r/chicago•
mt145

To people in the 'burbs: Do you consider yourself Chicagoan?

As the title says, do those of you who live in the suburbs consider yourself truly Chicagoan, or do you feel a stronger tie to the suburb you are from? Are there suburbs where the specific identity is stronger than others? More general parts of town?

I briefly lived in a suburb as a teenager, but moved away and haven't been back except to visit as some middling tourcal, so I'm not someone who lives in the city itself trying to say we're the only true Chicagoans or something. I moved a bit as a kid, so who knows what I am.

Thanks for any input!

Posted May 22, 2016, 7:28 AM UTC

958
Kambohdia•

I usually say I'm from Chicagoland. I'm from Dupage and people actually from "Chicago" have taken offense to me introducing myself as being from "Chicago".

29
DaFluffyPuppyLogan Square•

People from the suburbs are always from Chicago until they meet someone actually from Chicago.

26
evilpettingz00•

I consider myself Chicagoan but that's just because Svengoolie gives my 'burb shoutouts on the reg.

16
TRex_N_TruexArcher Heights•

BERWYN

17
beeny13•

Ber-wynn

2
silvertonesx24Loop•

I once had a friend who lives in NY introduce me as "from Illinois". Frankly, it was completely bizarre to hear.

10
redditor9000Mount Prospect•

"This is silvertones24, he is from illinoise"

2
AperionProjectRogers Park•

This brings up an interesting question, what would be an Illinoise?

2
sp0rk_walker•

My job takes me to almost every part of the city and across all the suburbs. My current address is not in Chicago, but even if I moved away, I would always consider myself a Chicagoan. I am fully aware that to most people in this sub, I am not.

9
ibtokin•

Most people like that in this sub are transplants anyway. Chicago is a lot more than just what's inside the city proper.

3
Yossarian567•

I grew up in a south suburb. I always loved Chicago, loved visiting, and thought I was lucky for living close to such an important city. I also loved my hometown (Homewood). I now live in the city and still feel the same. I identify as both Chicagoan and as a child of my hometown, and always have. I feel identity to region (Chicago) and neighborhood (Homewood) despite municipal boundaries.

Several of the people commenting here seem to have missed the point of your question. You were just asking how people identify, which is a feeling more than a choice. I don't think were you were asking people what the "right" way to identify is. Thanks for this question! I enjoyed reading replies!

8
Forfty•

Yo to Pop's Italian Beef on 183rd.

Yo to Lassens, and 5th Quarter, and Bogarts bar area.

Yo to the North Building in the fall, fuck that walk in the winter.

Yo to the DQ.

Yo to Dolphin Lake Pool before it got filled in.

Yo to Grape and Vine.

Yo to Aurelio's.

Yo.

3
tossme68•

I grew up on the SS too (I even worked in Homewood). One thing about growing up on the SS is that I felt we were very removed from the city. People didn't go into the city with rare exception. If they did go into town it was to do the tourist things. I knew so many people that had only been downtown to see the windows at Marshall Fields, if that and these people could drive to the loop in under 30 minutes.

1
Yossarian567•

Yeah, I didn't see much of the real city myself... downtown, museums, my aunt's place, Comisky. I definitely formed my attachment before I realized how much I was missing.

3
SergeantSchmoopySuburb of Chicago•

Yes and no. To people out of Illinois or Indiana, I say I'm from Chicago. To people from Illinois or Indiana, I say I'm from Aurora.

8
bendersama•

I love Chicago and moved back from Southern California with wife and family to have them experience the culture, food, and music. While in California I said I was from Chicago to make it simple, but to other Illinoians I say I'm from the NW burbs or more specific Woodstock.

So yes, and no. Depends on who I'm talking to, however anybody that loves Chicago and thinks it's the best big city...is a Chicagoan.

7
trippin113Logan Square•

r/chicago is the only place I've ever seen where people get shunned for saying they are from Chicago even though they are from the suburbs. I grew up in the burbs and moved to Miami for 10 years. If someone asked where I was from I told them Chicago. Now I actually do live on Chicago and hold no animosity towards those that identify with it.

6†
Rudas_Iskariot1060 W. Addison•

Skokie isn't really that different from the northwest side so yeah. But people know Chicago, they don't know Skokie.

5
Halgrind•

There's no real difference between Sauganash and Skokie/Lincolnwood.

5
TheOldKanye•

This is a silly debate. I know many people from Chicago that are from the burbs and they're not POLAR OPPOSITES as you guys are suggesting. I knew a lot of kids from the burbs that would take the trains/busses into the city upwards of 5 days a week and roam all day, but since they're not from Chicago "proper" they're not a Chicagoan? Get out of here with that.

5
omgdonerkebab0th Ward Alderman•

I grew up in one of the closest NW suburbs, and my parents commuted to the Loop (Metra + Blue line) every weekday for work. I went away for a decade of college, and then I came back. Now I live and work downtown.

I've always considered myself a Chicagoan, and you know, my Chicagoan identity didn't feel any different when I moved in to the city. You'd think that if there was a real difference, making the same person live in the suburbs and then live within the city's boundaries would reveal it. But there wasn't.

I also wanna say, there's gonna be some discussion about whether or not people who live in the suburbs should be saying they're "from Chicago" to outsiders, and I think this is a different question than whether you feel Chicagoan. I also think it's a stupid question.

4
Barking_at_the_MoonNear North Side•

People say they're from Chicago to outsiders because of horseshoes: sometimes close enough is good enough. People in Paris or Hong Kong or St. Louis don't care where Berwyn or Lake Forest are and nobody wants "where you from" to turn into a fifteen minute discussion.

The people who live in Chicago that object to that do so because they're just as narrow-minded and unsophisticated as they believe the provincials they so disdain are.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
OnRockOrSomethingLake View•

My parents were both born and raised in Chicago. They lived here when I was born, but due to circumstance I was born in a suburban hospital. Shortly after they moved to the suburbs, but growing up we were constantly in the city seeing family, going to eat, etc. Finally moved there myself after college. Always tell people I am from Chicago and I have the stereotypical accent.

Not sure why this is getting downvoted.

0†
ibtokin•

Because this is the thread where everyone gets shit on unless they're from the right place.

3
808360•

I completely agree with you. It is a stupid question to be asked. Some people like to quickly categorize who you are by where you live, what you do, and who you are around, etc.

Personally, it doesn't matter if you're from the boonies, burbs, or city...that shouldn't define you. If you like to identify with a backwards city with a terrible education system and murder rates through the roof, then Chicago is your place.

Take pride in helping other people out, and not solely identifying your life with a geographical location. "Chicago... come for the pizza....stay because you might get murdered."

-4†
99levtt60643•

If you're not from Chicago and tell people you're from Chicago because of the simplicity in conversation I think that's 100% understandable.

However if you're proudly not from Chicago and like to call Chicago a backwards city with a terrible education system and murder rates through the roof, and then go and tell people how you're from Chicago anyway, then you're just a shithead from the suburb who has it all figured out.

8
808360•

Haha, every Chicago resident is forced to be proud of being in the city? That's foolish. I put ketchup on my hot dog...

4
99levtt60643•

If you're a Chicago resident and you lead off your description of Chicago by talking about its problems, why are you a Chicago resident?

-3
Audeamus27•

If you like to identify with a backwards city with a terrible education system and murder rates through the roof, then Chicago is your place.

Take pride in helping other people out, and not solely identifying your life with a geographical location.

I didn't down vote you but I have to disagree with you. These are both part of MY identity growing up on the south side of Chicago and beating the odds. I am the first in my family to graduate from college and grew up in one of the roughest neighborhoods in the city. I am also an EMT so my experiences helped mold the fact that I want to help people. I am one of the youngest people to receive an award from a CFD commissioner.

The day I received that award, I was holding back tears in my eyes watching my parents in the audience.

I have lost friends to gun violence so I don't particularly take well to murder jokes. I myself could have been a statistic as an 8 year old that could have been killed during a drive by at my local park.

Every city has problems. It's up to its citizens to make the change. I for one, accept the unusual circumstances I grew up with and am trying to leave the world a slightly better place whether that be through saving someone's life, mentoring someone in my future career, or various forms of outreach.

7
symstealth•

I moved to Maywood not too long ago from the West Coast. People here tend to be very proud of being from Maywood, and I haven't heard too many say they're a Chicagoan. Being new here, I myself have a hard time telling whether I'm in Maywood, Oak Park, or Chicago. I'm sure that will change as I spend more time here.

3
maxxmurrax•

Proud of maywood weird. I would assume people would be sad to be from there seeing as proviso is so terrible.

-2
symstealth•

I've only been here for about a month now, but I've heard Proviso isn't the greatest place. Maywood itself isn't the greatest place either, but it seems like a close, small community where everyone seems to know each other. Personally, I would like to move either into Chicago somewhere, or another suburb, like Forest Park.

2
lifeInCHIJefferson Park•

I grew up and still lived in the city, but I never cared about the "designation". Frankly, a Schaumburg transplant who has only been in the city for a year is "less Chicago" than a 20-40 year resident who just moved out to the burbs.

I think the designation should be more about time spent in the city (even if your home address is never in the city), and how much you explore and respect the diversity of the city. Moving to Lake View or Lincoln Park and never venturing outside of it doesn't really help you become "true Chicago" in my book.

2†
hobojoe645Lake View•

Lol I love how you pick Lakeview and Lincoln park, as is living on other neighborhoods makes you more "authentic" somehow. Here's a tip: there are people in Lakeview and Lincoln Park who go to other neighborhoods plenty and there are people in more "authentic" neighborhoods who never leave their spot and spend the majority of time in their own hood.

6
lifeInCHIJefferson Park•

I picked two areas many suburban transplants go. I could have made a big list if that will please this nitpicky crowd.

1†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Schlectes--Vorbild•

I tell people from out of state/country Chicago and people from here the actual town. I don't see why people make it a big ordeal if someone from Arlington Heights or Lockport or wherever say they're from Chicago. Personally I take pride in the suburb I grew up in, the one I'm raising my family in now and the city I am in daily and have so many memories growing up with.

1
lidongyuanNorth Center•

I'm from the far NW side, and my friends and I gave crap to kids from Niles even though they lived less than a quarter of a mile away. The whole thing is so dumb.

1
super_fast_guy•

Grew up in West Ridge, live in the northwest suburbs for about 8 years. I consider myself a Chicagoan, and I think it's ok to say that you're from Chicago even if you're from the suburbs.

Interestingly, I was driving through Garfield Park one day and had an intense desire to lock my doors. And I felt bad about doing that because I was questioning whether or not I was a racist at that point. In any case, living in the burbs made me a little soft on the inside, time to move back into the city.

0†

If you say you're going "Downtown" when you mean Wrigley Field or Evanston, you're not a Chicagoan. Also, if you fled "the big scary city" to go buy a house in Naperville because your kids were nowayinhell going to CPS, then you're not a Chicagoan.

0†
mt145OP•

So where do you stand on people who left because it's expensive to buy a house in Chicago proper?

0

I'm not making a judgement call on their decision. I'm just saying if you give up on the city, for whatever reason, however good it may be, you can't really call yourself a Chicagoan. That's like me saying, yeah I'm Catholic but I don't go to church, I don't pray, and I don't really believe in the whole Jesus thing anyway, and actually I'm kinda into the whole Judaism thing now. It may be semantics, but try convincing an actual Catholic that you're Catholic. (I'm probably going to regret this comment, but oh well here goes...)

-7
YawnsMcGeeWest Town•
0†