Would you make this trade?

[removed]

Posted Mar 30, 2016, 3:00 PM UTC

115
pocket_infinity_•

Hard to assess when $100 is "mystery trades".

But generally, trading up into a NM/LP card on the reserve list seems like a win to me.

3
showstepsOP•

Thanks.

1
DarknessLeo•

Pile B is definitely better in my opinion. You get a large amount of value in staples.

2
showstepsOP•

Thanks,

1
DontGetMadGetGood•

I would rather the time vault for a long hold but feel the trader is asking too much.

Cardkingdom wants 530 for a vault, 540 for just the LED+Goyf. SCG wants 600 for vault, 510 for LED+Goyf(led out of stock I feel they'd ask for more once restocked) - TCG wants 470 for vault 430 for goyf+led. It gets a bit closer when looking at peoples asking prices on high end mtg and such but I feel you could realistically sell your pile for more than you could buy a time vault for. As you mentioned you dont need any of the cards I would recommend selling your pile and either buying a vault or sitting on the money.

2
showstepsOP•

Good advice.

Thank you.

1
goldpocketwatch•

time vault unlimited on tcg mid is 500. any reason why he wants 630?

1
NapkinZhangy•

Usually when people trade up a bunch of smaller value stuff for power/larger ticket items, the more expensive item demands a premium. It's like..if I wanted to trade a 3500 Lotus, i'd expect $3500 cash, around $4000 in higher-tier trades (Duals, FoWs, Goyfs, etc), or $4500 in random jank (bulk, lower end staples, etc). It's because traders who deal like that and who would "trade anything for anything if value matches" demand a premium when trading down due to the effort it takes to sell the smaller pieces.

4
goldpocketwatch•

i know the concept but a foil goyf and a lions eye is not standard trash. 25% seemed high to me is all.

2
DontGetMadGetGood•

I'd walk away from any trade where someone starts with "I value my cards 25% higher" unless they were taking literally any cards towards the trade.

I have people do it with dual lands all the time, thinking their $80 dual is worth more than a $80 modern staple when to buy either card off ebay or anywhere would cost you the same.

2
goldpocketwatch•

thank you. if it was eternal for standard. . i could see that. but its a foil goyf and a lions eye. both are high value cards of the same calibre as the time vault. if OP is ok with it then fine but it seemed unnecessary to me.

1
Shitposters•

I see people asking 500 for a time vault, 300+ for a foil goyf and 100+ for LED.

I think if OP sold his pile of cards he could probably afford a time vault + pocket some change, but it's whether he wants to do the trade or go through the hassle of finding buyers and then a seller for all cards involved.

2
showstepsOP•

Thanks for the response :)

1
showstepsOP•

The reason for the $630 was that the only NM copy on tcg mid was around $750 from a seller. And checking other places, they didn't have one in stock, and from the looks, tcgmid still have an oldish mid price i'm assuming.

1
goldpocketwatch•

but the card is not nm. its not a huge deal, just seemed odd at the time.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1