r/Fitness•
nigtitz

Beginning strength training on a deficit

I jumped on the keto bandwagon maybe a week ago and am excited to see where it goes. I am eating a 200-400 cal deficit.

I also started SL 5x5 about a week ago and am curious how a deficit will affect it. I know all the basics of bulking/cutting and strength gainz/losses from them.

What I'm curious about is should I begin by bulking and gaining strength first then cutting once I've seen some gainz? Or should I continue eating at a deficit while starting out.

I ask because I'm probably ~25% BF which I really want to lose. I'm worried about beginning strength training while sort of cutting, but if I start by bulking for strength is it just gonna make fat loss even harder later on? I tend to think bulking right now wouldn't be particularly healthy for me. I haven't really been able to find a suggested course of action for my situation, so I would appreciate some feedback on whether to cut, maintain, or bulk.

Posted May 3, 2016, 2:13 PM UTC

19
sknick_•

200-400 is not enough to lose even 1lb per week past the first couple of weeks, FYI (500 * 7 = 3500 = ~ 1 lb per week)

Common wisdom is cut to 10-12% range, bulk to 15-17% range, repeat, taking 3-4 months in each phase. But you mostly just maintain existing muscle during the cutting phases, you don't get much stronger unless you're still new.

Cutting down that low just depends on how important it is to you to stay lean, and whether or not you believe that building muscle is impaired in general when you get to 20% body fat & above.


Proper bulking starts with understanding that when you raise your calorie intake and take your body out of a deficit, your anabolic hormone levels rise, and your body’s ability to synthesize proteins is restored to normal levels.

This is why bulking involves eating slightly more energy than you’re burning but not eating everything under the sun, moon, and stars, which leads to excessive fat storage. This not only makes you look like a big, bloated mess, but it also makes it easier to get fatter and impairs muscle growth.

You see, as body fat levels rise, insulin sensitivity drops, which means that cells become less responsive to insulin’s signals. 6 As the body becomes more insulin resistant, its ability to burn fat decreases, and the likelihood of storing carbohydrates as fat increases. 7 Furthermore, insulin resistance suppresses intracellular signaling responsible for protein synthesis, which means less total muscle growth. 8

Research has also shown that as we get fatter, our free testosterone levels drop and estrogen levels rise. 9 As testosterone plays a vital role in the process of muscle building, and high levels of estrogen promote fat storage, the downsides of these consequences are clear. 10

The reality is that excessive weight gain during a “dirty” or “dreamer bulk,” which involves eating obscene amounts of food every day, is incredibly counterproductive. It gets in the way of muscle growth and makes subsequent efforts to get rid of the excess body fat even harder.

This is why I always recommend that guys don’t bulk if they’re over 15 percent body fat and that they end their bulks once they reach 15 to 17 percent and begin cutting (as this is where the above problems start to kick in). Then, once they’ve reached the 10 percent body fat range, they’re ready to bulk again and add more muscle to their physiques.

Matthews, Michael (2014-01-05). Bigger Leaner Stronger: The Simple Science of Building the Ultimate Male Body (The Build Muscle, Get Lean, and Stay Healthy Series Book 1) (p. 117). Oculus Publishers, Inc.. Kindle Edition.

3
nigtitzOP•

Thanks for the info

So from what I'm gathering, I need to lose a ton of weight before I can really take strength gains seriously?

2
sknick_•

So from what I'm gathering, I need to lose a ton of weight before I can really take strength gains seriously?


Cutting down that low just depends on how important it is to you to stay lean, and whether or not you believe that building muscle is impaired in general when you get to 20% body fat & above.

You could even cut to 15%, and then shift between 15-20% for a few cycles to build some lean mass before cutting lower. But getting below 20% & not letting yourself cross that threshold again would not be a bad idea. Just don't expect to get much stronger during the cutting cycles, or else you'll likely be disappointed.

1
milla_highlife•

Then they can adjust when they start to stall. Starting at a lower deficit is generally a wise move. Allows for more mobility in the diet later on.

1
JuliaB2016•
1
nigtitzOP•

I actually already posted it there, I'm just looking for a second opinion/bigger userbase

2
HelllYeaHHH•

I'm about 7-8 weeks into SL and lost 9 lbs. Now at around 180 lbs bodyweight.

I started the program from absolute 0 on all lifts. Basically because I've never done the movements before and wanted to get comfortable before adding too much weight.

As for strength gains: yes I've gotten stronger but I think progress will slow down quite a bit soon if I don't start eating more. But im ok with that. Just be clear about your own goals. I want to lose weight first so I'm not expecting to look like The Rock.

Reading your story you're probably in a similar situation and your goal is to lose some fat. My advice would be to start with that first and get used to training regularly and eating proper. Get motivated by looking in the mirror or comments from friends and family when they notice your weight loss. Measuring your stomach and taking pictures can be really motivating as well, in my case more than what the scale says.

Good luck!

1
nigtitzOP•

Thanks for the response, in your case can you see a difference in the mirror? I've never really managed to change my body for the better and that would be a huge boost for me

1
HellllYeaHHHH•

Yes I can see it pretty good. Love handles are disappearing, arms and chest look better. Posture in general has improved. Most noticable though is belt size.

People close to me didn't really notice it yet, but I can see it myself very well. Still quite a way of my goal but it's been real easy so far.

1