Clarification on harmonic mixing
i am familiar with keys and the Camelot wheel in general but ive been super confused lately.
at first i believed you need to go 1 up or 1 down so if youre at 6a you can go to 5a or 7a4
then i heard you have to go either two up or two down so if youre at 6a you can go to 4a or 8a. which to me makes sense because 6a is G minor and 4a = F minor , 8a= A minor
and then i went to this record shop and this guy was telling me you can go either 3 up or 3 down and i dont quite understand the logic behind this.
after that i heard you can go 5 down so if youre at 6a you end up at 5a so thats like going half a step down.
im just very confusd because i dont know when to use each of these. like if im at 6a i dont know if i should go to 7a 8a 4a or 1a .
also how do i make sure that the keys that are given to me by serato are reliable? is there any way i can check for myself ?
thank you in advance for bearing with my scatter mind
Posted Apr 14, 2016, 2:58 PM UTC
Harmonic mixing is a guide for you to use when looking for songs that will mix well together for extended fades, shifts in mood/feel, consistency, mashups etc. It is not a "can do this, can't do that" hard and fast rule set.
Once you move away from same-to-same, eg Am-8A to Am-8A or C-8B things aren't as certain to say "yes this will work" or "no this won't work". It really depends on what notes are dominant (other than the root) on the outgoing track, and what notes are dominant on the incoming track, so you can align (same note) or harmonise (good sounding complementary notes) with them. You can generally assume that dominant notes in an intro or outro will be in in the key that the song is in, but unless you have a good ear for intervals or perfect pitch you may still need to experiment to get a transition that sounds and feels right - which is part of the magic!
Like take Am-8A. A natural minor is all the white keys on the piano, so Bm-10A, Cm-5A, Dm-7A, Em-9A, Fm-4A, and Gm-6A all have a good chance at having some good melodic compatibility - although unless you are going same to same you are unlikely to be able to get the basslines to coexist. A lot of it comes down to what feels and sounds right so experiment.
If you have the time/ability, key your tracks by ear rather than autodetect, as the auto stuff in software is often wrong (DJ techtools did a good writeup on this a while back) and for some tracks it's arguable what the root really is. Keying by ear also allows you to flag dominant exit and intro notes individually for key changes. A comment on your track might be "Am-8A, exits on Cm-5A or Dm-7A". Keying by ear is great practice. I use this goofy thing and bash notes until I find the one that feels right as the root:
http://www.bgfl.org/bgfl/custom/resources_ftp/client_ftp/ks2/music/piano/index.htm
Learning some music theory (if you haven't already) can be helpful. Also don't let key limit you. Does every line in a vocal have to rhyme? No. Similarly not every transition needs to follow harmonic rules. Key is only one dimension of compatibility. Don't let it limit your ability to get to the right song at the right moment.
thank you for your detailed comment
i think what i needed clarification on is that harmonix mixing is not a definite rule. I built this playlist where all my songs are edm and they are easy to blend but yesterday i couldnt do it because i was so overwhelmed today when i did it i chose tracks with the same key while yesterday i would try to go either up or down . i think now i have a better understanding of how to create flow but practice is key.
again thank you