r/AsianBeauty•
applemiiiint

I'm looking for a Japanese physical sunscreen

Routine Help

I've heard some amazing things about Japanese sunscreens. I get a pretty horrible allergic reaction to chemical sunscreens. My lips swell up, this salty liquid comes out of the side of my lips, little bumps all over my skin and start to peel. It's a pretty horrible experience LOL! This also means I can't wear makeup, lotion, etc with sunscreen. :(

Right now I use blue lizard which has an spf of 30. Would like something with a 50+++ spf! What Do you use?

Posted Mar 9, 2016, 7:13 PM UTC

1432
remusatNC15|Pigmentation/Pores|Combo|EE•

You can use the search function on RatzillaCosme's site to filter physical-only sunscreens. Also, AFAIK, u/SnowWhiteandthePear can't handle chemical sunscreens either and she reviewed a physical-only Japanese sunscreen here!

8
AncientLadyNW13|Aging/Acne|Sensitive|US•

Here are the Asian physical-only sunscreens I know of (not sure if they're all Japanese; I haven't paid attention):

Innisfree Eco Safety Perfect Waterproof SPF 50 PA+++

Innisfree Eco Safety No Sebum Sunblock SPF 50 PA+++

LookAtMe Jelly Sunscreen 50+ PA+++ (<---I think this is physical only)

Goodal Mild Protect Natural Filter Sun Cream SPF 50+ PA+++

5
AncientLadyNW13|Aging/Acne|Sensitive|US•

OK, no, I have to correct myself . . . I was looking at the LookAtMe sunscreen on Amazon and the seller states it's mixed chemical/physical. So scratch that one.

4
alisonlou•

Hey, I have been using Blue Lizard for about a year! It's not bad! After reading ALL of u/SnowWhiteandthePear's reviews, I think I'm going to try the Goodall. Club Clio had a 2 for one deal at some point (could still be going on), but I think I'll just hit eBay for a single tube. She does warn that it is heavily scented, so I am a little nervous.

3
myseoulawayAcne/Pigmentation|Oily|US•

Fwiw I just got the goodal and I like the scent. Haven't tried it yet for reasons, but it smells nice :)

3
alisonlou•

Thanks! I appreciate the feedback. :-)

1
colapuff•

I use the Nivea Sun Protect Plus UV. It has spf 50 PA ++++. I wouldn't recommend it for people that are oily. But if you're dry to combination, it's a nice physical sunscreen that doesn't irritate my screen. It has an initial oily feel but it goes away after an hour. :)

3
hibaobao•

Have you tried putting on makeup over this?? :3

1
colapuff•

I actually have. It doesn't play super well with makeup if you apply your makeup right away as it has a tendency to ball up on your face. However, I find that if I let it absorb for 10-20 minutes. My bb cushion does not ball up.

1
hibaobao•

Hmm. Back to the drawing board then haha. I swear I will find my unicorn sunscreen one day.

1
colapuff•

LOL if anything, Biore sells a Perfect UV Milk (blue bottle) that is a physical sunscreen. I have it but havent gotten the chance to really test it out yet. However, from what I can tell it dries pretty matte so I think it'll be great for summer to control oily skin and being a milky formula it wont ball up under makeup ;3

1
lovechattingAging/Acne|Dehydrated|US•

Hey, looking at the Ratzilla Cosme entry, ingredients include some chemical filters (octinoxate, tinosorb, uvinal a and t) along with zinc oxide so this looks like a combination sunscreen.

1
2catsinjapanBlogger | asianskincareblog.blogspot.com•

I'm repeating it like a broken record but NOV EX Shield is probably the best and most cosmetically elegant physical-only sunscreen in Japan that can still be considered moderately priced. Also the SunMedic line has physical only options.

If you want the Benz of physical-only Japanese blockers, then Acseine Super SunShield (the non-chemical option in an airless pump) is the way to go.

3
alixalix•

Have you tried the Shigaisen before..? If so, am curious about how it is compared to NOV. Thanks!

1
2catsinjapanBlogger | asianskincareblog.blogspot.com•

Honestly, Shigaisen was garbage. But YMMV. There's a post about Shigaisen on my blog somewhere.

1
alixalix•

Ok thanks! Now I'm really keen on trying the NOV :)

1
WattouatRedness/Dullness|Combo|FR•

I'm currently using the Shigaisen sunscreen and I really like it! It doesn't smother my skin like it seems to do for u/2catsinjapan. It's lightweight, dries up fast, and protects my skin even with daily use of AHA. The only downside is the white cast :( It's quite obvious, even though I'm fair (skin79 orange bb cream is a perfect match). I always wear bb cream when I go out so it's not a problem but yeah, don't wear it without foundation or you'll look like a ghost XD I'd like to try NOV but it's so pricey ;_;

1
2catsinjapanBlogger | asianskincareblog.blogspot.com•

I am sure that if I had tried Shigaisen first, I would have liked it, too. That's the problem with living in Japan. There are so many choices and there's always something better waiting just around the corner.

1
WattouatRedness/Dullness|Combo|FR•

Yes, there's no point settling for average products when you have so many great other possibilities available to you. Unfortunately being in France I don't have a lot of affordable options. Your review on Acseine Super Sunshield Ex was super convincing though, so I plan on trying it out someday when I run out of my current sunscreens (they're tiny but they seem to last forever??).

1
mizliuNC15|Redness|Dry/Normal|US•

I am with you on this!! I don't have such a horrible reaction to chemical sunscreens, but after switching to physical I haven't had issues again. I scoured RatzillaCosme a long time ago and found all the physical-only SPF50+ PA+++^+ sunscreens (oo, an extra +!), but the only thing is I have a hard time finding them at a good price (I'm located in the US btw). I currently use the (Korean brand) Innisfree Eco Safety Perfect Waterproof SPF 50 PA+++ and I have the Goodal Mild Protect Natural Filter Sun Cream SPF 50+ PA+++ on backup. If you can find these easily, I would check out the following:

Good luck!!

3
lovechattingAging/Acne|Dehydrated|US•

Ratzilla Cosme is my resource for searching Japanese physical sunscreens. If you're looking for SPF 50+++, you can also consider Korean sunscreens, e.g. Innisfree Eco Safety Perfect. I have tried some of the Japanese physical sunscreens (Atopita, Shigaisen, One de Bijin, Heroine Make, PS Collection) - broadening my search to include BB creams and primers allowed me to find some more affordable Japanese physical filter choices.

2
alixalix•

Which did you like the best? I've tried Shigaisen and am thinking of trying Atopita.

1
lovechattingAging/Acne|Dehydrated|US•

The Atopita is very price-friendly, but it is more emollient than the Shigaisen. One de bijin is categorized as a CC cream and pulls a darker beige, like a N23 or N27. Heroine Make has a pink tint, PS collection also has a pink tint although lighter than the Heroine.

3
alixalix•

Great thank you! I may try the Atopita then - the other brands sound too pink and/or dark for me.

1
midfallsongAging|Dry/Sensitive|US•

sounds like you pretty much have the same reaction I have to chemical sunscreens! sadly for me, I'm also allergic to vitamin E which rules out so many of the physical-only sunscreens. I'm using a SPF 20 one from innisfree at the moment, so I don't have anything to actually to contribute to your question other than to offer my solidarity hahahahaha

2
zosny•

NIVEA Sun Super Water Gel 80g - SPF50 PA+++

It is made in Japan. The NIVEA in the US doesn't make it.

This is what I use it is great! It doesn't leave a white cast and is very light. It doesn't peel up into little balls over moisturizers either. I have a store around where I live that sells it, but looks like they also sell it on Amazon for fairly cheap.
http://www.amazon.com/NIVEA-Sun-Super-Water-Gel/dp/B00BALO6X0

2
applemiiiintOP•

Is it a physical sunscreen? I can only use physical ones 😭

1
zosny•

I'm sorry. better if I hadn't even mentioned it it does contain some chemical sunscreen ingredients. sorry :(

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
hanjjag•

This is a non-AB recommendation, but I've been using a tinted version of EltaMD UV Physical Broad Spectrum SPF 41! And so far so good! No breakout.

1