are having to obtain the form that shows proof of insurance from their parents' providers, increasing the difficulty of them even handling 1040ez forms.
Both points are somewhat anecdotal, admittedly, as the first is from the experience of myself and friends of mine in the same position, and the second is what I've been encountering while working to help prepare taxes. Key point is, there is a burden being created by the ACA, if not a strictly economic burden then definitely a burden of time utilization and excess effort.