So Cracked recently released a video last week that I think deserves to be here.

So the video on they released on their Youtube is called Why Outrage Culture is ruining the Internet and yes I agree that's a terrible title which was probably only given that because people love to get outraged on the topic of Outrage Culture so hey Cracked gets some clicks.

But the video should have shared the same name as the actual subject matter which is "3 Online behaviours that just aren't helping" which are:

  1. Calling someone an idiot before trying to educate them.

  2. Lying for apparently no reason.

  3. Problematic Problematicsm.

And to be completely honest I see a lot of these points reflected in our community, myself included and was hoping for some discussion on exactly how we can improve with dealing with some of these points.

Posted Mar 7, 2016, 1:27 PM UTC

3929
casersatzKeep Gamerica Gamerican!•

I can't disagree, but I think we need to keep our outrage in perspective.

If a person thinks "outrage culture" goes too far when Matt Taylor is judged over the shirt he wears, but then they lose their shit when a fictional character has their outfit changed for a video game, you can't judge "outrage culture". You're just as deep in it.

34
CaelrieNew Mod, Same Great Oppression!•

This. The outrage over outrage always vastly dwarfs the original outrage.

27
casersatzKeep Gamerica Gamerican!•
11
acedisWhat you just said really misaligns my QPUs•
1
cdtsI am the Scales of Justice! Conductor of the Choir of Death!•

"He who fights monsters..."

7
casersatzKeep Gamerica Gamerican!•

I thought it was soooo precious when DarkMatter2525 quoted that in his cartoon about social justice warriors.

Besides, do people who are upset about "SJWs" really even fight them? They don't fight them... they just whine and complain about them.

13
cdtsI am the Scales of Justice! Conductor of the Choir of Death!•

Hold on, there's a certain anti-GG YouTuber who likes to quote Nietzsche too...

Do I smell... a conspiracy?!

6
CSStrowbridge•

I think a quote from that video applies here:

"I tend to only apply reason to people who are using it themselves."

I'm more than willing to educate people when they are wrong, but only if they are wrong in a way that shows they might be willing to learn.

6
a4qbfb•

“In the words of the greatest philosopher of all time, Friedrice Nitseshee...”

1
[deleted]•

Besides, do people who are upset about "SJWs" really even fight them? They don't fight them... they just whine and complain about them.

I dunno Nazis are pretty violent.

4
Ayasugi-san•

Besides, do people who are upset about "SJWs" really even fight them? They don't fight them... they just whine and complain about them.

Some of them doxx their "SJW" enemies and try to get them fired and ruin their lives. Does that count as fighting?

2
casersatzKeep Gamerica Gamerican!•

Nope! That doesn't count as fighting, that counts as harassing (or worse).

It's much in the same way that I would say that someone threatening to kill Donald Trump isn't really "fighting" bigotry.

1
BeetlecatOneFlair to Middlin'•

Every time I see that quote used, all I can think is that --yes, they also played Baldur's Gate... :)

I'm actually surpassed he went for an "SJW" video. He normally keeps to the funny and sometimes really well-done bible commentary. It felt so forced.

2
DrakosAmatrasAnonymous Legitimate Source•

I can agree with #1 in some instances. Thing is, some people are deliberately ignorant, and they keep themselves that way to avoid having to be intellectually honest and responsible, even to themselves. They're not looking for broader understanding, despite how they may claim otherwise. In those cases, there isn't much you can do except remark their idiocy and move on, ideally sparing your energy for someone actually willing to listen.

3
Wigdog_JonesCrazy Far Left Ideologue•

I feel like complaining about 'Outrage Culture' is just another way to completely depoliticise the little matter of who is shitting on whom. Some things are worth getting upset about.

19
phearlez•

Thankfully the piece never talks about it not being okay to be pissed and react with anger when being mistreated. The framing is very much about media and thinkpieces. Presumably once you've sat down to write the article you've exited the moment when you're being shit on.

I think this is actually a fair use of the title, if we take it to mean outrage culture as in this method of expression being a part of culture. And I'm inclined to cut Cracked some slack here, as they're consistently good on this stuff.

9
cdtsI am the Scales of Justice! Conductor of the Choir of Death!•

Some things are worth getting upset about

Like when one side literally starts threatening your family, your friends, and your job.

8
ZagdenPro-Dat Ass•

The video seemed entirely reasonable. If you don't intend on changing minds, then sure. But if you do want to change minds, calling the people you want to listen idiots before explaining your views to them is patronizing and isn't going to make them listen. It's just going to make you yourself feel better because you've vented.

8
CaelrieNew Mod, Same Great Oppression!•

I don't think this one was a home run for Cracked.

Point 1 came across more as tone policing than good advice. Yah yah, be nice to people on the internet... but telling minority groups to be nice to KKK members in the naive hope that said KKK member is looking to be educated is... dumb

Point 2, nothing to disagree with there.

Point 3, this one was just privileged white mansplainy as all hell. "Everything's fine!" No, it isn't. You don't get to tell minority groups what's fine and what isn't, Mr White Man Hipsterdude.

11
cdtsI am the Scales of Justice! Conductor of the Choir of Death!•

Point 3, this one was just privileged white mansplainy as all hell. "Everything's fine!" No, it isn't. You don't get to tell minority groups what's fine and what isn't, Mr White Man Hipsterdude.

He most certainly can, because we most definitely live in a post-racial society!

(If only.)

6
Ayasugi-san•

Take the white women who named their PR company “Strange Fruit” after the Billie Holliday/Nina Simone song about the lynching of black people. They weren’t trying to mock Nina or the actual blood in her words; they loved the song and thought the title was great for a business that “stands out in a crowd”. They didn’t understand what it means to take a piece of work so important to the struggle of civil rights and re-purpose it for your business needs. Seeing the most beautiful and heartbreaking renditions of the pain of black people turned into the slogan “Are you a strange fruit?” is like a punch in the stomach considering that the “strange fruit” in the song is the hanging bodies of lynched black people.

I remember that, and I still can't believe that multiple people all thought it was a good idea and nobody said "wait, no, it's a horrible idea". Even if everyone involved was white.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
friendlyskeletongirllmao banned for calling out homophobia•

it really is such a bad video. it's not revealing or confrontational, all it does is make people who already think these things feel better about themselves.

it has such a ridiculous premise. the internet is home to nazis and pedophiles. i don't think it's " being ruined" by this guy's gripes with social justice.

point one fucking sucks. it assumes from the outset that the objective is recruitment, when that's not actually what everyone is on the internet to do at all times, surprisingly.

i really like when people use examples like in the video of "real problems" like his cry of transmisogyny, when actually those very same problems get written off as "not real problems" on a different day.

like this video is so blatantly about modern sj/feminist culture, and since when did that become "outrage culture"? i hate this term already because apparently it's one that's applied with no discretion whatsoever.

but whatever. since when was cracked worth listening to?

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
bbrightsideOP•

I feel this Video isn't really about Outrage Culture as it's traditionally portrayed but is intended to be used by the socially aware as a sort of nudge in a different direction that can actually be used for good.

For example; instead of not calling people idiots why not calling a unknown sexist/misogynist cis scum or that all men should die right off the bat, your intentions are to pull back the curtain and see the error of their ways of thinking. And yet here you are probably introducing them to these terms and jargon while doing so with such a negative connotation it's not surprising when they immediately put their shield up and double down on those tendencies, in their head they may as well be the 'hero' in this battle as they aren't the jerk that doesn't call people things they don't understand.

10
ryannaughton1138•

Yeah, this hits a little bit too close to home. Particularly whenever Salon is brought up.

5
cdtsI am the Scales of Justice! Conductor of the Choir of Death!•

A general rule of thumb I use: I try not to stoop to the level of the people I find to be repulsive when countering their arguments. Otherwise, I become no better than them.

5
Desecr8or•

In response to number 1, I can usually tell the difference between someone who genuinely wants to learn vs someone who is just JAQing. I still remind them that it's not my job to educate them and they should seek out sources that are actually meant to educate but I'm more polite to the former than the latter.

0
AdrianBrony☠Skeleton Justice Warrior☠•

His first thing kinda misses the point imo.

Sometimes criticism isn't made specifically for the betterment of the target, but to make an example of them.

For instance, a nazi or white supremacist. I couldn't really care less if they improve, if they do then good, but ultimately I would prioritize making it known they are not welcome in a community for the sake of keeping the community safe.

I'm not going to abide them on the off chance that they might turn over a new leaf, that's not my responsibility. Safety takes priority over that. I'm going to make them feel as unwelcome as possible so not only that person goes away, but like minded people will know that those notions are not tolerated.

And yeah, that won't change any hearts, but once again, that's not my responsibility. There's other people in a better position to try and fix them.

-2†