Remember Tomorrow Land from last year, that film really annoyed me becuase it totally ignored the fact that logistics is an element of world building
Ok so the basic premise is that a bunch of smart people in the 19th century found a gateway to an alternate world and built a technological utopia there in the space of time between then and the 1960s.
In the movie's universe(s) all that's required to do this is for smart people to be allowed to do there thing unmolested by the rest of humanity. It totally ignores concern's like who actually makes the stuff? At the time film is set tomorrowland is clearly post scarcity so one could imagine all there building and spaceships are built by robots or something, but they had to become post scarcity in the first place which means there must have been a time when they weren't. At some point between the 1960s and the 1880s there must have been a time when they actually would have needed farmers, builders and bus drivers. But as I said it's implied in the film that tomorrowland was and always has been totally about nothing but innovating. In the movie's world it's apparently possible to invent and distribute things without having to worry about nitty gritty things like where are the materials going to come from and how is going to be cost effectively mass produced.
This is of course not the case in reality, you could stick the best engineer in the world on a desert island. He's never going to be able to make a WiiU because he simply doesn't have the equipment or the needed materials. For instance the WiiU is partially made of plastic, unless you have access to and the ability to drill for oil you don't get to have plastic.
The reason this annoyed me was because the movie's messages was about how we should all band together and fix the world. I think it's intellectually dishonest to have a message like this if you can't be bothered to actually construct a reality where fixing things works like it does in real reality.
Posted Apr 25, 2016, 11:35 PM UTC · edited