Question about incidence calculation

Hey I'm a medical student. I'm reviewing a large study about diabetes prevention (http://www.nejm.org/doi/pdf/10.1056/NEJMoa012512) But the thing is, they gave the incidence density rate (cases/ 100 life years) rather than giving the number of cases. And they didn't provide the total time at risk for the population but only gave the range and average duration of the study. How can I go about to calculate the incidence to get the relative risk/ odds ratio/etc...?

Posted May 15, 2016, 8:40 AM UTC

43
prattja8•

There are a variety of ways to measure risk. For example, you could make a 2x2 table and use the classic (a/(a+b)) / (c/(c+d)) formula.

Another way to calculate risk is to compare the cumulative incidences between an exposed group and an unexposed group.

1
Impuls1ve•

Don't over think it. Risk ratio is literally risk in the exposed versus risk in the unexposed. So calculate risk in both the groups separately using the incident density and divide exposed by unexposed.

If you do it the way you want, your numbers won't be a good estimate.

1
neoporcupine•

You might consider rate ratios, although you will need the N cases for each group to calculate the 95%CI, and without the CI the rate ratio isn't much of a statistic. You could have estimated the N cases if the authors had included the incidence rate 95%CI but they didn't even do that.

Most journals will require you to report absolute N values and/or person time totals. It is quite disappointing when you find an interesting paper that falls short on the reporting, particularly when doing literature reviews, comparative analyses or a meta-analysis.

If you really want to include this paper then I would write to the authors.

Rothman, Greenland. Modern Epidemiology, 2nd ed. Lippincott-Raven 1998.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0