r/Gundam•
Code980

Anyone seen ANN comment section when it comes to Gundam ?

Sorry if this is a touchy topic, but ANN's comment section when comes to anything Gundam is pretty Bad, the IBO Toonami News had nothing be shit posting like almost Gamefaqs level, has the site always been like that ? (remember the same thing happen for 00 when it was still airing ) I also hear the mods and the staff are pretty bad too but I don't know how true that is, If someone can confirm this that would be a huge help. :)

Posted May 14, 2016, 6:08 AM UTC · edited

336
The-Red-Comet00•

I blame it on that sites crowd being young kids like most of gamefaqs and only liking the new "cool" anime and not actually having any form of taste.

5
Code980OP•

I agree with this, I never thought I see the day where, I would say ANN and Gamefaqs in the same sentence.

1
The-Red-Comet00•

It's a combination I didn't expect either haha

2
Dorali•

I don't think it's necessarily a matter of "good taste" as it is a matter of preference.

Even amongst Gundam fans, each Gundam release is somehow extremely polarizing. There are very few Gundam installments that are overwhelmingly praised (especially here on the Gundam Reddit itself). Top that with the fact that Gundam or the mecha genre for that matter isn't a very popular one these days, and you get a lot of dislike for Gundam. It's just seen as something that has lasted so long that it shouldn't exist to the degree that it still does.

I wouldn't blame other anime fans for being wrong, necessarily, but rather the industry for changing into something that is rather harsh on what Gundam represents in the community. Gundam is neither really good or bad as a whole, but instead is something that is ill-fitting when more mainstream works have evolved beyond it. Sunrise likes to try pushing their luck by putting their feet into mainstream trends (hence why their artistic variety over the past decade or so has been very diverse), but it seems to be a battle between pleasing classic Gundam/mecha fans and bringing in new viewers with new interests.

4
Kino106•

Reminds me what Namco and Square enix do, every time there is a new Tales or Final Fantasy, fans are always arguing about it.

One groups say : Its a Very good game and deserves a 9/10

while the other group say: This so bad its a trash game why did they make this ? please make good games again. 1/10

its an endless Circle Jerk, I mean I like what Sunrise is doing but sometimes its impossible to make everyone Happy.

-_-"

1
randomking0x70•

I'm a regular lurker on ANN (I don't post much because I just never know what to say on forums), and it's really only a certain few series that cause threads like that, Gundam being one of them unfortunately. You can't mention Gundam on there without it causing a shitstorm.

The mods and the staff aren't too bad. That's mostly an exaggeration from the salty people who the mods either warned or banned.

2
NativeJovian•

Huh, that's weird. Always interesting how different sites have their own individual issues particular to that community.

What's their problem with Gundam, exactly? There's gotta be a story behind that.

2
Char_X_3•

Not everyone likes mecha anime. Hell, I believe r/anime voted it as one of the most hated genres a while back. And when Gundam is one of the big dogs of the genre, it's easier to pick on.

Though, I do remember Fukuda creating some anti-Gundam sentiments last year. He said something like "Cross Ange was a success, but Sunrise is more focused on a "long-existing" franchise. Let Sunrise know you want more Ange" to the show's fans at a meet and greet. A bunch of guys over at ANN took what he said as "Cross Ange was a big hit, but Sunrise doesn't want to make more and instead wants to make more Gundam," and Ange fans foamed at the mouth.

3
KaiRellim•

Wait...

CrossAnge has fans?

I mean, I didn't hate it, but... Come on, the character designs and mecha animation are ripped right from SEED, the character writing is bloody horrible, and wtf signing activates their super modes?

2
Char_X_3•

I think it's more anime fans look towards the medium as a means of escapism. They want characters who can kick ass and take names without consequence to their actions. That may be one of the reasons why they have a problem with so many mecha shows, because the genre constantly goes on about such things to the point of ruining the escapist factor. They want a more CoD plot over Spec Ops The Line, and Cross Ange fits the bill to them.

Also, boobies.

2
KaiRellim•

True enough, I often forget how much anime and it's fandom has changed since the start of the 21st century. I can enjoy a bit of Moe now and then, but it seems like it's taken over everything. It even pops up in what I thought was going to be grim-dark.

Not that grim-dark for the sake of edginess is good either, but damn it I grew up in the 90's and early oughts.

Edit: typos. Cracked screen plus autocorrect equals terribad.

2
Ledakan43•

I've been thinking about that as well for a long time now. What exactly is about mecha anime that a lot of ppl hate? How illogically logical it is? How clichéd most of the beginnings are?

I really can't see any definite reasons why they could loathe mecha anime that much, when they can't even see deeper than what a lot of mecha anime represents. Perhaps that may be the reason? The fact that mecha anime presents themselves as an action flick, that most ppl don't even try and look deeper into them and get what they're really trying to say.

1
_robotical•

Can't speak for everyone, but when I asked my friend why she doesn't like the genre, she said it's mainly because she has a hard time getting immersed in the battles because of the giant robots. She feels they protect the characters too much, and there's not as much at risk because there's two large robots between the two who are actually fighting.

In general, I imagine the political themes are also a turn off. Think of how popular the slice of life genre is, and how prevalent school settings are right now too, judging from my limited experience with the genre so far, mecha as a whole doesn't have tons of those elements. Some people also just don't like CGI, and if they already don't find mecha necessarily appealing, that could just be another reason to steer clear of the genre.

3
Ledakan43•

That is actually a very sound logic. Too many mecha shows use their mechs as plot devices to stay alive after all.

Fortunately for the slice of life genre, there's always going to be people who are more leaned towards that side of things, while the mecha genre gets alienated even from the action anime fans.

1
Code980OP•

Really ? mechas are just like a fighter jet or a tank once they blow up and you die, if anything the risk are higher when you are in a robot, how more real can you get with that ?

1
Kino106•

Did you tell her to try Gundam animes like IBO ? Being in a robot is the last thing you want to do.

1
Char_X_3•

Maybe they've just been burned too much? Too many dead Kaminas, too many wtf Evangelions, too many Aldnoah Zeros, too many dead waifus.

1
Ledakan43•

But there was only 1 Kamina (Orga didn't die), 1 Evangelion (despite Tomino's attempts, Brain Powerd failed to become one), and 1 Aldnoah Zero (I don't think there's that many mecha anime where the MC gets NTR'd, no?). As far as I can remember, there aren't that many mecha anime that follow those animes' plot. Aside from similarities in some of the beginnings, most of them are just very different.

1
X-Burner21•

Maybe to many people, giant robots just seems too much for their suspension of disbelief.

I mean, IDK. People can watch harems with MC who have girls all over him but does nothing but will say they can't understand mecha.

Or maybe it's its stigma of being overly nerdy?

1
Ledakan43•

Looking at how greatly received Marvel movies are, I really can't say much about the suspension of disbelief part. It's as if their belief is controlled by their bias to the point that they can't stand it anymore. Also this might be a bit too farfetched, but with how Titanfall was well received in the West, their suspension of disbelief for giant mechas shouldn't be that bad right?

1
ShinnAssuka•

Of course FUKUDA would say that.

1
KaiRellim•

Fuck him. The only good thing he's done is the Original SEED, and that was more in spite of him than because of him.

1
ShinnAssuka•

I attribute the good things from SEED to the writers(not including moreswa)/muscians/VA ect who did their best despite him. After watching Ange, I have come to the opinion the man can pick good music and some ideas, but he fails at consistency, and narrative structure, and can't listen/learn from criticism.

2
Char_X_3•

http://www.soul-anime.to/anime/future-gpx-cyber-formula/

This is Fukuda's first show. Just watch the first episode and see how much he reused for SEED.

1