What sounds would a humanoid creature with no tongue nor teeth be able to produce?

Question

I'm asking this both out of curiosity and because it very may well be an interesting idea to start off my conlang/worldbuilding adventures with.

Imagine a regular human being, completely normal in every way except for the fact that the human's tongue and teeth are gone. Which IPA sounds (or maybe even non-IPA sounds) could this modified human create?

  • Consonants are fairly obvious: all the labials ([m b bβ β ⱱ̟ ʙ] and their devoiced counterparts, as well as [pʼ pɸʼ ɓ ɓ̥]) would be fair game; some of them (especially [p]) could have distinct aspirated/unaspirated forms.

  • Glottal consonants would also still work, so that's [ʔ ʔh h]. (I'd rather stay away from distinctions based on creaky voice/other phonation, though. No particular reason, just a personal predilection.)

  • Would [ʘ] be possible? It's called the labial click, so it seems like it should be, but when I make it I can't tell whether my teeth are involved as well.

  • About vowels: Without a tongue, I'd presume that only one vowel sound would be able to be made. What would this sound be? [ə]?

  • Are there any other sounds (in the IPA or otherwise) that this tongueless, toothless human could make?

Posted Apr 13, 2016, 11:41 AM UTC

2217
HwelltynnassaneCarnilyllian, Ereran, Huchuchurrish, Happish, (no, en) [es, la]•

Obviously all the labialized versions of the sounds you have already provided, so w m̥ʷ mʷ pʷ bʷ ɸʷ βʷ pɸʷ bβʷ pʷ' ɸʷ' pɸʷ' ɓʷ ɓ̥ʷ ʔʷ ʔhʷ hʷ.

(Prenasalized versions of all of these of course too. mb mbβ mp mpɸ mɓ mβ mɸ et al).

ninja edit: silly me forgot that the alveolar lateral does infact make use of the tongue.

6
KeyboardFireOP(en)[jb]•

[w]? Isn't that coarticulated? Otherwise, yeah, that makes sense; thanks!

3
HwelltynnassaneCarnilyllian, Ereran, Huchuchurrish, Happish, (no, en) [es, la]•

hmm yes i suppose. there are various types of labialization anyhow, so im sure you could get around it somehow! :D

2
gokupwned5Aanglisj, Sonzewüyu Languages (EN) [ES]•

Use the labial approximant or, β.

5
HwelltynnassaneCarnilyllian, Ereran, Huchuchurrish, Happish, (no, en) [es, la]•

^This

1
lanerdofchristianSaan, cofl.github.io (en)[--]•

For consonants, I feel like the ones you have listed plus the pharyngeals are the only ones that'd work. For vowels, you could probably get at most of the non-central ones (not ɨ, ʉ, ɵ, etc.) with ease (though not impossible to pronounce), and the only area of difficulty being some of the vowels at the points of the chart that are usually pronounced with a bit of tongue, i.e. /i æ/. I, of course, have my tongue and teeth, so I cannot back these claims with evidence, but some practice was involved in finding them.

3
KeyboardFireOP(en)[jb]•

Hmm. Aren't pharyngeals articulated with the tongue root? In any case, even if they are possible, I might wind up excluding pharyngeals/epiglottals only because I find them insanely difficult to pronounce.

I was previously under the impression that vowels are distinguished only by the position of the tongue. Is this not the case? How could different vowels be produced without a tongue?

Thanks for your input!

2
lanerdofchristianSaan, cofl.github.io (en)[--]•

Rounding, mostly. A great deal can be accomplished with just varying amounts of openness. If you've ever seen I think it was Artifexian's video on vowels, tongue positioning is a convenient white lie as to how vowels actually work, as well.

7
chrsevsSiḷa (en,fr)[et]•

You can have /ə/ with length distinctions as /ə/, /ə:/, /ə::/ and also with other qualities like nasalization, breathy and/or creaky voice (though I saw you didn't want to use them). I'd imagine diphthongs are also possible by switching from one variant of /ə/ to another like unmarked > nasalized, nasalized > creaky.

Also as far as consonants, you'd also be able to use the voiced glottal fricative /ɦ/. Even still, while they may not have teeth, if they have a ridge or gumline or protrusion in their oral cavities, you could have an equivalent of bidental consonants /ʭ/, /h̪͆/ and /ɦ̪͆/

4
KeyboardFireOP(en)[jb]•

Right, I'd also been considering phonemic length and tones. Bidental consonants look interesting; I'll be sure to take a look at those too!

2
chrsevsSiḷa (en,fr)[et]•

They're fun, but the percussive hurts my teeth haha

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Jafiki91Xërdawki•

Phryngeals are indeed made with the tongue root, but eppiglottals could still work.

The vowels you can get roughly central vowels with a few heights just by opening the mouth more - /ɨ ə ä/ . You can then add in rounding, nasalization, length, tone, and voicing distinctions to get a surprising number of vowel sounds.

Something important to address from your original post is that clicks wouldn't be possible since they're made by using the tongue to rarify the air in the mouth to get the suction to produce them. An ejective would be possible though.

2
SpitalianKwroxwkaxw•

The labial click doesn't work because you have to make a rear velar/uvular closure with your tongue. I think the only vowels would be /ɑ ɒ/.

3
culmaer•

what do they have in place of teeth : a gum-ridge, or does the mouth just flatten into the palate directly from behind the lips ? cuz then maybe you could also have "labio-gum-ridge" consonants (an analogue of the labiodentals)

3
NurnstatistSk'jind en Silare (DE) [EN, FR]•

They could probably make two vowels, a rounded and an unrounded one.

2
Kenley(en) [es]•

They have noses as well, so your vowels or consonants could have nasalized counterparts. That gives you at least four distinct vowel sounds, with rounding and nasalization.

I also think you can get different vowel heights by opening or closing the jaw. Mostly closed gives something like [ə] and all the way is more like [ɛ], if you keep your tongue as out-of-the-way as possible. Then you have 8 vowel possibilities, not including length or tone!

2
Everspace(en)•

Raspberries, whistles, pops.

1