[Spoilers S3] Biotech and Sundry - Chips, Flames, Genetic engineering oh my

SPOILERS S3

I think this might be a good point in the story to try to put together everything we know about how the AIs work in this universe. I'm just going to throw out a bunch of spoilery conjecture, but discussion of real science and sci-fi-world-science is also welcome!

THINGS WE KNOW ABOUT ALIE

  • Silicon body that appears to be some kind of base station connected to a power source

  • Independent consciousness

  • Remote connection to chip in host

  • Anyone can take the chip (as far as we know)

  • Chip is ingested and "reforms" on brainstem (what? nanotech, gotta be nanotech)

  • Programmed to require consent (gets around that)

  • Designed to help (but doesn't relate to humans on an individual level)

  • Survived some sort of "poison pill" virus

  • City of Light is some sort of digital repository/MMOG for the mapped consciousness of anyone who has the chip (only it seems to be only the stuff ALIE wanted to map)

THINGS WE KNOW ABOUT THE FLAME

  • Hardware implant (creepy tentacles)

  • Requires genetic augmentation/nightblood

  • Does not have an independent avatar (as far as we know)

  • Does not have an external power source (as far as we know)

  • Augments and amplifies the person, but doesn't take them over

  • The Conclave is some sort of digital repository for the mapped consciousness of anyone who has ever had the implant

On a basic level, it seems like the difference is ALIE is independent and the Flame is symbiotic. However, the way that Jaha and ALIE interact suggest that maybe it's a little more complicated than that. I think it is possible that ALIE is learning as she's assimilating in some dark manifestation of her natural programming.

I think the idea is that in the 97 years since the bombings, ALIE has self-created an upgrade to essentially the next logical step of its intended design. Becca said her mistake was giving ALIE sentience without binding it to a human for survival. She figured out the process in 4 years, so symbiosis with an AI hosted on a biotech implant must have always been the true goal of the project. I believe the difference between the 2052 and 2054 flashbacks was the development of the gene therapy black stuff that allowed the host to take the implant. It is interesting that so far it appears the ALIE chip does not require it. Some possibilities for why are nanotech, included gene therapy, or somehow the chip functions more like a dongle than an implant. I think it is interesting that ALIE referred to itself as having a silicon body. Are the chips implants like the Flame or are they more like remote connection points? I'm really curious about power and server space. Is it literally a Matrix thing where she's using human brains as a server farm?

The biggest difference to me is that ALIE is trying to assimilate many people at once, instead of a select few over time like the Flame. But maybe, ALIE still is designed to be in symbiosis with one person? I think the thing that Titus said about the Flame enhancing the person who was already there might also be true for the ALIE chips, at least for Jaha. It could be a feedback loop, where ALIE is bringing out the worst in Jaha by suppressing selective memories and in turn the worst of him is "teaching" it. The scene where ALIE took control of Raven like a meat puppet was really interesting because ALIE seemed almost surprised it could do it. I guess my question is did Jaha take the same chip as everyone else? He seems to have administrator control, but I wonder if that is just because he's our POV character. Something I also wonder about is the implications of ALIE spreading itself so thin. Is it learning everything from everyone? I guess I'm trying to figure out if it is a neural network or a singular consciousness overwriting.

The other interesting thing is the nightblood/Flame relationship. More importantly, why doesn't the ALIE chip need nightblood? One possibility is that ALIE figured out how to combine the Flame and the gene modification into one. This goes back to the nanotech possibility. If anyone has any ideas on how that could work, please elaborate. Personally, I'm about to get tinfoil hatty on you. Clarke pointed out in-universe that killing everyone with Nightblood except the new Commander sounds like a really fucking stupid tradition. What if it was to prevent ALIE from having people who could host it? ALIE said that Jaha was the solution to its problem. We assumed it was the power problem, but what if it was a host problem? On one hand we saw a non-Arker take the chip, but on the other he did have genetic abnormalities. It's fair to assume that Phase 2 is assimilating the Grounders, but we don't know that for sure. What I'm getting at is that it might be possible for one of the Delinquents to take the Flame.

What am I missing? I'd also love to hear everyone's thoughts on how the City of Light works. Basically, I'm just assuming Battlestar Galactica/Caprica rules. I wonder if "the Flame" has an independent consciousness or if it's more like a panel of "saved" previous commanders. I wonder if the Flame has a base station? It seemed self-contained...and not very sanitary.

Posted Apr 9, 2016, 6:51 PM UTC · edited

620
bananaforRTFM Clarke!•

ALIE requires a computer. Right now she exists on the Island, on the mobile server powered apparently by the nuclear power of Jaha's missile, and on the Ark's computers.

Flame is powered by the human body, and is removable. Its filaments retract when the magic word is spoken (so there's an off button).

Clarke has Flame's manual, probably written by Becca.

2
bubbles0luvBBF4L (ಠ‿ಠ)_人_(◕‿◕) •

ALIE requires a computer. Right now she exists on the Island, on the mobile server powered apparently by the nuclear power of Jaha's missile, and on the Ark's computers.

Don't forget, she's also powered by individuals. The more that take the chip the stronger she becomes, as we saw this past episode.

3
qkuc•

But ALIE needs the backpack as a "transponder"/wifi router.

That's why I'm curious how she wants to track down Raven, there must be a range for ALIE/backpack ...

5
bubbles0luvBBF4L (ಠ‿ಠ)_人_(◕‿◕) •

Maybe it's quantum computing?

1
qkuc•

Maybe, not sure.

ALIE itself seems a distributed system in "cloud", the question what the chip really is, what are the functions. Mini routers too (plus blocking the memory databank in brain, what else)? But it should mean it works with just a short radius, that's why the backpack and ALIE's "subsystem" must be near.

Other question, if the backback is needed, how on Earth does she send back "daa"/people to CoL to the main system in the house?

2
bananaforRTFM Clarke!•

What was the evidence that she was stronger?

1
bubbles0luvBBF4L (ಠ‿ಠ)_人_(◕‿◕) •

She or Jaha says it directly and she also was able to dispatch a large number of people by the end of the episode.

2
bubbles0luvBBF4L (ಠ‿ಠ)_人_(◕‿◕) •

It's interesting that Alie derives her power by bringing as many people on board as possible, while the Flame derives it's power by being placed in a position of power.

1
NatalieIsFreezingAzgeda•

Also the Flame is inserted at the back of the neck.

1
Artemis_BSkaikru•

do we know that the chip "reforms on a brainstem"? Was this mentioned/discussed somewhere?

In my mind I always thought of it as some sort of nano tech that enters bloodstream...

1
qkuc•

In my mind too, the spoiler from next ep makes me thinking, but at the end, nanobots could build a "center"? somewhere in the brain.

1
reddy2runfaster•

The Conclave is the duel between all night bloods for who will be the next Commander and not "some sort of digital repository for the mapped consciousness of anyone who has ever had the implant".

1
holayeahyeahOPYujleda•

That is possible. I did take a liberty there and assume the name "Conclave" was hint there was more to it. "Conclave" means "private meeting" or "council." I thought the new Commander is supposed to come out knowing the names of the previous commanders, but I could be wrong. It's entirely possible "The Conclave" is just the battle and the ambassadors simply don't know about the Flame implantation part. I was taking "the spirit of the commander chooses" literally, as in they all present themselves to the previous commander in some way. It could just as likely be the Grounders developed the children-battling-to-the-death thing independently as a means to choose who takes the Flame.

1
reddy2runfaster•

The part you are discussing is part of the "ascension ritual". Once the Flame is inserted, the night blood winning the conclave speaks the names of the past commanders (proving the Flame is within). The "choosing" is a belief but not reality. They believe that the spirit gives strength to the one most worthy (aka winning the conclave) but in reality, it's not. The Ambassadors must know about the Flame as Roan knew about it. It's interesting that Javi said no one knows about the Flame but the new Commander and Titus yet in 309 & 310, that is obviously not that case. Everyone seems to know about it.

1
Roasdf•

I think the purpose of the nightblood is to biologically continue the line of commanders. I don't believe it has anything to do with the flame accepting or rejecting its host. Its purpose is to work like a placebo that simply keeps the grounders from inserting the flame into anyone that they want. What makes me think this is that Becca had a few of that black stuff, and I assume she injected it into certain people of her choice, to get a biological chain of nightbloods started. Also, if the flame attaches itself to the brainstem, then I assume blood has little to do with how much control the flame asserts.

But just because it is a placebo for the flame, that wouldn't be the case for Alie. What if what Alie is looking for isn't necessarily the second AI, but a way of attaching better to humans, by way of nightbloods? It makes more sense since Alie's chip is ingested and eventually makes its way into the bloodstream.

Aside from being a placebo to prevent grounders from inserting the flame into just anyone, I believe nightblood is a way for the writers to (figuratively) connect the mind and heart in the AI world - nightblood is to the flame what the heart is to the mind. And I'm using heart in the figurative sense. Perhaps it is a way for the writers to connect the logical and rational flame to the emotional human.

1
icatintheboxFloudonkru•

I read a theory somewhere about how the nightbloods might be simply a "firewall" to keep Alie 1 away. It was something like: either Becca used it to hide from the evil AI and every nightblood can host the flame without Alie knowing where it is, or nightbloods have a defense against Alie 1 (so, a nightblood cannot be controlled by Alie)...I don't remember exactly now :p

Edit: With this theory, anyone could host the chip.

1