Graphical change in 4 years

Posted Apr 9, 2016, 1:36 PM UTC

Posted Apr 9, 2016, 1:36 PM UTC
Also in 2016 - the actual proper picture you should have used: http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/runescape2/images/b/bc/Refined_Anima_Core_of_Zaros_armour_equipped.png/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/112?cb=20160401194239
pathfinder armor
everything in solomon's
Not everything, just the stuff since they started using the texture-reliant style. The older Solomon's stuff looks fine.
yes
texture mapping also tells me they got way lazier than polygon mapping
The armor texture still looks extremely stretched and blurry in that picture. So disappointing.
Perhaps. We'll see how it looks in NXT, where it was designed to be shown, as opposed to a white background. That's much more important.
Most fancy looking armor looks like that in game, and I didn't see anywhere advertised in the description of NXT as "character model and armor revamping."
Model won't change but the higher resolution textures that become available should ameliorate some issues.
The armours that depend on textures to provide the illusion of depth are still going to look a bit flat though, I hope that new technology JaGeX teased will fix that issue.
Lighting and such makes a pretty big difference. Reserve your judgement for the 18th.
Has anyone from Jagex SAID these things will look better in NXT? Because I see a lot of fans defending this shit without a quote or source.
Also, no, background isn't important. The things people are saying are awful about these new armors won't go away with window dressing.
It's not that they will look better immediately in NXT. Java restricts textures to 128x128 which is why a lot of new stuff looks so blurred and stretched. Nxt doesnt have this restriction meaning that devs have the freedom to rip off those crappy 128x128 textures and reapply them how they were supposed to look at a later date.
It also means that future updates arent designed with this restriction in mind.
and yes they have said, on countless live streams as well as a recent nxt dev blog.
http://services.runescape.com/m=forum/forums.ws?16,17,987,65768282
I can't wait for NXT, i experienced it a bit the other day when it was on beta for some players. I didn't have time to experience everything :(
Look at vindictor's armor texture (3 dimensional) versus the actual armor that looks like paint on a piece of plastic ( 2 dimensional)
It's so slimming lol.
Kinda wish they would go back to making detailed 3d models instead of trying to add depth to textures.
Aren't newer armours specifically designed to suit NXT
And way to go OP, purposefully choose a shitty pick of the anima armour for dat karma
Well, they were going for less polygons used but still retain the detail, like how they did with the godswords graphical change. This post from last year explains the change from the godswords, going into how the old system used 9 separate textures just to make up the weapon, while current method only uses two.
Edit: A more accurate look would be the modern sara godsword with the old method and also comparing it to the concept art
just to elaborate on this, old method used to texture specific polygons and used polygon shading for colour, new method uses texture wrapping on model uvs which is far more efficient but is subject to blurring when textures are low res.
[deleted]
blurscape
Arma at least has the same colours , Zaros needs to be more green
Do people complaining about blurry textures play the game fully zoomed in? The textures are fine at half zoom, or further. And older, polygonal models look terrible zoomed in as well when if there's any sort of animation... The newer, texture-oriented models can be improved and scale better than the older, mesh-oriented models. You can increase the size of a texture, or use normal maps, or create better materials, but you can't do the same if such features are baked into the geometry itself.
And OP's comparison is terrible, regardless. The armor looks good, especially refined, and especially if you have other gear. And Vindicta is tiny compared to Kree'arra, so less detail is necessary. Do you also complain when the bricks in a cathedral are less detailed than a large stain-glassed window in some FPS? So why did you not compare something of comparable size... like Vindicta and Gorvek? If you think the duo looks worse than Kree'arra when considering graphical quality (not aesthetics or design--those are too subjective)...
If the textures were larger, all these complaints would be pointless anyway. It's absurd to blame the artists for the small textures, too; they would create much larger textures, so what they create and what we see after the model is integrated into the content pipeline would very much be different. The crappy rendering pipeline used by the Java client is to blame.
Actaully there are two problems here:
Fixing one doesn't automatically fix the other, and may in fact make it worse. Right now the game feels like it has two art-styles: one where it's heavily modeled, but not as much detail applied to the models, and another where it's lightly modeled with a heavy reliance on texturing to make them look good (which currently fails due to the low texture resolutions). Even if they do get higher resolution textures, those new models are still going to look painted-on, and are still going to be jarringly different than the older models.
IMHO they should have stuck with one art-style, rather than introducing a new one solely because it's easier to do things with (IE: They are lazy).
But the new god wars dungeon is a terrible example to prove that point because it actually has a really cool set of models for the textures to rest on.
RuneScapers have a terrible understanding of "lazy" and "hard"... You are no exception. Using textures rather than models that warp because of integer-based coordinate snapping is not lazy, it's what game developers have been doing since, oh I don't know, more flexible fixed function pipeline around the turn of the century? And let's not get started on when programmable graphics hardware became mainstream...
And what art style do you want? There's much more than "two". Let's see... This one, from 2004? Or this one, from 2005? Or maybe a slightly cleaned up, but otherwise untouched, example (or this one, or this one, or...) from 2004 or so as well? How about the "RuneScape HD era"? Or maybe the post-HD-era-with-pre-HD-graphics? Or do you want more examples?
Don't let nostalgia blind you--the entire game has been a mishmash of styles soon after 2004. So much content will never be graphically retouched, no matter how many new clients come out, and will look as crappy now as they did back then. Truly making RuneScape a modern, coherent game (graphics or gameplay) would require such a large overhaul they might as well call it RuneScape 10.
But let's talk like we know what's going on! So many experts on programming languages, software development, computer hardware, rendering, game development, and on and on in this subreddit... Never ceases to amaze me.
Ultimately it comes down with what Jagex will do with it.
If it's more ugly-as-fuck painted on textures (even once they get enhanced capabilities), then they should drop the style like a rock.
Yes the game has many different styles over the years, but ultimately I think they were actually doing a good job of keeping a certain feel about the whole thing up until they started using textures.
And yes, moving to something to "save you work" at the expense of "how it looks" is an example of lazyness until proven otherwise: Which will take something posted by Jagex themselves showing off the enhanced capabilities of the new client to actually quell anyone's discontent about the whole matter. No amount of "this is how everyone does it now" is going to make us believe that "Jagex will do it well", because for the most part they've been failing at it.
Wow, why are the graphics of armors so much worse now? The textures are absolutely atrocious. It's like they just took a texture and stretched it in Paint.
Very disappointed in how lazy the graphical artists are now. Even worse is that we were told that these new awful textures were made to look good in NXT...but they didn't look any better in the NXT beta...
They look stretched because they are stretched. Its been stated before that newer updates have very intricate and detailed textures that are compressed to shit due to the java client restricting textures to 128x128 pixels.
NXT doesnt have this restriction. Once java is killed, the devs have the opportunity to rip off the compressed crap and reapply them in the resolution they were designed for.
They should stop storing the 128x128s as jpgs then. That's where the ripply blurry shit comes in. That 128x128 arma texture looks fine, and it has actual 3d polygons shaping it instead of relying on a shitty texture.
Kree is like 4x bigger then Vindicta.
These armours weren't out for any NXT beta?
I'm taking about the texture system itself, not just this armor...
That's not the issue with the armour though. It's the lack of texture to it.
A lot of these textures look much better in NXT imo
But they really don't.
I doubt the Mahjarrat outfit would
for a Premier club exclusive, it looks lame.
That outfit is hilariously terrible. Wow.
there not lazy! they just spend time on Solomon's rather than actual content...
Pretty much this, normal armour is purposely made to look underwhelming so you buy overrides instead. Shame.
Hey you dropped your tinfoil hat.
The reason for the apparent "blurscape" is because the java client restricts graphical artists to creating textures that are compressed to 128x128 pixels. Because of this, older graphical updates relied on using several different textures to circumvent the restriction. This meant that while the 2012 GWD update is noticably clearer, it does make the models more graphically demanding, due to having a multitude of different textural elements.
As RS has evolved, developers have wanted to increase the look and feel of newer updates. This means things like larger, more immersive environments; and npcs with higher mechanics and more intricate animations. The problem is that this too is more demanding, so to counteract this artists have been scaling back the number of textures applied to an object that need to be loaded. This is why a lot of items and npcs in game right now seem to have this single texture wrap.
This focus on less textures however means that artists have a larger canvas to apply detail. For example, in a recent live stream it was mentioned that the devs used a new technique that allowed them to create textures but painting them directly onto the models, allowing for greater control and ease when applying detail.
However, java still restricts to 128x128, meaning all that detail and effort is lost due to compression.
With NXT this limit is reduced, meaning that devs have the opportunity to rip those crappy compressed 128x128 textures off and reapply them how they were intended.
However it should be noted that when NXT is released we probably will not see an immediate change in texture quality as this release is more about client stability. But the sooner we kill the java client the sooner we can have a game that looks and feels how the devs intend it to.
tl;dr https://www.reddit.com/r/runescape/comments/29tr0t/godsword_texture_comparison/
More like lazyscape, see examples: 1, 2, 3,4, 5, 6, 7. I linked the following because they all have a similar thing in common-- They're not just blank slates with textures pasted on to them, they all look and feel like actual objects and look nearly identical regardless of graphics settings where as texturescape items lose everything when you lower the graphics quality.
also they had some actual effort put into the 3d modelling, things nowadays are pretty much like colourful shirts
Yes. The problem I have with runescape nowadays is that everything just looks like form-fitting clothes to the character with different textures on top of them.
For example: http://runescape.wikia.com/wiki/Elven_warrior_outfit?file=Elven_warrior_outfit_equipped.png
It just looks like the character model has skin color that looks like clothes. This being compared to the 7 examples you posted where there's actual depth in the armor/clothes. Where it's 3D and not just a folded piece of paper with paint applied to it.
OK fam show us your graphical skills then
EDIT: also note that your 3rd example is using the texturing style they use now that you're criticizing
You aren't required to be better at something in order to criticize someone.
Thinking that is silly.
Theres a difference between someone telling them they could do their job better since we pay them, and doing it yourself not as a job/trained professional
[deleted]
It doesn't matter how high resolution a texture is(or will be in this case). If it doesn't have a good model to be applied to, then it still looks noticeably worse than one applied to a more detailed model.
Also he intentionally used the non refined variant of armor.