r/TEFL•
Mustafa413

TOEFL Preparation Effective?

I was wondering if anyone here knows of any research done on the effectiveness of TOEFL prep classes in Asia (you know the type–cramming sessions, basically, when kids are on vacation). Even classes in the US are kinda questionable based on the research I've read so far. Lack of qualified teachers, low-quality materials, etc.

I teach ELs in the states at an independent boarding school, and I have to deal with what seems to me to be a frustrating misconception among students and their families. They believe that the best use of their kids' vacation time is to spend every waking moment in TOEFL prep courses back in China, Korea, etc. Not only does this negatively impact their English proficiency in classroom and social settings (we're at a boarding school, so they're pretty much completely immersed during the school year), but it creates tension between my program and the students/parents. It's also just a shitty way to spend vacation for already stressed-out teenagers.

The reason for the tension is that they (parents and students) sometimes feel the work in my program is not useful to them because it's not TOEFL prep as they define it. I spend a frustrating amount of time explaining that being able to effectively read English and communicate through English writing will generally result in scoring well on the TOEFL. I argue that they should use the time and money spent on TOEFL courses back home on books and summer programs in the states. Proficiency is key, not memorization without context.

If the end goal for these students was to simply score well on the TOEFL, I would happily tell them and their families that they should hunker down in a TOEFL prep course for 6 months and then take the test immediately after it ends. However, I work at a school that takes the education and preparation of its international student population seriously. My program (I'm the director of the program) is focused on preparing students to succeed in our mainstream classes and at the US college level. I could not give less of a shit about TOEFL scores since all these kids are going to get into school if they want to study in the US. They have money, and that's really all they need at this point unless they're planning to go to a more selective school. And if that's their plan, they won't have any trouble on the TOEFL anyway (assuming they have a legitimate chance of acceptance).

So that's the deal. I have little doubt that actual English language instruction and improved proficiency is more beneficial to students (and their TOEFL scores) than rote memorization TOEFL prep. I have not found any good data or solid academic, peer-reviewed arguments as of yet, at least nothing that I could use as evidence in the eyes of the students/parents. I've looked a bit, but figured someone here might have some info. And if not, maybe I'll learn something from the conversation.

So if anyone can point me in the right direction as far as some good ol' peer-reviewed research on the topic, it would be much appreciated.

Posted Apr 27, 2016, 7:35 PM UTC

04
Loading comments…