What would you do?

So I just received an email from a company who is doing an investigation on patent infringement.


Hey ****,

Sorry to bother you but wanted to ask you a very important question. How did you purchase the *** knife sharpener? It would be greatly appreciated if you let me know about how you received the product with or without the amazon review…

We are the makers and patent holders of the original product the *** Sharpener. Your cooperation and giving me as much info as you can, regarding how you got an *** sharper will greatly help us out :)

There is currently an investigation going on with patent infringement and any help or information you can provide will assist. *FYI – you are not at fault for purchasing the *** product that infringes upon our patented product. Also you are not liable for anything regarding this matter so do not worry. Any information on your end will be greatly appreciated, even a one sentence reply.

I thank you for your time.

Very Best,

...

Please let me know if you have any questions or need additional information.


One part of the email that bothered me is; "It would be greatly appreciated if you let me know about how you received the product with or without the amazon review." <--- As I am not sure why that would matter?

Also, since this company contacted me through my profile page, which is accessible from the review I did on the product in question - it clearly says at the end of my review that I received the product free/or at a discount in exchange... blah, blah...

Anyway, I have mixed feelings about what to do, and wanted to see what you guys would do - if anything?

Thanks! :)

Posted Mar 23, 2016, 1:44 AM UTC

212
sneakyboi•

i cant help but think someone's desperate to find out where people get freebies to review from and thought of this ludicrous far fetched approach

7
really-i-care•

What this moron is likely trying to do is to figure out if someone is reselling. What I would do is ignore them completely and let them get their lawyers to laugh hysterically at them when they claim a patent issue. This isn't your responsibility, and I'd stay far away.

6
DDnutnut•

What would reselling have to do with it? Curious

2
really-i-care•

Because a few of them are under the impression that they are the only people who can sell their branded product. One of the coupon clubs even tried to scare people with that threat.

3
DDnutnut•

The sellers actually believe that? I thought it was just a scare tactic for them. Wow!

Anyone can legally sell anything they own.... Well, besides drugs and shit. I.e. Look at high end hair care products that say right on the bottle "only sold in fine salons". Lol. You can buy all of them at the supermarket for cheaper

2
OFUBOP•

Pretty much what I am thinking too, just to let them battle it out with attorney's etc.

2
Reapter•

Ignore it. First, they would be the worst investigator on earth by you messaging people in broken English. Also it would tip off everyone about the case by doing this instead of a C&D route. Second, if it was a real case they would just get the information from Amazon.

If you want, google the email address to see where it goes. I am going to guess not to an actual law firm/investigation service.

5
bluebell221•

Was it a unique product? Or was it like every other knife sharpener on the market? I probably wouldn't give them any information. They do say you can contact them with any questions and since I am kind of nosy I would ask them for more info on their patent and the investigation. Just to see if it's actually legit. See if they will give you a patent number and you can cross check it at the Global Patent Search http://gpsn.uspto.gov/

3
OFUBOP•

These types of sharpeners seem to be a dime a dozen on Amazon, some with 2 slots, and some with 3 slots.

2
Enfin_Mon_Dieu•

So if I understand this correctly, the email says you bought a fake sharpener?

If they think your sharpener is fake/patent issue, they can always buy one and deal with Amazon themselves.

I don't know if this is any sort of fraud or scam, but I would probably do nothing. I was thinking of forwarding it to Amazon, but if it's a competitor, that might cause problems for them, who knows.

1
OFUBOP•

Yeah, I found the email to be a little odd to say the least. And like you pointed out, why don't they just buy the sharpener themselves to pursue their investigation, rather than contacting all the reviewers.

3
SkittyScatty•

I would ignore it. If it was real they would be contacting Amazon directly and they would most likely send all correspondences via snail mail. I'm not sure what exactly the point of the email is but it seems extremely fishy. The fact that they started with 'Hey ****' is a huge tip off, no professional would address you like that.

1