If I'm an investor, is it stupid for me to invest in two direct competitors?

Eg coke and pepsi

Posted May 12, 2016, 8:13 PM UTC

144
rewardiflostnot a lawyer/doc/or other expert•

The stock market isn't a zero-sum game, or a battle to the death. Both of those companies can do well at the same time.

In fact, if you remember Microsoft investing in Apple - sometimes having a strong competitor in the industry can help your business. Just do your research on each, and invest smartly.

12
Turtle456just curious ...•

Not necessarily stupid.

If you expect the market in a given industry to grow as a whole, investing in two competitors can actually help reduce your risk of "betting on the wrong horse".

Just a hypothetical: China opens its market to foreign car makers. You could now invest in BMW or Mercedes, but you're not sure which one will do better in China. All you know is that the market for cars will be growing. In that case, you could invest in both and you will probably make a profit.

Pepsi and Coke, however, is probably not a good idea, as u/doughcastle01 explained.

4
doughcastle01•

It's generally not advised. One company is usually going to stand out. If the market is mature (like soda) then it's more or less a zero sum game. Any gains in market share from one company will subtract from the others.

You picked a pretty good example of this, actually. Coke and Pepsi have about the same market cap. Pretty close valuation (P/E ratio). Dividend yield is about the same. They're almost the same company. Coke has a little bit better margins. At this point the differences are very slight compared to two companies in any other industry. Hilariously, it's as hard to tell the difference between coke and pepsi stock as it is to tell between their products.

Besides flipping a coin, you can start digging into more numbers like growth, or technical analysis if you're into witchcraft. You can also do more research into the company cultures, the board, the CEO, etc.

Also take a look at other companies in the industry. Maybe you want a smaller company like Dr. Pepper.

4
32OrtonEdge32dhRun the Jewels•

Hilariously, it's as hard to tell the difference between coke and pepsi stock as it is to tell between their products.

Does that mean it's incredibly easy?

-2†