r/badpolitics•
Gweena

Reconsidering the Horseshoe Thesis: The role of syncretic explanations for the variation in electoral support for radical/populist parties?

Discussion

Hi All, After looking over the Top comments in this sub, I've somehow reached the conclusion that the Horseshoe Thesis has not been well received by the community. Under certain conditions though I believe this thesis can be adapted to show how some syncretic variables explain some of the variation in electoral support for 'radical' parties.

Taken from my post in ask_political_science...currently 1 comment :(

In exploring the broader phenomenon of rising anti-establishment sentiment in nearly every European democracy, I'm looking to re-examine the often criticized 'horse shoe theory' to find variables that could help explain the mutual rise of the 'radical' left and right. 'Radical' in this context is taken to mean those parties operating within liberal capitalism, as opposed to the traditional 'extremist' revolutionaries seeking absolute systemic change. Building on a 2008 study by March and Rommerskirchen linking unemployment, Euroscepticism, anti-globalisation, electoral system and the degree of political competition to the success of the radical left, there are a few of the same factors found within a 2015 study by Roodujin of the radical right. In sum, the right and left have their own topics of interest (immigration and inequality) but I see a considerable amount of overlap on these and others to the point where at least a few of them could be considered 'horse-shoe' like (taken to mean that they exist outside of the simple left/right dimension of the political spectrum).

My aim is to try and consolidate a list of such factors and use regression analysis to determine their statistical significance. At present, the syncretic factors I think help explain the rise of both political extremities are: Economic trouble/GDP loss, Euroscepticism, Urbanisation, Corruption, Immigration, Electoral system, Ethnic/Linguistic/Religious fractionalisation (Alesina 2014).

I'd greatly appreciate any comments/critiques, and to all the anarchists and fascists out there, I challenge you to be as savage as you can (you're all the same to me anyway).

Posted Apr 21, 2016, 2:28 PM UTC

2010
Volsungasuper specialised "political scientist" training•

Distrust in the status quo (the variable you're looking for) indeed causes a rise in far left and far right parties. However, that's not related to Horseshoe Theory at all. Horseshoe Theory is the idea that all ideas far away from the political center are fundamentally the same ideology. It's ridiculous because they choose an arbitrary metric to determine "sameness" that has no predictive power.

Ideologies don't exist "outside of the simple left/right political spectrum", since the spectrum is simply a grouping model meant to display how political actors make alliances and compromise on issues to pass mutually beneficial policy. Radical parties don't work with radical parties on the opposite side, but sometimes do work with non radical parties on the same side. Whether the radical parties have similar ideological features or stances on an issue is irrelevant to the model because they don't use those similarities to compromise.

You have the right idea in building a statistical model to predict ideological behavior. In fact, it's already been done and the Manifesto project database is one of the most renowned and useful tools in the field of Comparative Politics (and can be cross-referenced with the European Values Survey or something similar to answer your specific research question). It just has nothing to do with Horseshoe Theory.

54
Cookies12•

Wut. radical parties do work together in denmakr at least. Our semi communist party and our anti immigrant right winged party works togethere on a ton of things

1
TheWolfFateWorldwide Communist Gangster Computer God•

Which "communist party" would that be? Enhedslisten? KP? DKP? KPiD?

1
Cookies12•

The semi communist enhedslisten

1
TheWolfFateWorldwide Communist Gangster Computer God•

When exactly has Enhedslisten worked together with a right wing party?

1
PlowbeastKeeper of the 35th Edition of the Politically Correct Code•

While the theory may have some application, it's applied far too indiscriminately and simplistically on reddit as shorthand for those who simply don't want to learn what different groups stand for. Bear in mind the phrase partially came about only in the past 10-20 years as a way to describe anti-Semitism among far left and far right groups which glosses over the different rationales used. Virulent anti-Semitic conspiracy theories also find root among many who are "anti-establishment" including the generally apolitical.

I can't speak as to European politics as much as American politics but far left and far right groups here, including those that operate within liberal capitalism, have far more divergent grievances and platforms in part due to very different regional and demographic bases like the current OWS-Sanders base versus the Family Research Council. The current success of the Trump campaign is also another confound to horseshoe theory, at least for me, as it is a mix of old-fashioned nativism with anti-establishment secularism drawing on both independents and Republicans.

A regression analysis may help if your focus is European politics but I would caution against a continental-level look equally across the board as even groups on the same end of the spectrum with the same platform in different countries can have huge objections to each other which can throw off your results.

Also, you may find more answers to your question on r/asksocialscience as well as on StackExchange.

10
SnugglerificPersonally violated by the Invisible Hand•

As mentioned above, a simultaneous increase in far left/right politics is not horseshoe theory. The closest thing in reality might be Third Positionism. It claims to be "beyond left and right," but in reality looks like idiosyncratic forms of fascism or racial/ethnic nationalism and separatism. Third Position organizations do actively attempt to recruit from left-wing orgs, though.

8