Scorched Earth Theory. AKA "Escape From Konami"
So i've basically left the hunt for Chapter 3 of "Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain" as well as the search for clues in "Ground Zeroes".
Based on the evidence i've seen on this subreddit over the last year i've formed a theory about what Kojima intended for MGSV to be, and what Konami ultimately released.
We know that Kojima could have ended Metal Gear after Metal Gear Solid. Every subsequent title could've been "the last Metal Gear".
Kojima himself intended MGS3 and 4 to be the end of the series. MGSV is a chapter that chronologically takes place somewhere between MGS3 and the original MG.
Now Konami had reported in 2014 that their social network games were making about the same as their console market.
"Mobile is where the future of gaming lies." - CEO Hideki Hayakawa
So at some point in 2014 after the Console/PC division of Konami reported 44% profit drop, Konami's Executive board made some changes and appointed Hideki Hayakawa as CEO and Takuya Kozuki as President.
They see the profits being made on the social media side of gaming which is a lot less demanding as far as development goes so they decide to focus on that side of business in addition to pachinko, health and fitness, etc.
"As Jordan Amaro, a designer who worked with Kojima on Phantom Pain, put it, “Why risk producing pricey and sophisticated games in an age that favors indulgence in shallow, convenient entertainment?” Ryan Payton, who worked at Konami between 2005 and 2008, went even further. “We’ve seen the end of the console-game market in Japan,” he said. “Even by the time Metal Gear Solid IV shipped, in 2008, I felt like our team was one of just a handful of Japan-based developers who were still fighting to produce blockbuster games.”
Now it's important to remember that in 2008 there was the whole Lehman brothers thing which launched the financial crisis, credit crunch, and ongoing depression that has affected all forms of industry. Metal Gear Solid 4 came out in 2008.
Also it's important to remember that in Japan it is very expensive to develop any video game.
I believe the reason why Kojima continued to make Metal Gear after he was ready to move on is that if he didn't, someone else would come along and make an inferior Metal Gear tarnishing the series and ruining his continuity.
So for several years Metal Gear is relegated to the mobile market where derivative tales about Big Boss's exploits unfold on PSP. Metal Gear Portable Ops is cited as one of the weakest Metal Gear games. Kojima returns for Peace Walker.
When Konami calls Kojima and says they want a Metal Gear Solid 5 there's a clear financial purpose. MGS4 sold 6 million copies.
Peace Walker didn't sell well enough for Konami to say exactly how many copies were sold. A combined figure of "Metal Gear sales for the year" was released at 1.24 million.
If we look at the figures in this report from 2012 we can see that the consumer game sales drop from 2011 aside from Baseball and Metal Gear.
The report from 2013 shows a drastic drop in most consumer video game sales. Pachinko hangs on.
The report from 2014Shows another big scale down on production and profits in the video game market.
2015 is just as sad but shows that Metal Gear and PES hold their own as far as sales go. Konami has lost out on millions of copies it used to sell less than 5 years ago.
So throughout this from 2012-2015 Kojima is going through an estimated total of 80 million dollars creating a studio, building an engine, and generating hype hoping to sell at least as much as MGS4 which was made for 70 million dollars.
His game plan is to create an engine that Konami and Kojima productions can use to develop multiple games. But when the new guys on the executive board at Konami get into position their first job is to consolidate everything that keeps Konami profitable while eliminating excess.
Konami even delisted itself from the stock exchange to save 5 million dollars.
The executives cancel Silent Hills which leaves Kojima hanging. Kojima also has to cut out a lot of content from Metal Gear Solid V and maintain the storyline. Because of this, there are entire chapters missing from the game.
Perhaps Ground Zeroes was released as a stand alone game for 40 dollars to help fund the rest of the game.
The end result of this economic problem that both Konami and Kojima has is a compromised game that could have been greater than great. Kojima salvages the story and makes it even more dissociative.
At some point between 2012 and 2015 Kojima probably sees the writing on the wall and realizes that everything he has built is going to be closed down to maintain the rest of Konami. Kojima then prepares to depart and set up another studio to either Remake Silent Hills as a new game, or perhaps pursue something else entirely.
However, he can't leave Metal Gear behind to be tarnished so he makes a few decisions. He intentionally leaves as many openings for interpretation as possible while closing off the story lines that are concluded in MGS4. Thus leaving an opening for future Metal Gear games to take place in between MGSV, but without changing the final touches on MGS4.
In addition he leaves behind pieces of Chapter 3 that weren't finished to imply that there is more to the story even if there won't ever be a game to tell it.
Thus, Kojima finishes up Metal Gear as a project. MGSV remains a phantom of itself. A facsimile of a game that we didn't really play. The protagonist isn't Boss. The year probably isn't 1984. The entire thing may be a VR simulation beamed into Big Boss's head while The Patriots keep him in a coma.
This community has put forward hundreds of different theories explaining what is going on in MGS:V which i think is intentional.
“In MGSV, we hand the story (the legend) over to the player. That’s how the player becomes the Big Boss in the MSX2 Metal Gear. You play the game as you will, raise up your Mother Base. That’s the way I want the player to create his own story, thinking of things like “war” and “peace” as Big Boss. Up until now, the Metal Gear Saga was told by creating video games, but I want each player to think and come up with their own story (legend) on their own.” - Hideo Kojima Gamingbolt article
The two phantoms that were born from FOX (engine) are Silent Hills and Metal Gear: Solid 5.
They're not there. But their phantoms "P.T. and "Metal Gear Solid V" do exist.
"...Up until now, the Metal Gear Saga was told by creating video games, but I want each player to think and come up with their own story (legend) on their own."
TL:DR: The economic crash of 2008 and dwindling profits doomed MGSV from the start and ultimately stunted the production resulting in an incomplete product that Kojima turned into an open ended story. Its fragmented nature is a testament to Kojima's effort to produce the highest quality story he can present in a video game and falling short due to the reality of the real world. That is why there is no "Chapter 3" except in our minds. MGSV closes off the Metal Gear world and the need for another Metal Gear game since Kojima has moved on. If we feel like we need more Metal Gear, its up to us to come up with our own stories.
Edited for formatting
Posted Mar 26, 2016, 12:02 PM UTC · edited
Good thought, I wonder what the next MGS game ( made by Konami ) will be like...
heaven forbid a pachinko machine
h...hit the lever?
Louder! HIT THE LEVER! cracks whip
woah there this is getting a bit too kinky