I have some savings right now in EQ Bank saving accounts but I was wondering if it is better to have it in a TFSA account until I max it out

Posted Mar 10, 2016, 4:45 PM UTC

05
HabsFanInTO•

EQ has 3% rate, but you pay tax on it. If a TFSA would be better (assuming you are talking about a savings account, not ETFs/stocks/etc?) would depend on the interest rate and what your marginal tax rate is.

1
SoroSuub1Ontario•
  1. How much do you make (total income).

  2. What is the interest rate in the TFSA you're considering.

  3. How much do you value the ability to send 5 free Interac e-Transfer / month and make bill payments (unlimited) from your savings account?

1
plutoniaex•

Isn't the tax rate on interest somewhere around 18 percent? Correct me if I'm wrong but that means that the interest you make after tax on savings with EQ would be 0.82*3=2.46 percent. While with a TFSA the most you can earn is about 2.5% and then you would have used your contributions.

Does this make sense or am I missing something?

1
SavingMentor•

The tax you pay on income depends on how much income you make. That's why they call it the "marginal tax rate". Each portion of your income is put into brackets where you pay a different amount of tax. These brackets are different for federal income taxes and provincial income taxes but they usually overlap quite closely.

For example, almost no one in Canada pays any income tax on roughly on their first $10,000 earned. Once you get about $150,000+ in earnings, your tax rate jumps to 50% or more (only on the higher portion of those earnings). There are several buckets in-between where your tax rate is somewhere between 0% and 50%.

I personally use 30% as a rule of thumb when doing my own mental math - as my own personal tax rate usually ends up close to that when all is said in done accounting for all the tax brackets I surpass.

1
SavingMentor•

If you guestimate that your personal tax rate is about 30% (depends on your income of course) - then you'd need to earn more than 2.1% in a TFSA for you to be better off than you are with 3% at EQ Bank.

1