r/DnD•
dot_exe

Like Darkest Dungeon? I converted the stress system into a campaign I'm planning. Would love your thoughts.

Homebrew

I really enjoyed the game play of Darkest Dungeon, and felt like the stress and resolves rules from the game would work very well in the custom Ravenloft setting I'm building. Like the game, the goal is to make things more tense for my players, and force them to constantly evaluate their position. This is pretty much my first draft, and I tried to follow the rules of both games as close as possible. Any thoughts or opinions are welcome.

Stress and Resolve Stress is a measurement of your characters current state of mind. Unsettling events occurring before them, a critical hit on an ally, or certain monster attacks can increase your stress to varying degrees. On the other hand, certain actions done by your characters can reduce stress during the adventure. Healing spells will always reduce a bit of stress, but performing a heroic action or slaying a great foe can reduce it as well.

If you are unable to manage your stress, eventually your character's resolve will be tested. While there is a chance for great bravery to shine through in this tenuous moment, it is more likely your character will succumb to their fears. Passing a resolve test will grant a large reduction of current stress for you, a small reduction in stress for allies, and a great boon allowing you to press on. Failure however, will lead to a slow destruction of your party.

Stress

  • All characters start at 0 stress.
  • When a character reaches 100 stress, their resolve will be tested.
  • A character will continue to gain stress past 100. Upon reaching 200 stress, the character dies in a way most horrific of my own choosing.
  • When leaving a dungeon (but before reducing stress in town), your stress is set to 100 if it is above that value.

Events that increase stress:

  • Critical hits against you increase stress by half the amount of damage dealt. Allies stress is increased by half of that amount. (example, you are critically hit for 20 damage, your stress goes up by 10, and your allies goes up by 5)
  • Unsettling events are bound to occur in the depths of the dungeons. When your character witnesses an unsettling event, you must pass a saving throw (DC and stat based on the event). Failure increases stress based on how horrific the event is. If you pass, you probably want to count your lucky stars.
  • Certain monster attacks can appear more vicious than they really are, but maybe that’s the intent. Some attacks or skills a monster use will increase stress by those hit a great amount while dealing minimal damage. Not everything has the ability to do this, but those that can should be treated just as much of a threat as a monster then can deal a ton of damage.
  • If you fail a Resolve test, all allies Stress is increased by 10.
  • If an ally dies, the rest of the party has their stress increased by 20.
  • If you are asked to eat, and do not have enough food for everyone, everyone stress is increased by 10.
  • The option to run away is always present, however characters become unnerved from facing certain death. Your character's stress is increased by 30 when they flee a dungeon, and the monsters will swarm the area again (this stress will not trigger a resolve test).
  • When a character reaches 0 HP, they are downed and begin making death saving throws as usual. All allies Stress is increased by 5 for every round the ally is downed beginning when they go down. If the character is healed, and then dropped back to 0 HP, they automatically begin with 1 failed death save. This pattern continues until the character has been downed a total of 4 times in a given dungeon, at which point they will instantly die when hitting 0 HP (as they will start with 3 failed death saves).

Events that reduce stress:

  • Landing a critical hit against an enemy will rally you and your allies to press on. When you hit with a critical attack, your stress is reduced by half the amount of damage dealt, and your allies by half that amount. (for example, you hit a creature for 20 damage, you lose 10 stress, and your allies 5)
  • Defeating a great enemy (I will let you know when it’s a great foe, typically bosses and mini-bosses) will reduce your stress by half. Not every outing will face a great enemy though.
  • Healing spells will reduce stress by 1d4+1 per spell level. A second level Healing Touch spell would reduce stress by 2d4+2 point. While healing can be a useful way to manage stress, it will be a poor choice to dedicate one person to only doing that.
  • Sometimes just being a total badass and performing a heroic action can reduce stress. The value will be determined based on how awesome it is, along with how successful you are (gotta keep the rule of cool in motion). Typically moments where you would gain inspiration would reduce stress.
  • If your character passes a resolve test, your stress is reset to half of the value you rolled (explained in the Resolve section)
  • Upon returning to town, your stress is reduced by 1d10+20. There will be additional services available such as a church to pray, a bar to drink, or a gambling den. These services allow you to spend hard earned gold to further remove your stress.
  • Eating will remove 5 stress and heal 1d6+1 HP.
  • This excludes Bardic Inspiration: if you gain inspiration, and gain a second point of inspiration before using the first, your use the point of inspiration right away. Reduce your stress by 1d6+your character level.

Resolve

(Note:I did this as a percentile test as I did not want to link it to any particular stat. I felt that would be unfair to certain classes.)

Your resolve, your will to push onward is what will keep you in action. When your character has their stress reach 100, they must pass a resolve test in an attempt to heroically stand tall. Upon failure, things go from worse to OH WE ARE SO DEAD THERE’S BLOOD EVERY WHERE.

  • Every character has a base resolve chance of 30%.
  • Your character Resolve can be increased by gaining levels (+2% per level), and there are likely to be items within the dungeons that will bolster your resolve as well.
  • When your stress hits 100, you roll a 1d100.
  • If the result is under your resolve chance, you pass the test, you gain a mighty boon (determined at time of test). * Additionally, your stress is reset to half the value you rolled (a roll of 28 will set your current stress back to 14), and your allies have their stress reduced by 15.
  • If the result is above your resolve chance, your allies stress is increased by 10, and you suffer from a panic attack that chips away at your group's ability to press on (determined at time of test).
  • If you are able to bring your stress back down below 100, the negative effects inflicted by a failed resolve test are halved.
  • When a character returns to town, any effects of the resolve test are removed. A character must pay to have their stress reduced before they can go on another outing.

Posted Mar 16, 2016, 6:14 PM UTC

4918
Falerix•

This is great!

I have actually been converting the quirks of DD to more manageable DnD terms, if you want to comment and contribute the link is here: Google Drive Link

9
dot_exeOPFighter•

Oh nice!

I made the resolve test table. Very interested to see how these play out.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1q4FwA0VgJsVuVUrziSPKrE9xUlKGFABmkBuu7MIBVa4/edit?usp=sharing

3
bubblebooy•

I like the idea but I think instead of having 100/200 stress levels I think it should scale with lvl.

link it to any particular stat. I felt that would be unfair to certain classes.

What if each stat had a different effect on the stress system. ex:
Con - amount of stress from crits
Wis - effect ths 100/200 values
Str - amount of stress reduction from great kills
...

3
dot_exeOPFighter•

Having stress numbers scale with level is kind of a pain for balancing the encounters. Stress is a slow creep of death that will consume them. The only stress inflicting thing is criticals, and those are rare enough that it's not a big deal.

I like the second idea, but like the first point, I'm not looking ot have much scaling on stress side of things. They will get an item or two that will help, but keeping stress at more static values keeps my life simple running the game.

3
bubblebooy•

The reason I felt like it needed scaling is that obviously the stress you get from critical will scale. Though none of the other stress gains scale. Maybe scale the %dmg to stress as you level?

5
NineBlack•

Mainly the crits that are insane at higher levels. You may want to put a cap on it.

1
dot_exeOPFighter•

I don't see the game getting past level 10 or so. But you're right, a max of 20 stress dealt or something along those lines is fine. Crit should be rare enough that having a strike deal a ton of damage and stress is ok since it's unlikely to happen again soon.

2
VaranusNiloticusWizard•

This is really cool! thanks :)

2
kvltbro•

A system like this exists in Torchbearer, which might as well be Darkest Dungeon TTRPG.

2
necrothe•

It looks amazing!! fantastic idea

1
I_love_Beef_Jerky•

I was actually thinking about how to turn DD into a tabletop game too, and after some thinking i thought it would be easy to convert DD into uni system (Afmbe namely, All flesh must be eaten ) . I know its not DnD but i found that if you do some minor tweaking and with the grim nature of Afmbe, I thought it would capture the nature of the Darkest dungeon.

1
AtlaStar•

Fear effects definitely need to be on here...being extremely frightened for multiple rounds is bound to stress someone out

1
dot_exeOPFighter•

Stuff like that is getting filed under "on my mind, but don't want the players to know all the things that will mess with them".

Fear of the unknown

1
Sadakar•

The spells Bravery and Becon of Hope should also impact stress in some way. Where as crown of madness and the various lovecract spells should increase it.

1
presto575•

This would be great if my characters would roleplay according to their stress levels.

1
dot_exeOPFighter•

I think the big key for me is going to be making sure I get the environment right. If they don't take it seriously it's as easy as making a brutal fight they have to run from or risk certain death.

If you haven't played darkest dungeon, do it. It will really show you how quickly things can go from perfectly fine to complete screwed in a matter of seconds

2
presto575•

I have played darkest dungeon and it is lovely.

It's amazing how you could crush one encounter and then have those characters you've worked so hard on be destroyed like they were nothing.

1
TalasDM•

I love this, it's brilliant! I'm going to steal this for my Dark Souls inspired dungeon crawl... and here I thought I was already playing with "prepare to die" in mind.

Let me know how it works in play!

1