Does it make sense to get the Wii U version when I have the 3DS version?

ssb4

I have seen similar posts of people asking if they should get a Wii U just for Smash, or people asking about differences between For Glory on the two systems, but nobody comprehensively sharing an answer to my question. If it has been answered a link would be appreciated.

A couple of months ago I decided to get into the Sm4sh scene. I had played a lot of N64 and Melee in college, even went to a few Melee tournaments but was never super competitive. I attended a tournament for Sm4sh without owning the game, and not surprisingly I got annihilated pretty bad. Someone suggested I pick up the 3DS copy since they are basically the same game. I did so, found a main in Cloud, learned several match-ups and basic spacing vs many common characters.

I did see an improvement the next couple of times I went to locals. However, I noticed that I played significantly better after warming up a few matches with a GameCube controller as I was mostly practiced on the 3DS. As I looked into the differences, I also saw some threads suggesting the caliber of player on the 3DS is usually not as good as on the Wii U.

Money is not a concern for me really, I have an engineering degree and a stable job. I would have to buy a complete Wii U but that isn't really an issue. What is a concern, though, would be wasting money on something that does not really get me better. My girlfriend was laughing at the fact that I would purchase a console just to play a game I already own on another console.

The majority of me playing the game is online (3DS). I've only gone to locals a handful of times. Obviously one choice is to continue practicing on the 3DS and keep attending more local tournaments until I become more comfortable on the Wii U. I could also try to meet up with friends to play on their Wii U, but with a full-time job, a GF and hobbies in addition to my friends living in different cities its hard to meet up.

So to summarize my question is this: is it worth it to get a Wii U if all I'm planning on doing with it is play Smash and I already own a 3DS, just to get more competitive? Or would I really just be wasting money for little to no benefit?

Posted Apr 7, 2016, 7:24 PM UTC

012
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
sourmilkandcereal•

It's your money man do what you want with it. I say it's better have at least 10 other games or so that you would like to play. The Wii U has a lot of gems.

1
JennaZanthow does one smesh broz•

If you're really interested in competitive Smash 4, get the Wii U version. It's much better for competitive play, as you can use better controllers and there's much better stages.

1
goatpath•

Lol, I am in basically the same position, but with one major difference: I play with my friends on their wii U all the time. I have to say, if there are differences in the game mechanics, I can't tell. I have the 3DS version and I feel like I can switch right over to the gamecube controller no problem.

I am also bad, but I usually take games off the nerds at the local place, and occasionally I win a set. That's all I want, so yeah. Don't buy a Wii U just for Sm4sh. If you want to get better, you have to play against people anyway. The best players go to the local place (I think we can all agree playing against the best players makes you better), so if you find yourself wanting to go there all the time, just go there and 'get gud' as the saying goes.

1
dakattack101OP•

Well one issue is that my locals is about an hour commute away and only once a week. In addition I can't make it out every single week so it seems like it will be a long uphill climb to get to the top players level at my store just by showing up each week. I don't mind where I'm at RN which is winning some sets but getting 2-0 smacked by the top 5 or 10 in our store but I want to be at the point where I feel confident enough to go to big tourneys.

I feel like the Wii U will bring me to that point quicker but I may be wrong.

2
goatpath•

Yeah, it sounds like you should buy one if your goal is to attend large tournaments.

2
Reddit_overload1•

I think the 3DS version doesn't have the rage mechanic.

Never mind I'm totally stupid.

1
JSConrad45•

It does.

1
Reddit_overload1•

Really? Did they patch it in, because I remember somebody telling me that was the only gameplay difference. Thanks for the correction, though.

1
JSConrad45•

It's always been there since launch. You can find posts of people complaining about it before the Wii U version was even released.

There are a few gameplay differences, though. The blast lines are slightly closer on some Wii U stages compared to their 3DS counterparts. Wii U Pikmin don't desync as often (sometimes 3DS Pikmin start the match desynced) and will carry items to Olimar. I think there's some differences in collision data on BF ledges between the two also, or at least there used to be.

1
Cidalfos•

Smash on Wii u is very shiny. Also Wii u has many other good games. And if your girlfriend makes fun of you just play the pokemon theme at her. Cause that will work. Well, the first line anyway.

1
Hitokage_Tamashi•

The mechanics of the game itself are the same, but the Wii U version is definitely superior to the 3DS, and honestly, having it on Wii U would probably improve your play style some. The gamepad is surprisingly a really good controller for Smash, and the Wii U version definitely feels more...responsive. It's also where more of the pros will play (the Wii For Glory is definitely harder than the 3DS, there are a lot more skilled players there), and since tourneys are done on Wii U, you'll be adjusted to the controls

1
Evello37•

I have the same problem even though I actually have both versions haha. I just don't have the opportunity to sit down and use the TV for multiple hours very often, so I end up mostly playing 3DS.

Getting used to the GCN controller definitely takes a while, so you WILL perform better in the Wii U version if you practice on Wii U. That said, it won't be a huge difference, so I would make sure there are other Wii U games you are interested in before dropping that much cash. If not... I wouldn't bother unless you're really planning on attending lots of tournaments.

1