Found my first practical use for the circuit network
Posted Apr 26, 2016, 2:56 PM UTC
Posted Apr 26, 2016, 2:56 PM UTC
You should probably have put the description you put on youtube, here.
Oops.
Good job designing that yourself!
I can't figure out what the two splitters are for though, are they just remains of the old loading station that you didn't dismantle yet?
Here's a link to a design that's based on the same idea that was created by MadZuri. It's a bit more complex and a bit more performant, and it's based on calculating the negative average, adding it to the content of each chest and giving that as a signal to each smart inserter. The result is that each inserter only works when its own chest is below or equal to the average, which means it'll always be perfectly (to a reasonable degree) balanced.
I considered that idea as well but I figured that the performance improvement would be minor and not worth the extra complexity. I could always be wrong though as I didn't actually try to build it. The extra splitter here helps this version smooth out the distribution a bit.
Oh ok, I see what you're doing with the splitters now. That's actually pretty smart.
I like it
Nicely done!
Now, start thinking about how to improve your setup... you could split the output and load the train from both sides, for even shorter train stops. You could use more drills on the mine (placed side by side without spaces) to increase yield per pickup.
Eh, it's not a very big patch, hardly worth a train stop at all really. It was just my first train so I was playing around. I'm not concerned about maximizing the yield. That wouldn't necessarily even be an improvement if I didn't actually need that much copper. The sooner I mine it out the sooner I would have to tear it down.
This is quite clever. I like it.
Also, because you posted it on the internet, it's mine now.
your copper throughput is painful to watch.
It's a compact train loader using the circuit network. It loads the chests mostly evenly without needing a million splitters. The circuit is simple; the inserters don't load the chests while the amount of ore in the last chest is less than the average.
Did you come up with this on your own or did you get inspired by MadZuri's design? Yours looks very similar to his but with an extra combinator.
Either way, great work! You can adapt this for even unloading from smart chests, too, by switching from comparing your ore amount <1 to >-1 (might be the other way around, can't recall and not at my gaming rig right now). Let me know if you need screen shots, I'll try to post them tonight.
No, I actually hadn't heard of MadZuri or his design before someone here mentioned it, though I assumed I wasn't the first to figure this out. I haven't spent much time on the forums, mostly because I actually don't want to see those things in advance because then I lose the opportunity to figure them out myself. :)
My factory was pretty small and I don't think I had a need to keep the unloading distributed, but if I need to on my next game I'm sure I can figure it out; that's half the fun! Thanks for the offer though.