Why is /remake already in the game when it doesn't work?
I just had a game yesterday, where our midlaner was disconnected from the very start of the game. Everyone in my team wanted to do the new /remake thing, but no one has ever seen it suceeding. I heard about it before and liked the idea, but I didn't see it in the last patch notes, thought must've overread it or something. Now I know it says it's only coming at patch 6.11 but I didn't know that in the game yesterday. The problem is: something already happens when you type it in chat, but absolutely not what we wanted to do - which destroyed our game sadly.
Well, we all wrote "/remake" in the chat starting at minute 1, which of course wouldn't work because it was too early (the official lol website says the player needs to be disconnected at least 90 seconds after the 3 min mark or be announced afk by the system, as I now know). The message "it's too early to surrender" appeared in our chats after we tried to remake.
I was baffled for a second. Why does it say surrender? I already got a bad feeling at that point, but thought I'd just trust riot - they'll know what they're doing. It was very confusing, because you didn't type /ff or /surrender, yet it said "surrender" in the error message. You typed /remake, which is something completely different - none of us wanted to surrender the game, because we'd lose lp which we of course didn't want to. The team wanted to remake and they were all 100% sure it was already implemented and working. (well, one didn't know about it beforehand but trusted it immediately upon hearing)
The afk came back after 6-7 minutes, in which half of the team was just spamming /remake, which kept displaying the error message. At this point 2 of the players already stopped playing the game properly, saying they were going to /remake anyway - as soon as it worked.
So at minute 20 (they didn't look at the time) everyone typed in /remake again, as they did for the whole game since minute 1. And finally a vote appeared. It was the surrender vote. I thought it was odd to have the vote finally displayed, as first blood (obviously) had already fallen and 20 minutes into the game was far too long for something like a remake, but it was the vote that came up when we typed in /remake, so we trusted it. We confirmed the vote.
Now, I'm not gonna say it was undeserved, we should've known better than thinking we could still remake a game after 20 minutes, my issue is the following: Why does /remake automatically trigger the surrender vote (which cost us all around 18 or 19 lp)? We didn't want to surrender and we wouldn't have done it, if we didn't trust in the client which displayed the vote for /remake. Of course it was dumb to vote yes when the vote clearly asked if we wanted to "surrender", but none of us asked for a SURRENDER and everyone was pretty mad and disappointed. The vote appeared after we said /remake, so we thought it was probably a typo or it's just called surrendering too, when someone remakes a match.
The chances of winning the game were low, as the enemy midlaner was already level 6 when our midlaner reconnected, all lanes were behind because we had to cover mid and were ganked by more people than we had in our team - still: our base wasn't open yet and we still had a little chance. None of our team wanted to surrender and give up their lp, but we agreed on trying to remake the game because even if we'd have won, it would've taken forever to get back to lead after getting stomped for the entire game thanks to the afk.
Long story short: We lost lp because we didn't know what exactly was implemented yet and what wasn't. And because 2 out of the 3 remaining members of my team were deadly convinced /remake was already in the game and working, while the last person had never heard about it, but jumped straight into it after he learned about it from our teammates (naturally). I've heard about it before, too, and I've been told it was implemented already - but as said I didn't read it in the patch notes, so I wasn't entirely sure about what to do and what was the right information. In the end I gave in to the begging of my teammates, who didn't want to play it out and potentially lose lp because of a disconnect, which happened anyway in the end.
It hurts a lot to have lost that lp in vain, without having tried to save the game to the bitter end - but it's over and can't be changed. I'm not gonna trust anything again before I've seen it happening (to the other team) with my own eyes.
The issue I wanna talk about is the fact that /remake redirects the originally given command to /ff, which is something completely different and fatal for unknowing players.
If you type in /remake in the chat (at the current patch) before min 20 it shouldn't display "it's too early" but something like "/remake isn't yet implemented in the game".
And more importantly: If you type in /remake later, it shouldn't make a surrender vote pop up but once again "/remake isn't yet implemented in the game. If you want to surrender the game type /ff into the chat window" or something like that (maybe better phrased, but you get the idea).
The lp loss was deserved, because you know... ignorance does not protect against punishment. But I feel like typing one command into the chat should never equal something completely different none of us wanted to do. We were dumb to think it could work, but in the end we never typed /ff and shouldn't have the client think and decide for us.
If /remake was an proper command for surrendering up to now (which might be, because the command is already doing SOMETHING before its' release, even though not what it should do) it should definitely be disabled immediately. After releasing texts about /remake on the offical website and most players having heard about it briefly it's only logical that people will try out and might destroy their game on accident because of false information and no prevention by riot's side.
If it is indeed intended for the /remake command to redirect to surrendering after 20 minutes have passed, then they should rethink that decision or at least implement a confirmation option for the one who starts the vote. Something like "The time to remake the game has passed. Are you sure you want to surrender the game with full loss consequences?".
[I hope you were all able to read through that smoothly, I'm no native english speaker and don't know how to properly phrase some of the stuff. Please don't hate, I didn't mean to offend any person or Riot. Also I know we were dumb, no need to stress that further. We're all aware and have learned the lesson the hard way. I'm over the pain of that accidental surrender, I just want to prevent it from happening to more people. Apologies if a post about it was already made, searched for one but couldn't find anything.]
Posted May 23, 2016, 10:24 AM UTC · edited