Opinion: Satisfied yet underwhelmed PvPer's rant and seemingly inevitable departure
Let me start by saying I've really enjoyed my time playing The Division, I did little research on the game and purchased it with few expectations. Historically I've disliked most of the 3rd person shooters that I've played. I assumed this would eventually drive me crazy, and I've been pleasantly surprised to barely notice it. So all of my observations are inspired by constructive criticism, and not complaints stemming from buyers remorse. My experience thus far has been well worth the price I payed for the game, but as I'm quickly approaching Dark Zone Rank 50, I can't help but notice the storm brewing ahead. As I sit upon the precipice of The Great Division Tech Grind, I can already feel my patience waning.
[TLDR this section: Long time FPS player, Long time PvP-centric MMO player] I've been playing First Person Shooters since Duck Hunt was released, and although I play a variety of genres, shooters stand head and shoulders above the rest for me. I've been been playing the Battlefield series since it's inception, and liked the Delta Force series before that. I enjoy the quick games and semi-structured combat that these types of games have, but I've always longed for an open world shooter. I picked up World of Warcraft a few months after it was released and immediately fell in love with the gear progression and how dynamic the combat was. It wasn't my first, but we all know how impactful that game was on the MMO industry. They found such a wonderful balance between Player versus Player combat, and Player versus Environment content. It was so clear why you were gearing up your character in WoW; whether you were into PvP, PvE, or both. The Division has the potential to bridge the gap between my two favorite genres, I've only realized this after playing it for a few weeks and getting to know the mechanics.
Games that are overly bullet-spongey generally turn me off, and I think Massive has done a good job of incorporating movement in combat with deployable gadgets to minimize this and keep combat fun and engaging. The variety of weapons and attachments for the launch of the game seems totally sufficient, and the lack of balance isn't surprising and shouldn't be condemned too harshly. Beta testing can only give them so much perspective into the disparity of gear between the most devoted and the most casual of players. Challenge modes are a lot of fun, but only if your group is in the Goldie Locks zone of gear score. Get yourself into a PUG of fresh 30s and you're likely in for a bad time, run through with a group of moderately geared friends that are using Voice Comms and you just blow through them with no trouble. That Goldie Locks zone is really great though! The Dark Zone is a brilliant way to bring casual PvP into a PVE-centric game. Although it's mostly a farmfest, this early implementation of it does keep you constantly on edge and wary of all who you come across. It needs work, but I really think they tapped into something beautiful and ugly about human nature with the Dark Zone.
Matchmaking is a tedious and buggy process, it's so frustrating to constantly load in and out of zones as your groups bug out or can't start missions. We should be able to form a group, before zoning into an instanced event. There is way too much automatic switching of player location. Although I noted above that weapon balance is difficult to get dialed in, the over-abundance of SMGs and the Vector in particular is a massive oversight that is over the top. Grenades need to be easier to switch through and deploy, as a PC user I know I can set keybindings, but what's the solution for console users? In fact, every single interface is clunky in my opinion, due to a sorry ass effort to port the game over from console. I can't be the only person that took one look at the CTRL and Spacebar keybindings and thought they were backwards? Spacebar to crouch, CTRL to go up and over...have the developers never played a PC game before? Also, Hackers. I won't go into detail, but the worst thing about this game has to be the lack of end game content. Who looks forward to playing Box Opener 16', and to what end? Incursions hardly seem like they'll be much of an improvement from Challenge Mode, they just lack some margin of error.
Larger scale PvE content is what this game needs, difficult bosses that force camaraderie among players. I always enjoyed raiding in WoW, whether it was 10 man, 25 man, or 40 man raids. It was a surmountable hill to climb that took knowledge, preparation, and a coordinated effort to complete. It offered a mix of randomized rewards, that would eventually let you build the character you want. There is nothing even close to that in The Division, successfully completing the most difficult content only makes you glad your group didn't suck that time. This game seems perfectly suited for small scale arena or battleground style combat. It has a good mix of defensive and offensive abilities, where most shooters heavily favor offense. The Dark Zone is really cool, but I'll never be comfortable being a Rogue, as it really doesn't jive with my altruistic nature. I'm not a ganker, no hate to those who are. Don't change the Dark Zone, just give us some form of structured PvP combat that is a semi-level playing field. Everybody has their cooldowns available, is aware of the battle and prepared for it. Just give me some reason to continue building my character. Massive, throw a dog a bone...that he can use to hit other dogs.
For anybody who read this and doesn't share my opinion about the end game grind, or thinks I was destined hit a wall because this game was never meant to provide me with the things I normally find enjoyable in a game...I get it. I can't know what their priorities are, or what they have in store for us down the line. I just see a lot of potential for this game, all of which was garnered while playing the game, not just hype about the game. At this point I'm glad I didn't buy the more expensive season pass like I normally do, as they've provided little in the way of replay value. There is not much to look forward to in terms of player engagement beyond 4 player PvE, and occasionally fun but generally avoided small scale Dark Zone PvP. There has been a lot of criticism of Massive's apparent long term vision for this game, or lack there of. They have a game top notch game engine, that I get the impression is capable of handling 8 or 12 man Incursions or PvP battlegrounds. Which seems to be an obvious direction to go with such fun and dynamic combat. There was recently a list of community suggestions that the developers are aware of, without indication of if/when they might be implemented. This is a fantastic showing of community engagement by Massive, merely acknowledging the suggestions should be applauded. However, missions or incursions larger than 4 players are curiously omitted from the list. I'll be keeping an eye on this game regardless of how I feel after hitting the Div Tech wall because "Competitive team v team mode" is on the list. I think the community just wants some assurance that there is a plan and a prioritization to have bigger and better end game content for at least one, but preferably both PvP and PvE to make this a prominent game in the industry.
TLDR: PvP Battlegrounds and/or Raids please
Posted Apr 4, 2016, 8:59 PM UTC
Great post. It's a sentiment shared by many here. I loved my time in The Division but even my casual ass is at the dreaded Div Tech Wall and that just can't be it.
I agree with your ideas as well, from balance to new activities. Just a well written post, glad I read it.