UPDATE: Sunscreens that don't pill, no matter what you layer under them.

Review

A little while ago, I asked for r/AB's opinions and experiences on sunscreens that don't pill even if you layer products underneath them. I've always had a problem with pilling, mostly because I must moisturize under sunscreen as I have very dry, ridiculously sensitive skin. I'm not prone to acne but I do get red irritation bumps if my skin doesn't like something. I got a ton of helpful responses, I went and bought a whole bunch of the sunscreens recommended, and here were my findings
https://www.reddit.com/r/AsianBeauty/comments/4f7w8z/what_is_a_sunscreen_that_youve_used_that_doesnt/

My morning routine is usually:

  • Cosrx propolis

  • HadaLabo gokyujun

  • 2 sprays TFS Chia Seed water spray

  • Benton Honey All-in-one

  • Dr. Jart++ Ceramidin cream (not liquid)

  • Biore Watery Essence This sunscreen required that I wait at least half an hour after applying my moisturizers to prevent pilling. It was very cosmetically elegant and left no white cast. However, the alcohol did burn my skin. I bought this from a Japanese cosmetics store in Toronto (Pacific Mall)

  • Biore Milk I did get a bit of pilling with this one, especially around my jawline, even though I cut down my routine to just the Dr. Jart Ceramidin cream. It burned less than the watery essence. I bought this at Yonge/Finch (Toronto)

  • Skin-lab fre-C SPF50 I love this. I really do. It doesn't pill on me, it does leave a tiiiiiny white cast, but is very easy to hide with BB cream, and has dual physical/chemical protection. I have only used it for a week, so hopefully the VitC content of it doesn't leave me with irritation marks, as I am a bit sensitive to Vit C. If all goes well, I will definitely rebuy. I bought this from Wishtrend.

  • Shiseido Anessa Perfect UV SPF50 Very cosmetically elegant, no white cast. It did pill at my temples (which have some blonde baby hairs that I don't wax off). Not bad. I would probably rebuy this. I bought this at Pacific Mall.

  • Missha all around safe block (in the pink bottle) This glides on smoothly, again it pills a bit around my temples but easy to pat in and fix. My makeup looked great over this until about 2 hours after I had applied it, when my skin became very very dry. If you have normal or oily skin, this sunscreen would be great. For me, it is too dry. I bought this directly from the Missha store.

  • Innisfree Eco Perfect Sunblock Left a bit of a white cast, and again left my very dry skin even drier. This, again, would be a great sunscreen for normal to oily skin types. Did not pill at all! But it did burn my eyes a bit. I bought this from Pacific Mall.

  • Solanoveil Protect UV 50 Really pretty, no white cast, blends in seamlessly with my makeup. Pills a tiny tiny bit at my temples, but no big deal. Only downside is this thing is difficult to find. I believe several versions have been discontinued, so it's a pain in the butt to acquire. I bought this at Pacific Mall.

  • Neutrogena Dry touch This guy felt a little funny on my skin. Like, I could feel it sitting there. It's probably because I'm weird. It didn't pill at all, but it did burn my eyes. I bought this at Shoppers Drugmart.

  • Shigaisen Physical SPF 50 primer This leaves a definite white cast but pills minimally. It definitely protects against sun, you can see the rays bouncing off your face. Well, not really but it feels like a nice strong screen. If you're ok with a white cast, it's not bad. I bought this from e-bay.

I have yet to try the following sunscreens suggested, and maybe I'll review those too when I do: Elta MD Physical Sunscreen, Shiseido Senka Mineral UV gel, Sunkiller Perfect Water Essence, CosRx Aloe Suncream, Lookatme Jelly.

Posted May 7, 2016, 3:14 PM UTC · edited

232110
synaestheticmodum•

YOU ARE AMAZING.

25
-zygomaticarch-•

I agree with neutrogena dry-touch. I can feel it on my skin as well.

17
MsMerriamNW13|Pores|Oily/Dehydrated|US•

Eugh. I hated my neutrogena dry touch. Haaaaated it. It felt slimy and weird on my face and nothing else applied well over it. I relegated it to arms use once I finally got an AB sunscreen.

28
WillowLeaf•

I agree, it was too greasy for me.

3
alienman•

I hate this one with an unhealthy passion. It feels like I'm wearing a greased up nylon stocking on my face. So it's dry AND greasy, and heavy. Also irritates my eyes. Like some face eating alien parasite.

23
helenkellersipodsOP•

I love your seeming obsession with aliens, thanks for the laugh xD

6
Sharkus_ReincarnusBlogger | fiftyshadesofsnail.com•

"Dry" Touch. One of the worst sunscreens I've ever tried on my face :\

3
leah128•

Neutrogena Dry Touch contains Cinnamon extract so that's why people find it to be burny.

2
vegetal_properties•

WHY?!?

2
etherealemilyy•

On top of it feeling gross, it also made my skin burn whenever I tried to reapply. Definitely not a fan.

1
givenchysister•

I saw you wanted to try Elta MD. In my experience it pills like CRAZY, even on bare skin!

16
helenkellersipodsOP•

Hmm, if it pills on one person in the universe, it will also pill in me. Maybe I shall remove this one from the to-try list...

4
givenchysister•

Yep definitely be careful, and if you do buy it make sure you can return it! I tried so many different ways of using it, but I never could make it work. I wanted to love it so bad (5% niacinamide holy!!) but the sunscreen gods were against me :(

2
saiph•

FWIW, I currently use Elta MD Physical as my everyday sunscreen. A lot of things pill on me, but Elta MD + moisturizer somehow doesn't. It gets a little more finicky when I throw makeup into the picture, but I can usually prevent pilling by waiting 30 minutes before applying any makeup. Since you mentioned that your skin is sensitive, you might still want to try it. It's been amazing for my incredibly sensitive skin (eczema and seb derm, flake city!), and I find it really moisturizing when my skin is at its driest. On the other hand, it can also be pretty sticky/greasy (and I'm sure would leave a white cast on someone who's not already a ghost), and it's less ideal for when my skin is actually behaving. YMMV.

2
Mziani•

I second the pilling - and this was pre AB obsession so was using it on bare skin!

1
myumapplesNC15|Pigmentation|Combo|CA•

Yep, not a fan.

As a near daily makeup wearer (work days anyhow), I hated the Elta MD. I see it raved by others, but simply not a fan. Not a fan of LRP Anthelios either. It was better, but didn't work so well for me.

As always, YMMV.

3
alienman•

Yeah, the LRP was everything I hated about western sunscreens. Heavy, serious white cast, can't be reapplied, so greasy.

2
nocturnem•

LRP Anthelios also felt sticky and pilled on me.

1
dmhuNC15|Acne/Redness|Sensitive|US•

Yup, pilled on me too, and I don't wear makeup/BB daily, just bare skin. It was like having face dandruff. Blech.

1
theliveaboard•

This is great!

I also highly recommend the Skin Aqua Moisture Milk Whitening sunscreen. I put light moisturizer under it and makeup over it and I've never had pilling. Sounds like you might be set for life with all of those, though. :)

13
helenkellersipodsOP•

I apparently like to throw my hard-earned money away, so now that I have another recommendation, I will very likely buy it :D Thanks for the heads up!

3
palimpsestnineNC15|Acne|Dry/Dehydrated|UK•

Seconding this recommendation - this was my first AB sunscreen (my first AB purchase ever, in fact), and I'm still using it because it's great for me. I honestly had no clue what you meant by 'pilling' when I saw your first thread, because it never happened to me with this sunscreen!

3
ThrowAwayAccountKEKNC30|Pigmentation|Oily/Combo|US•

I have this and just found out it has MAP and AA2G! Protects PIH from further damage from the sun, and lightens it at the same time 0.o

2
myumapplesNC15|Pigmentation|Combo|CA•

Great list!

Since you've got dryer skin, I absolutely recommend Kanebo Allie Extra UV Gel Neo Mineral Moist.

  • Non-drying
  • Satin finish (though more dewy if you've got more oily skin)
  • Absorbs well and quickly (takes longer than Biore, but much faster than any Western sunscreen I've tried)
  • Has both chemical and physical UV filters
  • Plays well with makeup
  • Available in 90g bottles

Also, quick note about pilling. Double-check the ingredients, and try to match your skin and makeup products to be the same sort of base. See [this post from r/mua for more info](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/comments/25hkqi/how_to_tell_if_your_foundationprimer_is_silicone/). I usually run around doing a couple of errands, prepare my lunch, get partially dressed to allow my sunscreen to absorb completely before putting on my makeup and I find this helps to minimize and prevent pilling.

10
shinemy•

I just want to mention that this has pilled on me (very slightly!) in the past. The milky version of Kanebo Allie is better in terms of pilling, but I do love the Kanebo Allie line!

2
eohsoquiet•

This sounds absolutely perfect!

1
MsHobbes•

I lovvveee this.no pilling n no whitecast on me.its slightly expensive but a large bottle.

1
2catsinjapanBlogger | asianskincareblog.blogspot.com•

I'll add my best/worst pilling picks.

Worst - Hanyul White Chrysanthemum Sunscreen SPF 50 PA+++. It pills like crazy. The only way I could make it work was when I used it on a nearly bare face (toner only). Then it was lovely and all sorts of magical. But as soon as I tried a full blown routine under it, then no matter how long I waited before applying this sunscreen, it would ball up like crazy. Pity, because otherwise it's a very nice product.

Best - Jewel Pinky AstaUV SPF50+ PA++++. It's a chemical/ combo sunscreen that's alcohol free. It doubles up as a makeup base. And it's impossible to ball it up. I've tried. No matter how many products I use beforehand, this sunscreen stays put, doesn't pill, dries to a perfect finish, leaves no white cast. It's a b*tch to find it, so when I see it, I stock up like crazy.

9
AbsMiDe•

The Jewel Pinky sounds interesting. Any ideas where you can get from the US? How does it compare to Canmake Mermaid UV Gel?

3
helenkellersipodsOP•

This sounds amazing, and I need to try it. I can see why it would be hard to find, I haven't even heard of it yet! Thanks!

1
AkaHana413•

What skin type do you have? The Jewel Pinky sounds amazing!

1
apidae92•

I can't find anything about the jewel pinky one, do you have any links about it to share? thanks :3

1
autumngirlsoup•
7
helenkellersipodsOP•

D: Oh jeez, I guess that's gone

1
ctoan8•

NOOOOOO I just bought this sunscreen last week and been loving it so far. I thought this would be my holy grail sunscreen :( So it's pretty much useless? I should have known it's too good to be true :(

1
autumngirlsoup•

I know, I'm so sorry! I went through the same painful realization last month and it sucks. I haven't been able to find anything that works. :(

1
RonrinesuN10-15|Dullness|Normal/Dry|FR•

I absolutely hated the pink Missha, left me so greasy and icky after an hour.

My go to sunscreen that works with any base is the yellow Missha which is physical and leaves a nasty cast but if you are fair and you use BB on top, it's a no biggie.

I am really curious about trying the Innisfree sunscreen, it's been raved a ton and it has filters I generally tolerate well.

6
Nekkosan•

Hey, I am working that pilly look. Pilled is the next dewy !

Seriously, this is very hepful. I think I use every more under my sunscreen as I am so dry. I totally relate.

6
MsMerriamNW13|Pores|Oily/Dehydrated|US•

Thanks for this! I love seeing sunscreen mini reviews. PS I believe Jolse, Wishtrend and Memebox all carry the CosRx aloe sun cream. Jolse is having a sale atm, and I think Wishtrend is too. c:

4
helenkellersipodsOP•

nnnnoooo what have you done :P

2
MsMerriamNW13|Pores|Oily/Dehydrated|US•

Oops^enableralert^sorry^not^sorry! c;

3
electricgypsywoman•

I've tried using Elta MD UV Clear SPF 46 with significant pilling. I used Benton Aloe Propolis Gel under it, and Smashbox BB cream on top. I don't recommend it, and I'll only be using it on days when I don't wear makeup from now on. I'm currently using Neutrogena with Helioplex 50 spf, but it is very greasy to me. Thank you for these recommendations!

4
aoltatnoa•

I also use EltaMD UV Clear (not the same as the UV Physical the OP mentioned, but similar), and it pills like crazy on me, too.

4
helenkellersipodsOP•

Oh dear, that's two against Elta... Thanks for the heads up!

1
damiana8•

Neutrogena Dry Touch was the first sunscreen that ever pilled on me. YMMV

4
freudianasaurus•

I use Hada Labo UV Creamy Gel and it's been really excellent. No pilling whatsoever and incredibly cheap if you have Amazon Prime!

4
EgweneSedai•

What is pilling?

4
sxojia•

Pilling is when a product rolls up into little balls or things that look like eraser shavings XD It happens especially when pressure is applied to the area. I have a habit of touching my face when I'm doing work, so my sunscreen usually pills after I've rubbed my face a little.

5
omgpandas17•

Thanks so much for answering! I thought everyone was just misspelling peeling! I was like, am I the only person who spells it like peel and not pill? Lolol

2
EgweneSedai•

Ahhhh that's good to know, because mine does exactly that! Lemme go read the rest of the posts now ;-)

1
TitanchainRedness|Dry/Dehydrated|US•

I had the opposite results with the Missha Safe Block. It was fine for wintertime, but since it's gotten warmer it's just not worked out. I have dry/dehydrated skin, but in high heat/humidity my tzone will get oily. I've had to repurpose the remainder of my current tube to my arms instead because it makes my face a greaseball after an hour or two. I don't wear makeup in the summer unless I have an event that needs it, but I don't think I would be able to with it. Maybe it just doesn't agree with my routine. I can finagle it to work if I wear it over a really good primer, but I don't like doing that because I find the coverage isn't as good. I usually wear my routine and sunscreen under a primer so it isn't affected by environmental factors.

3
MsMerriamNW13|Pores|Oily/Dehydrated|US•

You should try the Innisfree Forest No Sebum sunblock! It's creamy and leaves a bit of white cast when first applying, but it pats in and goes away after a minute. I know a lot of people complain about the Eco Safety leaving their skin crazy dry, but the Forest one doesn't do that to me. My T-zone is oily and my cheeks are normal/dehydrated/a little bit dry and I don't ever have problems with too much dryness. It mops up oil like a BOSS though.

If you do end up trying it though, I definitely recommend a pore serum if you have big pores (like I do ;-;) because it does settle into them more than I care for. But it doesn't pill with anything else I've used over or under it, so bonus points for that!

5
spiritswithout•

Innisfree Forest No Sebum

This one looks nice but what does it smell like? If a product has "For Men" on it I assume it's going to be cologne-y.

2
MsMerriamNW13|Pores|Oily/Dehydrated|US•

Yeah it definitely does have an aftershave smell when you squeeze it out of the tube but the smell doesn't linger at all, surprisingly. If you're sensitive to fragrance maybe skip it, but if you're just concerned about your face smelling manly all day then you don't need to worry!

1
spiritswithout•

My worry is always that after I put 10 different smelling things on me that I can't smell anymore, other people still can lol.

2
TitanchainRedness|Dry/Dehydrated|US•

Ooh, I'll have to add that to my list. I've been using the Hada Labo UV Creamy Gel lately and just not doubling up on my moisturizer (usually I will do an emulsion and follow it with my Mizon snail gel cream for the added moisture) and that's worked well. We had a whole bunch of storms come in and drive the temperatures back into the 70s so I don't know how well it will work in heat and humidity, but otherwise I like it so far. I expected it to make my tzone a nightmare but it hasn't.

1
surlyskin•

What pore serum do you recommend? I like the look of the innisfree, have had so many probs with SS pilling or drying out my skin (I have dehydrated oily skin) but my pores can't handle the settling! I'll look like a forked pinata! ha.

1
MsMerriamNW13|Pores|Oily/Dehydrated|US•

Aww I have dehydrated oily skin too. I've had very good luck with the Innisfree Persimmon Pore Essence and the Skinfood Peach Sake Pore Serum. The Innisfree one is a bit more hydrating (without making my skin oily) and the Skinfood one is more silky and primer-y.

2
surlyskin•

Oop, thanks so much. The Innisfree looks lush! Is it too early to buy myself a Christmas pressie? ;)

1
Mastiffaskvet•

S&L SPF 50 is my holy grail! I wish people talked about it more. It's worth every penny.

3
surlyskin•

Not OP but what is this? Haven't heard of S&L and can't find anything on Google, guessing I've missed an abbreviation or sumfin?

1
pantyish•

I have noticed pilling with Biore Watery Essence/Gel but was convinced it was a combination with or due to another product, such a relief to be validated on this! I always apply very soon after moisturizer.

However I gotta say when I did a super basic morning routine of Beauty Water to wash, then Mizon Snail Recovery Gel Cream immediately followed by Biore Watery Gel I experienced NO pilling. But LOLOL at a 3 step morning routine ever being my usual.

I will try to plan my mornings better to allow my products to sink in before sunscreen application, although I'm concerned this will just make me forget to sunscreen D:

3
sxojia•

This is very helpful :D! Thanks a lot for compiling this, since I was looking for a good sunscreen that doesn't pill. I've been using the CosRx Aloe Suncream for about a month and I can say for a fact it does pill on my face :c but it doesn't irritate my skin like the Biore ones which is why I'm still using it. Will definitely check these other ones out when I run out!

3
JuniperLeaf•

Ohhh man I was gonna check out the cosrx one. Gonna weigh the options one more time

1
buzzbuzzbuzzzz•

I have tried so many of these and sounds like we have similar issues with suncreens. I also use Dr. Jart ceramidin cream as a moisturizer.

The only thing I am happy with is Menturm Sunbears Sensitive. Subtle scent of grapefruit SPF 32, PA++, yes it's not SPF 50 and +++ but if you are like me and are willing to sacrifice the max protection for something that works with your skin, it's worth it. Milky texture, easily absorbed, moisture without being greasy. I never had a problem with pilling, maybe a slight cast but I am fair and never notice this. I have dry and sensitive skin, reactive to silicones and so far this is the best sunscreen I have found.

3
helenkellersipodsOP•

Thank you! I've seen Sunbears on Yesstyle and was wondering whether to try it!

2
duckduckguusNW25|Dullness/Pores|Combo|UK•

Brilliant, thank you. I'll give you a spoiler for the Cosrx Aloe Suncream: this one pills pretty easily unfortunately. You have to be quite meticulous about how many layers you put underneath it.

3