All former Shield members are currently undefeated at Extreme Rules.

Extreme Rules 2013
*Dean Ambrose def. Kofi Kingston (c) for the United States Championship
*The Shield (Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins) def. Team Hell No (c) for the WWE Tag Team Championship in a tornado tag team match

Extreme Rules 2014
*The Shield def. Evolution in a six-man tag team match

Extreme Rules 2015
*Dean Ambrose def. Luke Harper in a Chicago street fight
*Roman Reigns def. Big Show in a last man standing match
*Seth Rollins (c) def. Randy Orton for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship in a steel cage match

Extreme Rules 2016
*Dean Ambrose def. Chris Jericho in an Asylum match
*Roman Reigns (c) def. AJ Styles for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship in an extreme rules match