Question about lookatme Jelly Sunscreen!
I'm looking for a none-silicone based sunscreen to use when I use no-silicone foundations and creams. A Google search revealed this one, but one of the top reviews of the sunscreen on Amazon claim that it has more like spf15 and low PA. Manufacturer then replied and noted that they missed one UVA filter in the ingredients, and somehow adding that in DECREASED the amount of sun protection?
It seems to have pretty glowing reviews for the formula and how light it feels, which is great, but I really do need something with high protection (broad-spectrum). I now don't want to take the sunscreen's word for it, but at the same time I don't know if this reviewer has it right, either.
Posted May 10, 2016, 2:10 PM UTC
Hey! I'm that reviewer!
That dude is the seller, not the manufacturer. He claims that it has Ethylhexyl Triazone, but he is making stuff up. It's not in the ingredients list on the manufacturer page. Here's a link to a old comment I made with links to findings.
Also here and here are some threads with people being burned by that sunscreen.
Edit: And even if it did have ethylhexyl triazone, that wouldn't improve the UVA protection, only UVB.
I have gone back to look at the Amazon product page a couple of times since the ingredient concentrations were revealed and noticed the ridiculousness of what's going on in your review and the comments. Thanks for fighting the good fight :)
Lol, thanks. I wish I could stop paying attention to this stupid sunscreen.
Same
Me too. I actually sent mine back to the seller (thank you Prime!) because it pissed me off so much.
But I can't seem to find a way to read the seller's feedback to you - I want to chime in to support you!
Edit : never mind, realized I had to go through a browser, not the app. It's pretty shocking they are threatening you with legal action (jerk). We should organize a boycott of the seller.
Hum. There should be a little "11 comments" link below the review if you're on a computer. Dunno about mobile. The best way to support is to mark the review as helpful :D
Edit response: also I found his mention of "legal department" hilarious. Dude just wants to mail me a glitterbomb. Or maybe more sunscreen. Heaven forbid.
Seriously, even if the product turns out to be the best sunscreen in the world with actual PA++++ protection, I would not buy it because of the way the seller has behaved on Amazon.
Thank you!! This is really disappointing. Have you found a good high-protection no-'cone sunscreen?
Sadly no. I use Shiseido Senka on days when I don't wear silicones underneath it, but it still pills a little. I've found that Biore Perfect Face Milk doesn't pill no matter what goes under it, despite being full of silicone, but it is somewhat drying.
Gr. I feel especially bad for the people who are sensitive to silicones. I might get a western one if I can find it, then.
Darn it, i have two bottles of this, guess it's going to be on my body then :(
Planning to use mine up on winter days when I don't go outside... lots of people don't even wear SPF15 daily, so you're still ahead of the curve.
Might do this as well
In South Korea sunscreen is classified as a functional cosmetic, so it has to be tested and the company has to be registered with the government to sell it. I wonder if the bottles that are sold in Korea are labeled the same. Or maybe there was a bad batch that someone got ahold of and is trying to sell off.
The bottles on lookatmecos.co.kr (product linked in parent comment) are labelled the same, and have the (mostly) same ingredients list. The bad batch theory is possible, but it seems unlikely that ... they put in the wrong amount of UV filters without messing up anything else, the ordering in the ingredients list managed to stayed the same, and then this seller got them and was told the post-screwup amount of chemical filters.
I spent some time looking at the KFDA site a while ago. There is a listing of registered cosmetic companies there, but only about 100 (seems low), and I couldn't find the manufacturing company (youngwon costech) behind lookatme (which doesn't mean much, I couldn't find a lot of companies in that list). Youngwon Costech describes themselves as a manufacturer and exporter. There may be a loophole in which sunscreens sold only outside of korea (and the packaging reflects that) don't have to be tested.
Side note: on the lookatme product page there is a photo of some paperwork about 15% of the way down the page. It seems too blurry for google translate, but maybe not for a person. might be worth trying to translate it, might be a stock photo, who knows.
I see if I have time to use the draw function in the translate app while on my computer later and get back to you. It works pretty well in my experience.
Edit: I'm just editing this comment, Cosdna is mostly accurate, but the sunscreen doesn't contain betaine, the specific type of butylene glycol being used is 1,3- butylene glycol, also called beta-butylene glycol. I noticed that they use complicated versions of names instead of the common ones or the NCIC accepted ones. The PA rating system can be trusted outside of Japan though as long as you realize that Japan revamped theirs to go up to PA++++ while the rest of Asia uses the scale that existed before that.