r/whichbike•
a_brain

New bike for commuting and fitness

Hi everyone,

I'm looking to buy a new bike for commuting and fitness. My daily commute is about 10 miles round trip and I plan to ride on pavement the whole way.

Budget Hoping to spend about $500, with $700 absolute maximum. Terrain I live in Chicago, so it'll be mostly flat pavement but occasionally some dirt trails.

I've ridden the Trek Fx 7.2 and 7.3 and liked both -- I liked the 7.3 better but I don't know if it's worth the extra money. I also tried the Novara Big Buzz which is currently on sale for $518. I liked that the Treks were more upright and I thought were slightly more comfortable, but the Novara has a much nicer drivetrain. My questions are:

  1. Does REI typically sell quality bikes with the Novara brand?
  2. Will I miss the hydraulic disc brakes and upgraded components if I choose to go with one of the Trek bikes?
  3. Is it difficult to get used to the more leaned over riding position should I choose the Novara?
  4. Are there any other bikes around this price range I should consider?

Thanks!

Posted May 22, 2016, 5:24 AM UTC

12
MilkTheFrog•

For that sort of money its worth at least considering a bike with drop bars, eg;

https://www.rei.com/product/893057/diamondback-century-disc-bike-2016

or

http://www.raleighusa.com/bikes/open-road/endurance-and-fitness/merit/merit-1

or

https://www.giant-bicycles.com/en-us/bikes/model/defy.5/22177/83959/

Which has an endurance geometry so its still pretty upright, and does not take long to get used to at all. The drop bars would help a lot with ensuring your wrists are comfortable, and it'd be a lot more versatile if you wanted to do longer rides in your own time.

1
Rumblefish1•

Novara bikes are a solid choice. Disc brakes offer more braking force for the amount of lever effort, so they are a nice upgrade. Where they really shine is in wet weather. Rim brake performance is worse in rain.

It is not difficult to get used to the more leaned over riding position. The question is, is it more suitable to the riding you are doing. For shorter distances, out of a lot of wind, upright is fine. So casual pace, 5 miles inside of a city, where the rider is sheltered from the wind, upright bikes are fine. More leaned over is better for going fast, and bucking a headwind.

At a given price point, you are going to get pretty compareable bikes. Which you choose depends on what is available in your area, as this allows you to test ride. Buy the best quality bike that you enjoy riding.

1