Reading through this sub over the last few months has me considering filing a discrimination claim.

I am have never been a member of the church but I have been deeply affected by it. I was born in Utah just after the revelation allowing blacks to hold priesthood. My ancestry.com results reveal names like Rich, Gardner, and Allred. My mother's family pressured her to give me up for adoption when they found out my father was black.

Coincidental, my adoptive family are descendants of the slaves of the early settlers. My Mormon heritage runs deep.

Before reading this sub, I had not done much investigation into race relations and the church. I am aware that blacks could not hold priesthood but I didn't understand why. I still don't understand everything, but one thing is becoming clear, weather they are willing to admit it or not, it seems like many TBM still believe that people like me are inherently flawed because of the color of our skin.

Recently I was given a psudo promotion - new title, no raise. The person that has been hired to replace me is TBM and was in my bosses words "hand-picked" by his boss because she was someone he could work with. She also revealed that this chosen person is being groomed for a management position but has no experience and needs to take over my role to learn the ropes first. There is no doubt in my mind, that my replacement will be coming on at a much higher pay than me, and to make matters worse, I am going to be the one training her. Last year, another new hire came in at a higher salary then me and he is also TBM. Even though I have more experience than everyone in my group, including my boss, and my bosses boss, I am the lowest paid.

I have an excellent reputation to those (non-lds) outside of my group. In fact, I am seen as the most competent person in the department. Within my group, I have been labeled as insubordinate just for voicing an opinion. My TBM colleague often agrees with me, but never speaks up in front of our managers. I guess he has learned the proper way to behave at church work. Things got better when I started asking my manager for "guidance" instead of suggesting that I knew the right answer.

What is bothering me the most, is it that I don't think they are being malicious. I get the sense that by keeping me employed, they think they are being benevolent. Without outright malice, I didn't pick up on the fact that I might actually have a case until now. Reading some of the comments on this sub make me think that while they are not being racists intentionally. For lack of a better word, they pity me and think that I should just be happy to have what they are giving me and accept my station in this life. Intentionally or not, the end result is still the same.

Any thoughts about how I am reading this situation based on your experiences?

Posted Mar 15, 2016, 4:28 AM UTC

915
laddersdazed•

Document EVERYTHING from the get go, document everyday. Go back a bit with all dates, times possible. And get a good lawyer, not tbm. Good luck & stay true to yourself, you deserve it.

7
LadyTemerityOP•

Thank you for the advice and the words of encouragement. I've started to consider that staying true to myself might include walking away.

2
_ZombieHero_•

As a white male, I think that in a parallel world where your fantastic skin tone is the cultural norm, you would never have to deal with getting paid less than a new employee who is taking your position. Given the real world that if you are black, or otherwise colored, you are still discriminated against (which thing seems so, so awfully wrong, and I hope I never do so),I think there is no doubt that you would have been given a monetary upgrade as well if they were not being racist, at least a little and probably not on purpose. I certainly hope that any whom I have been unjust to realize that it has been unintentional and I am deeply sorry for anything I have been wrong about.

3
LadyTemerityOP•

Maybe it is time for me to find that parallel world outside of Utah. Thanks for your comments.

3
[deleted]•

Deciding to initiate legal action for discrimination is a big deal. If you were seriously wronged at work, then go for it. But be sure you have your facts before you start.

Can you open a conversation with your boss about how compensation levels are decided and why your current salary seems out of place? Some companies follow a "squeaky wheel gets the grease" policy, and they don't give raises as long as the employee seems satisfied.

And how do you know all these salaries?

2
LadyTemerityOP•

It is a big deal, and I have honestly never considered it until now. I have thought about whether I am letting my history unfairly influence this decision, but I don't think it is.

I don't exactly know the salaries but the evidence suggests that they are higher.

For example, As a manger myself, I am higher up in the organization. When she assumes my role, my replacement and I will be at the level. Last year she took a position at one of our offices on the east coast and consequently made east coast money. Our company does not have a policy to reduce pay back to cost of living in Utah. Instead, it is left up to the hiring manager. My hiring manager went out to the east coast office and begged her to join the team. I can't imagine that he reduced her pay.

You are spot on about the squeaky wheel policy. It is common practice in my company so I asked to be considered for a raise last year, around the time that my other TBM co-worker was hired. During that conversation my boss justified bringing my coworker in at a higher pay because of his experience. I should mention, he has more experience but I have more institutional knowledge. Regardless, I accepted this and kept working hard. In fact, during this time I learned SQL on my own so I could run queries against our database. This is a valuable skill and now run reports for the benefit of our entire group and also for our sales team. I figured once I set myself apart, I could make a better case. I also completed my degree which is highly relevant to the field I am in. Still, no raise.

I asked again during my review a few months back. My manager admitted that I was "due," but nothing happened. Instead, I was told that I would have the opportunity to make that case closer to when I assumed my new role next month, but as the time passed, he is acting as though he has no intention of discussing it.

3
Crazy_Life61•

My advice: start looking for another job, prefferably outside of Utah if you can manage it. Law suits can be long drawn out affairs and could torpedo your career by labeling you as a trouble maker. I am a woman in a male dominated field and I have had my share of really bad bosses, some that would swear at me and pubically berate me. I would learn everything I could at the job and then find a better one, each time progressing in my career. My advice to you is to stop wasting your time with a company that doesn't value you and find one that will.

2
razorwiredbliss•

I'd be willing to wager that it has more to do with the new hires status as a Mormon than your skin color. Also, everybody I've met who has been labelled as insubordinate for "voicing an opinion" is generally exaggerating their innocence. It does suck to work in an overwhelmingly conservative field (I would know) I just tend to keep my mouth shut when it comes to politics (which everybody should at work)

2
canseesquirrel•

I can tell you from personal experience, way back in the 90's in California, there was big-time discrimination towards non-Mormons in the very large company where I worked. When I was hired, I was almost immediately told by my colleagues that if you weren't Mormon you would never advance to the top tiers of the department I was employed in. The Mormons advanced and the rest of us transferred to different departments or left the company entirely. It wasn't a secret .... it was openly discussed. This was a very large aerospace company, but the various departments and divisions had their own cultures. If you pursue this tread carefully. If you can make a leap that might be a good option too. Hang in there.

1
LadyTemerityOP•

Thanks. Did anyone file formal complaint with the department of labor? If so, how did it turn out?

1
canseesquirrel•

No one ever did file or officially complain, as far as I know. The company was ultimately acquired by a bigger fish, and that shook up all the pecking orders. edited: to change openly to officially

1
kolob-kittyApostate•

I do not know if taking them to court would work. If you live in Utah it will turn out that the Judge is Mormon and if there is a jury, most or all of them will be Mormon as well. They are not going be on your side no matter how good of a case you have. I am sorry to be negative but I just know how Mormons are.

Have you thought about moving to another state?

1
LadyTemerityOP•

Yes, I have considered it, I go back and forth. I am afraid to leave my family and find more of the same if not worse, most people think being black or being from utah are mutually exclusive. I catch a lot of flack about the way I talk.

1
kolob-kittyApostate•

You could get on the internet and check where the best places for you to live would be. If you have more information about other places it could help.

I am sorry about what you are going through. You sound like a very thoughtful, reasonable person. I understand what it is like to train someone to take over you own job because I have done it. and I know what it is like for others to get paid more when you deserve to make more. It feel so unfair and makes you angry, but you can't always do anything about it.

I wish that I could give you advice that is more helpful. I wish you the best. I understand wanting to be close to family but I think you might be able to find a better place than Utah.

1
shatteredarm1•

My understanding is that it's pretty difficult to win a discrimination claim at work. Everything had to be flagrant and well-documented. As someone else said, start documenting everything.

I don't know what industry you're in, but if you enjoy a liquid job market, start looking for jobs. The new hires could be making more money simply because the job market has improved, and they have to pay more to get someone to jump ship. I experienced this personally, where I was getting fairly meager cost-of-living increases, despite being paid below market value, but got a $15k raise when I switched jobs. Actually, the vast majority of increases I got at the last company came when I went to my boss with a job offer in hand.

A lot of people may not realize this, but many companies have a separate budget for cost-of-living increases from the emergency one they use to give people raises in the middle of the year. Find out what the market is paying for your skill level and position, and go to your boss armed with that information, and possibly a pending job offer to back it up.

1