[Marvel] Would Captain America obey President Trump?

During the debates, Donald Trump said that he would simply command the armed forces to do what he wanted, even if that was killing terrorist families and torturing people.

As a product of America's military would Captain America go along with President Trump's commands? Would he kill a terrorist’s family if ordered? Or round up and deport millions of illegal immigrants? Or force Mexico to build a wall?

Posted Mar 7, 2016, 9:36 PM UTC

925
BillybobThistleton•

Doesn't matter what the press says. Doesn't matter what the politicians or the mobs say. Doesn't matter if the whole country decides that something wrong is something right. This nation was founded on one principle above all else: the requirement that we stand up for what we believe, no matter the odds or the consequences. When the mob and the press and the whole world tell you to move, your job is to plant yourself like a tree beside the river of truth, and tell the whole world — "No, you move."

But I always preferred the far briefer line from Daredevil: Born Again:

http://cdn.bleedingcool.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/cap-dream.jpg

38
League-TMS•

Do you have a source for the longer quote?

EDIT: Found it, ASM #537

4
AtomicMonkey77•

No. He's not a mindless patriot, he's a true patriot who stands for justice and freedom. I'm pretty sure that's actually a component of his role in Civil War.

33
ngxpOP•

Would he do it even against the will of the American people? In the comics it seems like there's always someone behind the scenes manipulating events. What if this is the true will of the people?

4
Badwolf0310•

Again, with Civil War there was a huge public outcry to register super heroes, and he still stuck to his morals. That's the interesting thing about the character, he's steadfast on what he believes regardless of what side of the law he is on.

19
PrinceHarming•

This is a good quote from Cap concerning his stance:

"Doesn't matter what the press says. Doesn't matter what the politicians or the mobs say.Doesn't matter if the whole country decides that something wrong is something right.

This nation was founded on one principle above all else: The requirement that we stand up for what we believe, no matter the odds or the consequences. When the mob and the press and the whole world tell you to move, your job is to plant yourself like a tree beside the river of truth, and tell the whole world -- "No, YOU move.

16
T3chnopsycho•

This is actually a really good quote in general.

3
AtomicMonkey77•

I refuse to accept that Trump's platform is the will of the people, but hypothetically, I think he would still refuse. Again, the Civil War timeline is in part about Cap refusing to go along with the popular sentiment of registering supers. He directly fought Nazis, and has an insanely upstanding moral code, so the idea of him condoning the violation of international law seems really unlikely.

14
Cascadix•

It's a big part of Cap's character that he stands for American ideals and principles, not the government itself. So, no, Cap would not support killing a terrorists family, or forcing Mexico to build a wall, or deporting millions of people for one, relatively minor offense.

Cap's a good demonstration of the difference between good and lawful. If the laws aren't just, he doesn't support them just because they're the law. Unjust laws should be amended or defied, not tolerated.

So, if Trump says something reasonable, like, "deport this specific Mexican immigrant, because he committed crimes in Guadalajara, and Mexico wants him extradited," yeah, Cap's going to support that. But deporting all immigrants solely on the relatively minor crime of invalid immigration, just because Trump says so, I don't buy.

17
justplayKOF13•

This has been a recurring theme with him for decades:

In Captain America #180 (December 1974) Rogers becomes disillusioned with the U.S. government when he discovers that a high ranking government official (heavily hinted to be the then President of the United States Richard Nixon) is the leader of the terrorist organization known as the Secret Empire.

Rogers then decides to abandon his Captain America identity, feeling that he cannot continue to serve America after this latest discovery has shattered his faith in the nation's status. However, a confrontation with Hawkeye (disguised as the Golden Archer) forces Rogers to realize that he cannot abandon a life of heroism, and he subsequently takes on the name "Nomad" (as it means "man without a country") adopting a new dark blue and yellow uniform with no patriotic markings on it at all.

This identity is short-lived, with Rogers maintaining it for a mere four issues of the comic to varying degrees of success; he even trips over his own cape at one point. At the conclusion of Captain America #184 (April 1975) Rogers returns to the role of Captain America when he realizes that he could champion America's ideals without blindly supporting its government.

7
DCarrier•

Considering when he was from, I wouldn't be surprised if he was okay with forcing Mexico to build a wall or deporting millions of people.

2†
LibraryLassWorking on her Robopsychology Thesis•

Nah, Cap's been shown time and again as being as free of prejudice as humanly possible.

9

Also his mom and dad were poor Irish immigrants, and anti-Irish discrimination was one of the formative experiences he had to endure.

7
BillybobThistleton•

You mean 1930s New York? Home of the immigrant dream and heartland of American socialism?

Historically speaking, the odds are Steve Rogers leans further to the left than the entire modern Democratic party.

8
AttilaTheFun818•

He would probably be something of an Eisenhower Republican. Little to do with the Republican Party of today.

1
akaioi•

I think Cap might be practical about the wall and suggest that the US build it on our side, so that it be done to our specifications, and just bill them. If we somehow leaned on Mexico to build it, they likely wouldn't be very enthusiastic about quality control.

1
Pm_Me_Gifs_For_SauceWhere da white troopers at•

Nope. I'm sure in Civil War the president or the government at least had some pull in favor of registration, yet which side did he choose?

Anti.

8
ParameciaAntic•

Absolutely not. He always stands up for what he believes is right.

5
FixBayonetsLadsAnkh-Morpork City Watch•

And the thing about Cap is, usually, what he thinks is right, IS right.

5
LibraryLassWorking on her Robopsychology Thesis•

As it happens, all soldiers have not just a right but a mandate to refuse what are known as unlawful orders-- orders to commit war crimes, for instance.

Captain America's tour of duty is long over. He is no longer a member of the military and is therefore not technically obligated to follow even lawful orders.

4
AttilaTheFun818•

I'm a few years behind, but is he not a member of SHIELD?

I'm not clear on where they stand in relation to the rest of the military, but it seems to me that they still answer to the President on one level or another. I recall the President appointing Cap Director.

1
20150506•

It wouldn't be the first time he disagreed with the administration and abandoned the Captain America identity. See [Nomad.](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nomad_(comics\))

3
AttilaTheFun818•

He would respect the office, but may not respect the man.

In the military you are not obligated to carry out illegal orders, as I understand it. "I vas just followink orders" is not a valid excuse.

3
aonf•

Of course he would, he's a patriot. Would he obey Obama?

(Also mods can we have a rule against politicking in here?)

-5
LibraryLassMODWorking on her Robopsychology Thesis•

We have.

3