VirtualBrokers disallow "business email address"

Well, this is some unexpected brain damage. I received an email from "VB-Support" containing the following:

The Quotemedia Compliance Department noted on your account that you have used a business email address when signing up for our service. Please provide your personal email address if you wish to continue to receive market data as a Non-pro account.

As someone who as been using the Internet since 1992, I'm surprised to learn there is some distinction between "personal" and "business" email address. To be clear, the email address I am using is running off a domain name that I purchased in 2000. It is not exactly a business address, although I have used it for consulting work. Nothing related to stock or commodity trading, that's for sure.

I'm curious if anyone else has gotten one of these nastygrams. I'm planning to move away from VB anyhow because they don't allow the Norbert Gambit but this seems like more incentive.

Posted Mar 14, 2016, 7:26 PM UTC

77
stronz•

I received the same email about a month ago. Pushed back and they told me I would have to call Quotemedia to resolve it. I ignored it and decided to take my business elsewhere. VB then went out of their way to make closing my account take three weeks.

2
primetimey•

Not everyone works at their job for a lifetime.. most people keep a personal email for a lifetime. Makes sense.

-1
WhiteHalmos•

I think OP meant his email address is more of a vanity domain more than anything. As long as he keeps renewing his domain it's not going anywhere.

Disclaimer: I am a vanity email domain user. :)

2
primetimey•

I understand that, but how is their system going to differentiate from @aircanada.ca and @yourdomain.com .. it can't. If it isn't Gmail, Hotmail, Yahoo, Shaw, Rogers, etc. it doesn't work with VB.

1
nasOP•

That's exactly my point. There is no way for their system, whatever it is, to determine what is a "business" email address. It's ludicrous. Why should I be forced to sign up for an email address at some 3rd party email service?

Now, assume I am a professional trader wanting to freeload on their service. What's to prevent me from signing up with gmail and using their service, with my "personal" email address? Someone really hasn't thought this whole idea through.

3
WhiteHalmos•

Agreed, it's up to VB to disallow all non-mainstream domains. This policy unfortunately has a very high false positive rate on an address being a business email address.

2
nasOP•

I don't think they are worried about the address not working. They don't want to provide free quotes to professional traders. Fair enough. Trying to determine if I am "pro" based on my email address is a brain-damaged idea, totally ineffective and just annoying to normal customers.

1