Question from a lurking nevermo. Am I witnessing history?

The stories in this sub give me such a wide range of feelings. I am so happy to read about people living their authentic lives and it makes me angry and sad to read the stories about it coming at such a high price.

After lurking on this sub for a while, it seems like the number of people willing to pay that price are higher than ever before and are leaving the church in record numbers. Is that true?

My exmo friend says that TSCC will survive like it always has before by changing the policies and the narrative to suite their needs and maintain or even grow the membership. BUT it seems like in a world where the internet exists, this strategy would only get them into problems because it would exacerbate the problem of prophets not having foresight and potentially conflicting information is out there for all to see.

My question is if there is actually a possibility that the TSCC as we know it could collapse? Is this trend actually significant in the grand scheme of things? I hope it is. I feel like I am witnessing history.

To be clear, I am not celebrating the destruction of faith and families and everything else good that is interwoven with TSCC. but even as a nevermo TSCC has had a significant impact on my life. My father is black, my mother white, and I was born in the late 70's; you can see the problem. I found it so hard to believe that my mom would give me up for adoption that reason alone; I figured I just didn't know enough about the church. I have not been interested in learning more about it until this sub brought it front and center. I have watched Mormon stories, read the CES letter It makes me even angrier to know was given up for adoption because of this nonsense. I would hate for that to happen to anyone else and this sub gives me hope that destruction at the hands of the TSCC could be a thing of the past.

Edit: added missing words

Posted May 24, 2016, 5:25 AM UTC · edited

5546
Unmormon2Best Mormon is ExMormon•

We can hope for decay, but collapse is just a pipe dream. Too many, like all those in my family, are aware of the issues and choose to believe...plus they enjoy being racist bigots.

31
jayhalk1•

Do you think this could result in terrorism by exmos? Even a small group of them?

6
Unmormon2Best Mormon is ExMormon•

Not likely. Most exmos are atheists and have no desire to spend their one life in prison, plus anything done to the Momos strengthens their testimony.

Most terrorists are the ones that take religion too far, not the other way around.

7
bananajr6000Meet Banana Jr 6000: http://goo.gl/kHVgfX•

Have you heard of the Bundy clan? It has already happened and will continue to happen in the future.

5
pseudo_logianThat's not how it works! That's not how any of this works!•

I thought the Bundy's were active mos, not exmos.

3
bananajr6000Meet Banana Jr 6000: http://goo.gl/kHVgfX•

I misread your question. The only exmos who might fit the mold of domestic terrorism are those who join a movement something like the Sovereigns, replacing one cult with another.

Most exmos become more rational and empathetic, not extremists.

8
jayhalk1•

No? Sounds interesting though...

1
HelenofRavenclaw•

I've seen a couple of posters on here recently who seem pretty... Hitler-y? They keep preaching how evil every single mormon is (even us exmos) and it's starting to sound very genocidal. And nonsensical. I could see it happening.

It's so easy to jump from one extremist belief to another.

5
jayhalk1•

That's what's talking about... What if somebody goes and blows up a Chappell in the name of r/exmormon...

2
HelenofRavenclaw•

I could definitely see it happening. Combine the extremist nature of people in the church, coupled by the abuses of TSCC on members, and how difficult it is finding footing after leaving one's faith, and it would be a recipe for this sort of violence with the "right" individual.

I pray to gob that never happens.

2
fa1thlessFaith means not wanting to know what is true.•

Does Mark Hoffman fall under this?

2
Corsair64Who told thee that thou wast naked?•

Mark Hofmann could be considered the poster boy for an apostate terrorist, especially to believers. He fits a narrative that believers hold to that still leaves the church being true. To a TBM, Hofmann was an evil apostate looking to bring down the church through deception. He failed and is in jail. The actual details about what Hofmann did accomplish are very embarrassing to the church. Faithful Mormons would prefer this event to fade away as long as the institutional church survives.

4
protectedbybarney•

Although Hoffman hated the church, his violence was precipitated by financial motives, not hatred of any ideology, so he doesn't really qualify as a terrorist, but as a murderer. Embarrassing the church was merely a side benefitl

1
FearlessFixxerEvil Apostate/Regular Dude...depends on who you ask•

There is definitly an exodus going on like nothing the church has seen before.

Almost every mormon now has at least one close friend or family member that has left the church.

The church leaders are constantly talking about it...

What will the tangible effect be? It is hard to say.

There are always going to be a core group of members and I doubt the church will.make major changes on the lgbt issue....so I think you will see mormons stay the same, there will just be fewer of them.

21
kolobs_bitch•

Could we compile a list of major exodus eras for the LDS church?

I have a feeling our apostasy is merely the most recent. While we might have higher numbers, it's probably not the highest, proportionally speaking.

Other eras to consider:

  1. Kirkland Bank Failure

  2. JS polygamy rumors

  3. Brigham takes over the church and leaves for Salt Lake Valley

  4. Woodruff's revelation renouncing polygamy

  5. Word of Wisdom becomes doctrine

  6. LDS church attacks feminism and the ERA

  7. Blacks get the priesthood

  8. September Six

6
FearlessFixxerEvil Apostate/Regular Dude...depends on who you ask•

A good list.

What is the current era?

The Google Apostacy

8
subneutrino•

I believe there was an exodus of sorts in 1978 when they allowed blacks to receive the priesthood.

3
isperfectlycromulentNeverMo, AlwaysAmused•

Blacks get the priesthood now?? That's it, I'm out.

4
BizarroBednar•

Your username tickles me. Well done.

3
kolobs_bitch•

Oh yes, of course! Forgot that one! I'll add it in now.

1
zando95Gosh, Mormonism is silly.•

Religion evolves, and cult members keep having kids.

12
IchibanJC•

Every other major world religion has changed their policies and narratives to suit the times as well. I don't see how TSCC would be any different.

I think LDS leadership has already made it clear that past revelation is irrelevant as soon as new revelation comes along. If Members are willing to accept this GLARING contradiction, TSCC can continue for all time and eternity.

9
daveescaped•

Agreed. It wouldn't even surprise me if by the time I die of old age, that tscc will finally be the church that I would have stayed a member of today. But by then it will be too late. It's like when you dump a girl because she doesn't have her crap together. Then 20 years later you see her and she's lost weight, had a boob job, graduated, spent time with a therapist, quit drinking, etc. But by then you've moved on.

Apologies for the sexist example.

5
higherthenkolob•

The internet is definitely a no win situation for the LDS church and the best and brightest are leaving in record numbers but the church is loaded with capitol and enough members who do not want to know the truth. You are witnessing a down sizing but will probably not see a collapse.

9
deirdresm•

Also a nevermo, been here a couple months.

Based on my experience in Scientology, no. It will not go away in any sort of hurry, even when the leader's a rat bastard. (Referring to Scientology in this case.)

9
Unmormon2Best Mormon is ExMormon•

Hey, there's no monopoly on Rasbastards.

2
Anti-MormonIt's like Anti-Nephi-Lehi, but different•

I've always said that within 3 generations the LDS church as we know it will become Scientology levels or less. Ie, they might have a lot of money, but very very few members.

I'm personally hoping we can bring it down to 2 generations.

7
The_True_Zephos•

Maybe in the US, but there are a lot of high baptizing missions in poor/ less developed nations where information is not as easily accessible. I think it is more likely that the church becomes more and more foreign.

2
Fulk_Anjou•

Unfortunately for the church, retention rates are less than 25% outside of the US. Baptisms per missionary have been slipping for the better part of two decades (they peaked in the late 1990's) as well. I just don't see the church making significant, or rapid headway overseas.

That's not to say that the church won't have limited success in some poor/developing countries, but, overall I think the church will have a tough time converting and retaining people going forward. Even in poor countries. Each new convert costs the church and its membership tremendously. At some point, the cost of sending an army of young people into the world to win converts will reach the point of diminishing returns. I wonder what the church will do when/if that happens.

3
Zuikis9•

As long as they have money, they will find a way to get new members. :(

1
oomchu•

I don't think it's going anywhere. They'll just repackage it somehow. There is just too much power and money to let it go. If you want to use the Matrix analogy, it seems for every person willing to take the red pill there are nine others that take the blue pill. There are always people who want to believe crazy shit and that will never change.

5
12th_Tribe•

Google and its open door to knowledge, has been the downfall of many institutions in its short lifespan.

The church may survive, but it is hemorrhaging rapidly. I think you are seeing history.

5
Rickokicko•

To be clear, I am celebrating the destruction of this faith.

4
opentoinput•

I am a nevermo as well. I think that we are witnessing history. I don't know the numbers but American as a whole is becoming much less religious.

2
MinisteringAnglePatty cake and taffy pulling be upon me and my posterity•

Your story makes me so sad. Yes, this is why I fight against the church. Because innocent people are greatly harmed by their stupid policies.

2
Kelpie00•

Religions are like roaches: They'll even survive a nuclear holocaust :P

2
given2fly_Australia Brisbane Mission 2005-2007•

The collapse will be slow and barely noticed. We're seeing a lot of millenials leaving, but the generation before us is pretty strong and set in its ways, and the church is making massive efforts to inoculate and keep the next generation. The rising generation of Mormon kids is more extreme and devout than my millenial generation were, but I think their retention rate is worse than its ever been.

In my lifetime we'll see a demographic gap emerge, and in 20-30 years they might feel it in the pocket as millenials enter their big earning years and aren't paying tithing. But the church is so wealthy in its investments that it can ride that storm.

The only thing that would conceivably cause a collapse would be a series of devastating scandals, and I just can't see that happening. I just see them shrinking and becoming more extreme.

2
sevans105Just the facts, ma'am•

THIS. Sadly, I see this as the most realistic depiction of the future of the brighamite branch of Mormonism. Yeah, they're bleeding now, but they won't. They reproduce too fast. Their retention levels are lower but they were always at 30%

They'll adjust, like they have in the past. My only hope is to be the means of guiding as much of my immediate family out over the next years. The Mormons are gonna be around for a looooong time. Just my opinion, of course.

1
Zadok_The_Priest•

You are always witnessing history every day. Just probably won't be written down, unless you keep your own journal.

I personally believe that the number of members of the church who are discovering the church's truth crisis is increasing. There is such a wealth of information available on the Internet which was never available to the regular member before.

Under this weight of information, it is difficult to maintain an absolutely flawless view of the church. Will the church collapse? I doubt it. Will there be some major changes coming as we go forward through the decades. Absolutely! Things will change dramatically over the next 20 to 30 years.

2
JetBinFever•

Yep! And they'll pretend that it was never like that, because God is unchanging and all that... You know, like those unchanging, ancient temple ordinances.

1
JetBinFever•

Sadly, like the old saying goes, "There's a sucker born every minute." And despite all the amazing scholarship and work that countless folks are pouring in to trying to help others see the church for what it really is, fairly, intelligently, and for themselves... there will always be people that still buy into the Mormon fever dream.

They use group psychology in harmful ways to steer and manipulate people and control thoughts that may challenge that control. And so, even though more people than ever may leave and the church will hemorrhage some of its most thoughtful, compassionate, and intelligent members... there will always be more vulnerable people to baptize and indoctrinate.

This isn't to say that we won't see reactions to slow this process. There will be a few meaningless reforms, a few loosenings here and there, but then it will be back business as usual.

Edit: grammar

2
Texas-TB•

I think that we are. The church will not be able to keep up the narrative growth is the most difficult problem.

1
BrotherSneetch•

It's a faith that "works" for some types of people. It can be a very supportive community. It gives people a common language to talk about spirituality. It has a strong goal-setting and achievement focus.

I see it working for many people.

I've also seen the faith work for the uneducated and poor. It really helps some people develop some habits and purpose that they otherwise would not have without the faith.

I'm hesitant to even guess what happens. It's run by a handful of people at the top, so much of its direction is determined by the decisions of those few.

Economic prosperity is not going to be kind to Mormonism. Greater access to information will not be kind to Mormonism. Equal opportunities for women in secular society will not be kind to Mormonism. Greater understanding of human sexuality will not be kind to Mormonism.

Basically, the advance of Western civilization will not be kind to Mormonism.

Time will tell.

1
elder-batmanSwear to ME!•

It probably won't collapse in my lifetime, or indeed many of the others here, but it will collapse. One day, it will be exposed, fully and completely, for what it is.

It will no longer have any hold on people. That said, recent years have seen a major increase in memberships being terminated/people resigning.

1
exmo88•

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

1