How is he gonna get all his policies past congress?
People are grilling Trump for specifics on how he plans to pay for a 10 billion dollar wall... insinuating that if his "make mexico pay" plan falls through he would never get it past congress.
Liberals always complain about congress being a constant barrier for Obama. If this is such a problem, do you realistically believe that Bernie can get them to approve his multi-trillion-dollar socialist programs?
Posted Apr 15, 2016, 8:35 PM UTC · edited
Essentially what I'm seeing here based on the answers is: He doesn't know, but he is crossing his fingers that he can get some progressives in the house when they are hypothetically voted in by his supporters, and they will in turn support his policies. Sounds like risky, short-term thinking to me.
[deleted]
Remember though, as far as this "massive" movement is concerned, he would have to maintain that enthusiasm well past election season towards the congressional, senatorial, etc elections at state level to get those progressives in place. The fact of the matter is, there is a poor voter turnout among his supporters (largely college aged youth) and I can't imagine they would find themselves campaigning for local politicians. Even if they did, said candidiates would have to win, and do so nationally in large numbers so that their votes on bills don't just constitute like 3% of the vote and get thrown away. It just doesn't seem mathematically feasible to me.
At best in office I think he will raise taxes, pass some immigration reform, and work to socialize Obamacare more, but he needs to much political capital and support to get anything tangible done.
Poor voter turnout is a big problem, even in demographics other than young people.
Regardless of who gets elected, voter reform needs to be addressed. It should be faster and easier to vote, it should be easier to audit the count, and I think it should probably be mandatory. That's a whole 'nother fight.
I see your point, and please don't think I am a blind supporter. I worry about this too. I too am afraid it might lose enthusiasm after the election.
For me it's more about believing that the vast majority of people, if properly involved in the process, will make change to benefit the majority of people. Imagine a president whose main purpose is to include people in this process. I'd say that is better than any other candidate.
By the way taxes will only be raised on people making more than 250.000 dollars a year.
No, taxes will be raised for just about everyone. For the people making more than 250,000 per year, they will just be raised a lot higher.
This is a somewhat naive view. Most Congressmen have a hold on their district because it's so ideologically in favor of their party and it is hard to primary an incumbent who has the backing of the party. So while all House seats are technically up for election, a vast majority of them will not lose their seat.
Furthermore, even if Democrats do take back the House (which most analysis will tell you is an uphill battle by itself) likely over half those delegates will not agree on Sanders policies.Single payer healthcare? Not a chance. Obama couldn't even get Public Option in Obamacare, and it was Democrats who were the ones that gutted the Public Option, not Republicans.
Moreover, only 1/3 of the Senate is up for re-election this year and I think only 9 or so seats have a realistic chance of flipping blue.
Lastly, who are these candidates? Sanders has only publicly supported THREE Congressmen running and he did that this week. If he wants candidates to support his agenda, he's going to need to find people running that agree with them and help them win their primaries and then their districts.
Most House districts are also gerrymandered to shit and not competitive.
Basically, Bernie's part of a bigger grassroots project. You're right, we absolutely have to get new people into congress or else he won't get much done. A bunch of incumbent seats are up for re-election this year, so the timing is good. We'll have to take the momentum/resources developed for the Sanders campaign and turn them towards that end. There's a sub, r/grassrootsselect, that was started for that purpose.
Right now Sanderites are focused pretty heavily on campaigning to survive the primaries - if he makes it past those you'll likely see/hear more related activity for congressional campaigns.
A longshot, yes, but it's still a plan.
You mean once the primaries are decided for the downticket races? How does this get progressive candidates in? Would Bernie support less progressive Democrats in the general if it meant flipping the Senate and possibly the house (the latter is exceedingly unlikely you know...)
I'm not sure, I haven't heard much talk about it. Everyone's super focused on getting through the primaries right now.
Right and this is the problem when a protest candidate gains traction. He had no plan because he was never planning on winning.
Do you know how elections work?
He does know. He's the one that gave the call to action in the first place. He acknowledged that change can't happen alone which is something no one else will admit themselves. Clinton, or any other candidate for that matter, can't do anything beyond pro-corporate policies themselves so it's a false equivalency. The real change comes from changing the face of the government.
I understand your optimism and enthusiasm but like I said, his policies are to unfavorable, it's unfortunate but it's the fact. At the very least I'm sure Trump will be able to lower taxes and build the wall/increase the number of ICE officers or raise visa prices, little things like that which would be favorable and require relatively low political capital in the current republican controlled congress that Bernie would be torn apart in. His policies require to much overhaul and political capital/support, it's not remotely feasible.
What's ICE?
It's not optimism, it's realism. It's the only way to evoke change in government.
The Sanders campaign, or phenomenon, is an exercise in crowd funding democracy in this country. Kickstarter for President if you will. It's a template for the population to get the people into government that will work for them and not special interests. It began with Obama but at the same time he still raised a billion dollars at the drop of a hat via those very special interests and here we are today.
Everything you think Trump would be able to do will immediately be obstructed within congress by the Democrats just like you see happening today with the Republicans. That's not change.
Lastly, unlike Trump, Sanders has a history of finding common ground and getting things done within government. He's been an independent for decades after all that should be a given. Don't buy the memes.
Legitimate question, as I remember seeing a post about it. Can you link me to bills he has sponsored/co-sponsored that have been successful? What I saw showed me that he had a grand total of 3, and two of them were related to renaming post offices.
I wouldn't say hoping the Sanders "phenomenon" puts progressives into congress is realism. There may be a slight increase due to enthusiasm but not a realistically significant amount to pass any major bills. I don't mean to imply it's not the only way to evoke change in the government, he is doing something pretty extraordinary, but in the end I would think it won't be enough.
I do agree that Trumps proposals will be obstructed, but congress has majority republican support and his policies don't need as much political capital as sanders. I don't think his tax and immigration plan will come to complete fruition but I would say he will be able to lower taxes to some extent and reform immigration.
During one of the debates, I think the univision one, Sanders already threatened to use executive order if need be to grant the illegals in the country amnesty. I wouldn't call that getting things done with common ground. Who is to say he wouldn't do that with his other policies? At the very least Trump has ran his campaign on "I'm a unifier, I work with everyone, I get things done". If we're talking negotiation that has been his tagline almost, I have more confidence in him to be honest with you. I should make clear I'm an independent voter at the moment hence why I'm on this subreddit, trying to learn more about Sanders. Not impressed so far.