Quote from Rivera: "Dave has a crazy idea that he (Butler) will play the right side"

This is from their post draft Butler interview last night and it doesn't appear to be getting enough attention.

I remember an interview not so long ago with Gettleman about how Rivera really likes a DL hybrid like Butler because it allows so much flexibility. To me the above quote is somewhat tongue in cheek, Rivera isn't showing all his cards. I view Butler somewhat as a Michael Bennet/3-4 end type hybrd. Plays end (or some UT) in normal sets. Plays UT or nose in pass rush subpackages.

Posted Apr 29, 2016, 12:04 PM UTC

3440
aussiePanther•

The quote I heard was "Dave has this crazy idea that you have to earn your spot", I'll look over the transcript and see what I missed

Edit: yep I was right the quote in the thread title here never happened. Only thing close to it was:

" Dave's got this crazy idea that he believes everybody has to earn their right. I think that's a great way to go about it. Just because he's a first rounder he's going to have to go out there and produce and if he doesn't then won't get a shirt on Sunday. That's just the way it is."

http://blackandbluereview.com/transcripts-dave-gettleman-ron-rivera-vernon-butler-2016-nfl-draft/

38
JDDuVall•

This should be top comment by a mile.

2
thabigmilla•

They do that sometimes now if you didn't notice. Sometimes they even line a DE as DT for a few plays. So drafting a prospect like Butler makes sense. Remember when our defense got tired in the 4th Qtr? Not anymore, great pick, great depth. Go Panthers!!!

37

College teams do this all the time as well so he may already have experience up and down the line

6
skippapotamus•

The idea is solid, though I'm still trying to figure how they're going to sort out Ealy and Johnson, too, both of which are more of a left end. Ealy would be the guy you move but he played well at left end in CJ's absence.

Butler on the edge wouldn't be unprecedented, actually before Bennett the Seahawks used Red Bryant as a DE, and he was a less flexible college DT, and the Ravens, then Chargers, used Jarrett Johnson, another DT, as an OLB in the 3-4 to the same result.

14
tarbender2OP•

i think it is all about the subpackages, how we want to attack an offense, mixing up looks. Meaning, sometimes in a long distance situation we'll blitz a LB or S/CB and we want a DL that will eat up multiple blockers, this is where a CJ/KK/Star/Butler lineup is scary. Or sometimes we'll zone and need an athletic type DL that can play in space (Ealy). Also, as dual threat mobile type QBs become more popular, guys that can maintain gap responsibility while closing the pocket become more valuable. IOW, sometimes a great DE beating his man (Ealy for example) and Russel Wilson spinning away and throwing from Ealy's gap is not as valuable as a Butler type slowly collapsing the pocket.

9
KobeCryant•

So excited for exactly the reasons you said. Butler is so athletic that he gives them all kinds of scheme versatility. He can line up at the nose and just eat a center's lunch, he can 3-tech and draw double teams or snake his way through gaps like KK, you can even stand him up and let him flow with the line. The name of the game now is versatility and this is a luxury versatility pick for us.

5
venom859958•

this is where a CJ/KK/Star/Butler lineup is scary.

Stop, I can only get so erect!

3
skippapotamus•

Right. I like the strategy involved in scheming but in the end, you have a set of players rushing from a set of gaps, and a set of players in coverage working together. The rest can be window dressing, and so the more a guy fits in different ways, the more value he has.

1
Dlh2079•

Ealy and cj have already played on opposite sides of the DL before. Also I think you move cj. He's the guy on the one year deal. Ealy is the future get him in his real spot and let him eat.

3
babyman21•

Yeah I hope this doesn't affect his playing time, though I doubt it will. My bold prediction for this year is that Kony will be the Josh of this season. Kony 2016. And we did need more depth anyway

2
Dlh2079•

Who's playing time cj or ealy. Cause ealy gonna get all the snaps as long as he's healthy. After that Superbowl and close to the season. Really think the switch has flipped for that man.

1
babyman21•

Ealy, I agree though. It just seemed like at times earlier last season he was under utilized

1
bythog•

Johnson is back for a year at most (his production has been dropping off). Butler could be a good long-term replacement for him, as well as being good in rotation this year.

3
endernyc•

Some people would've just been happier with any type of project DE, which we could still get. I think we got a guy that will get good rotation and should be a steady contributor in year one.

The game is changing and linebackers need to be better in coverage and I think we're looking at it like we need defensive lineman that can play inside and out so we can protect those guys and pressure up the middle bothers QBs more than anything. I know we want speed on the edge, but showing double a gap blitz is a staple for our defense now.

9
allsecretsknown1•

That wasn't the quote.

Rivera said specifically "Dave's got this crazy idea, everyone's got to earn the right [to get a jersey on gameday.]"

The quote is at 10:25 of this video: http://www.panthers.com/media-vault/videos/Gettleman-Rivera-Butler-is-going-to-help-us/4ae4cb2c-5f5f-447c-9384-122565f81262

They never discussed where Vernon will play or what his specific role would be. The context of this quote was establishing that, while they intend for Vernon to play immediately, he will have to earn his way onto the field, it won't be handed to him.

9

NFL.com video: Gettleman, Rivera: Butler is going to help us HD SD

2
Ttilldog•

Just added 10 more feet to our goal line defense. No one is ever getting over the wall!

6
Woooooolf•

Hopefully that's right, because this pick makes zero sense. IGWT.

-20
bluetick_69•

Sorry, I'm a little tired of seeing this reaction already and it hasn't even been 24 hours. The best drafting front office in the past 5 seasons selected him. He made sense to them. I don't really understand all of the concern. Last year, you could argue the last thing (after QB) we needed was a LB. Got Shaq. Went 15-1 after losing a 1000 yd receiver. What in the fuck are people complaining about here?

34
Woooooolf•

So I cant criticize the pick? I love Gettleman but lets not act like he cant be criticized.

4†
bluetick_69•

No, I understand it's just your opinion which is fine. And I'm not trying to jump down your throat. Don't take it the wrong way. It just gets under my skin that so many fans here are down in the dumps and are saying the pick doesn't "make sense", like we (including myself) have ANY clue what's going on. We have 5 more picks. Maybe Gettleman sees a 3rd rd CB that is a steal. I'll bet he does. Can you name the CBs left in the draft and give me the breakdown, upside, how they will fit into our system? I know I can't. The DEs left? The OLine? I have no fucking clue.

We have 5 picks left. Still so much drafting to come and Gman is known for finding the gems after day 1. KK and Ealy were both 2nd round picks. CJ was a 3rd round. Tre Boston - 4th round pick. Josh Norman and Bene were both 5th round picks!

I realize Gettleman did not draft two of those guys but my point remains. Look at our 3-5 round picks from 2008-12 compared to 2013-15. I fully believe our needs will be addressed. We are in very good hands.

Again, nothing personal to you. Just my two cents towards anyone who thinks the draft is over after day 1 or thinks that Gettleman and Riverboat aren't aware of our needs. I'm very excited for tonight and tomorrow.

5
SixMileDriveCarolina•

You can criticize him, but you just sound like a buffoon doing it. People have this same reaction every year, and every year Gman turns out to be right.

3†
Woooooolf•

Well lets just shut down any discussion about the pick then. Thanks for your unique and original comment about Gettleman.

4†
Woooooolf•

Not looking so hot right now.

1
blindmansarrow•

He's an extremely successful GM, youre a nobody, you can criticize him bUT we can call you an idiot.

0
Woooooolf•

sup now

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ncleon2010•

the pick makes perfect sense.

Gettleman clearly values interior pressure. He recognizes a market inefficiency in the way other teams value edge pressure, so he takes DT that are undervalued.

DT is arguably the most valuable position for the Panthers. but Gettleman would agree and so would i. not only does their pressure collapse pockets and allows DE and edge blitzers to be isolated, but also their ability to occupy blockers allows our LBs to be free to make plays against the run. Luke Kuechly and Thomas Davis are only as good as the DTs in front of them and it would be criminal and shameful to not protect them with talented DTs.

this pick is not some out-of-the-box, whimsical, or nonsensical pick. it is doubling down on what has made our defense so successful the past few years. it provides depth at the position and insurance, not only for this coming season, but also for the future as neither Short nor Lotulelei are in long term deals yet.

15
amc111•

I think the last sentence is the best point. Yeah right now we don't need a DT, but look forward to next year. There's a good chance the Panthers won't be able to afford both short and Star. One of them is probably going to leave in Free agency. So gettleman is getting a guy he thinks can start for us not for 2016 but 2017 and beyond. And frankly I'm glad we have a GM who is more interested in the long term viability of the franchise than trying to force a pick to fill a hole for one year.

2
Tehtime•

Star has 2 more years at the minimum due to 5th year option, and we are so far from the cap you have to believe well keep KK.

Although it has occurred to me that next year if KK blows up again, he may want top dt money. Talking suh like numbers, and that might not be something gettleman is willing to do, which means we just drafted KK's potential replacement.

2
gugudan24•

It makes perfect sense. Defensive Linemen typically get substituted in and out more than any other players. Defensive tackles, in our scheme, are not as interchangeable as they seem. Since we don't run an even 4-3 scheme, the defensive tackle positions are pretty unique. We have a nose tackle (1-tech) and an under tackle (3-tech).

We had two big Nose Tackles (Star and Paul Soliai)

We had only one Under Tackle (KK Short). Now we add this big guy - I don't know much about him, but from what I hear, he excels as a 3-tech.

We have two NTs and two UTs. Keep in mind the Offensive Line hardly substitutes during games. Yet we have a rotation of four guys at DT. Do you see where I'm going with this? If we wear down other teams' offensive lines, then we can do whatever we please on defense.

Do you remember all those near-comebacks last season? Do you remember what the defensive line looked like during those comebacks? (Hint: it wasn't pretty; they were gassed.) This pick shores up a huge need.

3
Woooooolf•

Good point regarding the DL line being tired.

2