Question about W4 allowances, is it ok to claim more than I actually have?
I'm recently married and had my first child last year. I filed jointly with my wife and it turns out she had a prior tax obligation that she thought she had already taken care of (problems with her ex messing around with her allowances, made her end up owing a ton).
So she hired a tax attorney to help out with her situation, and now she's telling me (based on the attorneys advice) to submit a new employee action request to change my W-4, to single with 3 allowances (me, her and my child). But she is also saying I should change it to 5 for a couple months just to bump up my paycheck a little bit. I'm just a little confused on the topic. From what I've been reading this is allowable and it's just a guideline for deductions and doesn't actually reflect dependents?
I'm just a little skeptical about changing it without really understanding if I'm going to screw myself later. If anyone can help clear the fog in this situation it would be greatly appreciated.
EDIT: I live in California if that makes a difference.
Thanks in advance.
Posted May 13, 2016, 5:26 PM UTC · edited
Yes; it's allowable. Your W-4 form does not get submitted to the IRS; it only provides numbers for the withholding formula used by your employer.
I'm not sure why "5 for a couple of months". Do you have a cash crunch (or large bill pending) for which you need a paycheck bump, that will go away by July?? Otherwise, that doesn't make sense.
I am in the camp that says your withholding goal should be to end up slightly UNDERwithheld on Dec 31st, so that you pay your shortfall and are DONE in March -- look at the number of people on this board asking, "Where's my refund?" To avoid that problem, don't put yourself in that situation!
Your total tax bill for the year is affected by many things, and simple payroll withholding doesn't necessarily account for them adequately. Do you have lots of itemized deductions, such that you are overwithheld for the year? Do you have lots of untaxed income, such that you are underwithheld for the year? If those apply, you tweak your payroll withholding, either up or down, to accomodate those. The more work you put in to filling out your W-4, the more likely your end-of-year withholding will match your actual tax due.
Play by The Price is Right rules -- come close without going over!
Yeah, we have a bit of a cash crunch and not getting the big return I was expecting has hurt us a bit financially, when we were hoping to catch up a bit. I guess the idea was to boost it a little bit because I haven't been claiming that much up to this point, so I guess it would sort of even out, then I would change it back to 3.
Also, the attorney is saying I should claim single, I'm a little confused on this as well. Is that allowable?
Most should claim single and yes it is allowed.
As before, Yes, it's allowed, because that form doesn't get seen by the IRS.
Does your wife work for a paycheck? If not, claiming "withhold at the higher single rate" rather than married probably isn't what you want. If you're trying to get a paycheck bump for a couple of months, claiming single moves you in the opposite direction
Based on what you've said so far, I'd go with claiming Married/5 for a couple of months. Do NOT forget to refile a new W-4 in July or August -- there are also penalties* for "gross underwithholding".
*The penalties are waived for missing by less than $1000, missing by less than 10%, or having at least as much withheld this year as last. None of these, along with "I like to get a refund", are a valid reason for overwithholding.
Yes, my wife works and she is handling her tax obligation on her own (in the thousands), her tax attorney suggested that I make the change to S3 on my W4 so that I lower my withholding and receive that money instead of getting it taken and put toward her obligation at the end of the year, since we are now married.
Ahh. Make sure you don't both claim the same person. If she's claiming herself, you can't claim her at the same time -- in an "ideal world", you can claim 3 exemptions between you: 3+0, 2+1, 1+2, etc. Double counting is an excellent way to be underwithheld at the end of the year!
Still, S3 is -higher- withholding than M3. If you're trying to boost your paycheck, "withhold at the higher single rate" is not the path to that goal.