My 9-day gender swapped profile test.

So, I posted back here I was attempting this M->F. Basically swapped on review sites and Amazon my gender, made a alternate email, changed username to a full female one, hipster stock photo and all that. This also is only for 100% free items.

https://www.reddit.com/r/ProductTesting/comments/4jtb7x/anyone_try_a_genderswapped_profile/

It's 9 days later and thought I would share anything I noticed.

Tomoson/Reviewkick sellers definitely seem to take gender into account on on items or at least look at your name etc... In the 9 days I tried this I was approved for almost every item(Multiple on a few) I had applied for months previously(At least 20+ times from some of the sellers) and never been approved on a single time(Lunchboxes, Snack Packs, Kitchenware, Womens Clothing, stuff like that). Overall, it seems approval went up slightly, just due to extra selection.

Amazon Review Trader ones didn't seem to follow this, but this may be due to the low amount of free items offered.

Seemingly I received less email offers(May be due to the email swap etc... though or profile crawlers not picking it up).

Up-votes/down-votes seem unchanged. This may also be because most of my votes only come from a few reviews that really catch on. I did receive more comments from people saying they liked my reviews though, although, this may be because I have been intentionally trying to make them a bit funnier more lately.

None of this is some definite conclusive thing. But as far as I can tell that's the situation.

Posted May 27, 2016, 7:04 PM UTC · edited

312
OFUB•

Interesting about Tomoson, as they are harder to get approved for. With my rank improvement, I am getting more approvals from RK than before, and with AMZRT it has never been an issue.

With Tomoson I gave up after a about a month, and canceled my account. Granted that was back when my ranking was in the 20-30ish K range. Maybe I should set up a new account, now that I am in the 6K range, and see if that makes a difference.

As for gender, the way my name is setup and anyone looking at my reviews, can easily determine my gender. ;)

Thanks for doing this little experiment/test, definitely interesting. Although I am not really surprised at the increase in approvals for you, because studies show that most women do the majority of shopping for their household.

1
Mikazah•

I'm in the 200k range and I get some stuff on Tomoson. Not a lot, but I get a product every other day or so. I think a lot of them are looking for people with blogs and social media - not just Amazon. But some are okay with just Amazon.

2
ReapterOP•

Yeah, I actually started as Amazon only on Tomoson and did quite a few. I made a Instagram/Twitter way after the fact way into it. Most of them are seeking Amazon in general.

Blog type stuff just gives a bonus to your chance of being selected if they are only handing out like 10 items.

2
Mikazah•

That makes sense. I know I turned down applying for some things since they required instagram/twitter/facebook. I was thinking about doing twitter and instagram, maybe facebook too, but I wasn't sure if that'd cause a fuss with Amazon so I've been hesitant.

1
ReapterOP•

They can't require you to do anything. Just uncheck the other options. Most of them just click all for some reason. Chances are if there is a star option, it's probably looking for Amazon.

As far as the others, as long as you don't link your own review it shouldn't(You will see this asked and should just ignore it). I link the Amazon page physically instead.

1
OFUB•

You got lucky with just Amazon only, as I started with that - and when I wasn't getting any approvals, I added FB/Twitter - still nothing.

Someone suggested that I request a paid item, and then get the seller to leave me feedback, as it worked for them, and they get more approvals now - so I may try that.

Too bad they don't count G+, as I have over almost 27K followers there! lol

1
BoldIntrepid•

lol I've been trying to get sellers to leave me feedback; I've gotten only 3 approved things from tomoson but I never got any feedback :(

2
wonderwhatif•

I'm at 3K reach and get an ok amount from Tomoson. Mostly for stuff that wants Amazon reviews.

Good experiment!

I was actually surprised to be offered so much tech stuff, as a woman, so I find that reviews feel like one place women don't get discriminated against. Men maybe...judging by your findings.

2
bhargavat•

I requested on items that don't favor a gender, such as electronics, and I don't seem to get approvals. Should I switch to female to improve my luck :P?

0
ReapterOP•

Actually, my only fear in all this was swapping to female would lower the amount of electronics I get approved for. Not like Ear-Buds and cell phone stuff, but like actual electronic systems and digital multi-meters etc...

I don't think it will affect it to much though. Electronics is actually one of my more approved for items previously(Received a ton of gaming keyboards/mice/headsets/speaker systems etc...).

They don't come up enough though for me to have been able to tell a difference. Contacting those companies directly through their websites or using power user programs generally are the best way though(Don't contact them through Amazon).

1
Mikazah•

Honestly, women do seem to get fewer electronics until they get the reviews up. I have numerous of higher end electronics/computer parts/accessories reviewed on my account (from before I even started product testing) and it took me almost a month to get approved for even a cell phone cable or a pair of earbuds. However, once I got a few dozen up there, the products became for frequent and better. I still get denied for most electronics though (took me like 15 applies to even get a vga to hdmi adapter... those aren't that popular. Around 10 tries for a simple hdmi splitter.) But even if I apply within a few seconds of the listing, getting electronics of any sort is tough.

On the flip side, I do get offers for baby stuff all the time... which I previously had nothing of the sort on my review page. Kitchen stuff I almost always get approved for, womens clothes are practically guaranteed, mens stuff is always denied (even if it was something I'd actually wear/use. I do prefer mens wallets and belts...)

But as you said, AMZ doesn't seem to be as big of a difference, but on Tomoson the difference is huge.

So it seems to me they do take gender into account somewhat. If your profile already has the category going well, it seems that the difference is minimal though.

1