r/dogs•
CryptoProofs

[Help][Vent] It's finally happened

Vent

So it's finally happened to us too, our dog got into a fight yesterday. I don't know whether he was the initiator of the fight, because it was really close; still, Luci was leashed and the other TWO dogs were not.

  • Luci's state: Before anyone gets too worried: Luci came out of the scrape with a fright, a lot of tension, and a small cut on his lip. It wasn't bigger than your average papercut, and the bleeding stopped in 1-2 minutes. We used clean paper handkerchiefs to stop it and have been checking it regularly. He seems fine. Since going to the vet is a huge stress, we would like to only do it if absolutely necessary.

  • Big question: What I would really like is basically a bit of constructive support as to what we could have done better. So here's a description of what I saw last night, and what my instincts tell me. It may be a bit long, but I'll try to get the details, too.

When and where: It was last night, around 7 pm. My husband, Luci, and I were coming home after our run together. The incident happened in a field with a narrow dirt path, not far from our home. The area was relatively open, but we were sort of towards one side where there is a bit less room to maneouver.

Prelude on leashes, and leash habits: Usually it's either my husband, or I, who take him out, but last night it was both. When we go together, we have an arrangement that each of us takes the leash for a while, and we are responsible for what happens during that time. We have different styles of walking Luci. My husband likes to let him romp around at a better distance, I like him closer; I usually tend to let him socialize with dogs for short times, my husband is a lot more patient. Because of this, and to avoid tension, whenever one of us has the leash, the other HAS to respect their choices. We use a Flexi 8m leash, which Luci prefers and which we have never had problems with.

An additional piece of information: Luci is almost never off-leash when we are with him. He only gets to be off-leash in a specific place (a very large playing field that's closed by net wiring on three sides, with the fourth being almost enclosed by trees (there's a small exit path, but we can certainly make sure he doesn't stray there when we play)) AND under specific conditions: no dogs, no humans, no other animals.

The incident: Last night, Luci had had a lot of running, romping around on this field, lots of chasing each other around, a bit of digging, and we were all returning home. When I say "lots", I mean at least 1 hr of running with us or off-leash, some sprinting, some jogging, and about 20 minutes of walking interspersed in there.

My husband had the leash when we met the dogs in question. There are two of them, one is probably a certified mutt, the other is a mix with some sort of bully -- don't want to say ABPT, because I don't know, but he is medium sized and has that wide head and really strong torso. My husband said that he knew the dogs; I didn't. The dogs were off-leash, with their owner (heavy-set, older guy with a ruddy face and some sort of rope probably serving as a leash in his hand, ambling along some 30m behind his dogs).

First thing that happend was, the two dogs basically besieged Luci. I would never have let it happen, because I know that Luci hates being butt-sniffed. But as my husband had the lead, I let him do as he saw fit. The smaller mutt (whose head looks like a JR terrier's, but who is bigger, probably 35cm tall at the shoulder and he is about 60 cm long, nose to root of tail) went for the butt. The bully-mix went for the nose. They were nose to nose for maybe 30 seconds or so. My husband was behind and a bit to Luci's right hand side, I had stopped some 3m behind Luci (so I was behind the mutt too). Luci's Flexi leash was unblocked, because if we block it he gets nervous (probably at knowing he can't really defend himself).

I thought Luci was stiff. It could be just an opinion, because I know he hates being sniffed. His tail was not entirely bottle-brush up, but certainly going upward, with a kind of bow in the middle. For reference: whenever he is happy, confident, and proud, Luci's tail resembles nothing as much as it does a featherduster held straight up. When he is tired, but happy, it's sort of horizontal, with a small bed upwards. He was NOT moving the tail when the mutt started sniffing.

Suddenly, and I don't know why, or who made the first move, Luci and the bully mix were fighting. They were standing up on their back legs, trading blows with their mouths and their front legs. It was over very fast. I called to Luci and moved to get rid of the mutt, my husband went to separate Luci from the bully. The bully's owner started shouting at his pet, but didn't bother to get there. I moved in to interpose my body between the bully and Luci while my husband held Luci's leash and protected him behind him. The bully came back for more, but coudn't get through. Luci was growling so hard I thought the ground was shaking.

The guy finally took his bully by the scruff of the neck -- no kidding, with his fingers, no leash, and just asked me if I was ok. Since I didn't want him hovering with two unleashed dogs there, I just told him that he should leash the dogs and move along (I was probably more polite, but that was the essence of it). A few seconds later we discovered Luci's bleeding lip.

Luci was traumatised enough to sit down on the grass for a solid three minutes. He didn't want us to carress him, just lay down on his belly for a few minutes. I think he was really scared and exhausted. After a few minutes, he started walking again and we got home soon after.

What I think happened: Luci felt pinned between the two dogs. Whether it was he who attacked, or if one dog reacted to the movements of the other, I can't tell. I think it would have been better to make sure only one dog at the most had access to Luci at any one time, but if they dogs are off leash that's harder to do. I still think my huband could easily have stepped in and made sure the mutt did not go for a spot he KNOWS Luci is sensitive to. However, I am also aware that I am always the overcautious one, and that while with me, Luci does not get to interact as much with other dogs as he maybe should.

So that's it. A long post, but it's been haunting me, so please help.

Posted May 31, 2016, 9:36 AM UTC

178
sebeth204Jarrod - Greyhound•

I know you guys have an agreement, but IMO you guys (and especially Luci) would benefit from rehashing the details. You're doggie co-parents, and it would help you both (and especially Luci) to have each other's backs when it comes to certain situations. It doesn't help either of you (or especially Luci) if one of you feels like you can't intervene when the person holding the leash isn't paying attention or misses some serious doggy body language.

At the minimum, sit down and discuss how the two of you want to handle interactions with other dogs, known or not. Set guidelines (i.e. no greeting off-leash dogs, maximum of 15 seconds, et cetera) that you both agree to uphold - you may have to compromise. Throughout this conversation, focus on what's best for Luci - not what's most fun or most comfortable for the handler. If you feel like you need more information, research your questions together. Read some articles on body language together. Even if you prefer different walking styles - and that's fine when you're in an isolated environment - agree on when and how to step in. If you run into the same situation, how does he want you to bring the issue to his attention? It's irresponsible to let Luci get into bad situations because you're afraid of touching each other's pride.

This conversation may lead to a lot of other "what if" conversations. That's excellent! Communication, compromise, and cooperation are key in any caregiving partnership, and puppy parenting is no exception.

7
CryptoProofsOP•

Hey! Thanks a lot for the input.

I've actually been trying to get this done for a while. I think pride has little to do with the whole thing, honestly. It's not because of pride that we give each other space. The main reason to do it is because otherwise it would drive Luci crazy to hear us bickering about it all the time. It's happened in the past, it makes the walk really a terrible experience.

Personally, I can't stand seeing other dogs off leash heading towards Luci. The minute it happens, I get ready to intervene. On very rare occasions I will allow more than 3-5 seconds of interaction with another dog. This is usually when Luci shows me he really feels he should meet the other dog. Common signs are: slight whining, excess sniffing, and Luci lying down on his belly, but with his mouth open.

I have tried to get through some body language videos, body language books, etc. Honestly, it's much easier to see it in books than in the few seconds that something important actually happens. I would be really, really interested to see if you have anything that can help me get a visual intuition which is not static (like in a book).

There is another really important aspect to this whole each-to-his-own-style thing. My husband has been able to make some great progress with Luci because he is extremely calm and patient with other-dog encounters. I think his reassuring vibes really help in that sense, at least when that's possible.

Me, I am the opposite of that. I think a part of it is some sort of instinctive empathy. I let Luci's behaviour really imprint on me, and sometimes make decisions based on them. It's why I actually can't stand taking him to the vet, I see his fear and it's making me react badly. I physically can't bring myself to be as calm and level-headed as my husband is when we meet other dogs, other people, etc.

I think the most difficult and trying aspect is exactly that: how much meeting time is reasonable, and how do I ensure that my behaviour doesn't make things worse.

1
n0diggityLily Black Lab / Luna Staffy•

Oh yikes. The entire time you were describing the incident I was cringing. Not only is Luci probably freaked out by the two dogs but they were off leash and he was on leash.

When walking my bully I rarely ever have her greet other dogs. She's great and loves to meet them, but more often than not the other dog's owner is nervous and tensing up on their dog's leash so I just say we're in a rush and continue on. I ALWAYS put myself in between the dogs so mine feel more secure.

I know your husband might expect every dog to be nice but that extended greeting could go very wrong like you saw.

5
CryptoProofsOP•

Well, I've always thought off-leash dogs were a bit problematic. Usually what I do when I see one from afar is just hold Luci close and stop, trying to send a signal to the other owner that Luci is aggressive. It's not true: he isn't, but it's much safer if the other dog is leashed as well.

I really hate it when people are just being comfortable about their pets. I've met a chihuahua mix in the middle of the road because his owner walks him off leash and he -- the owner -- had stopped to talk to this old biddy at the corner of the street. I brought the dog back to the owner, but still, come on!

I really appreciate it when dog owners behave responsibly, and leash their dogs when they see another dog. At least in public areas.

1
ChrissygandtiIs 5 dogs too many?•

First, I'm sorry this happened to you. Why does it seem like all owners of bully-looking breeds seem to have no common sense? Like-- don't they want to protect their dog at least marginally?

Either way, to be honest, I agree with you. Your husband should've stepped in a lot faster instead of just allowing these dogs to rush up to Luci especially with him on a leash. I know he said he knew the dogs, but even then, I don't let known dogs greet my dog if one is off leash and the other isn't. I ALWAYS come between other dogs and mine and I will body block them until I can flag down their owner to get their dogs. When they say their dog is friendly or whatever, I always say "Yeah that's nice, but mine isn't." (Obviously). Because I've got a variety of dog sizes AND I have three big dogs, two being pit bulls, I take no risks when it comes to leash manners and two automatically heel the entire walk. One of my PBTs does walk off leash, but I keep a leash handy and leash her at busy intersections or if we see an unfamiliar dog. She's incredibly friendly because she lived in rescue for years but I understand that a stocky black pit bull doesn't exactly look like a friendly animal. I don't understand how anyone would be able to block their dog from potential attacks or fights if they weren't walking at their side.

On the contrary, I am not against greeting where both dogs are on leash, it's about 5 seconds long, and then both dogs move along. With most dog greetings there's that initial approach, some slow tail wagging, and then a decision is made. I basically like to intervene before the "decision" to react negatively can be made and I reward my dog for a good interaction and then continue walking.

2
alithia-{GSD Land Shark}-•

On the contrary, I am not against greeting where both dogs are on leash, it's about 5 seconds long, and then both dogs move along. With most dog greetings there's that initial approach, some slow tail wagging, and then a decision is made. I basically like to intervene before the "decision" to react negatively can be made and I reward my dog for a good interaction and then continue walking.

This! One of the first things our trainer taught us in our dog-dog introductions class was that three seconds and call it time. She said that it is usually long enough to say, but not long enough for someone to piss someone off.

Off leash/on leash introductions are unfair and they can escalate a situation because the on leash dog feels a little trapped. I know this happens with Tesla, so I personally body block or emergency u-turn out.

4
ChrissygandtiIs 5 dogs too many?•

Yup!

1
msivy_Lplatehuman•

First thing - calm down. No-one got seriously hurt, and you need to try to not let this colour either your relationship with your husband or with your dog.

if you go out tensed up, expecting trouble, as if you are walking through sniper's alley your dog will pick up on it, and the whole experience of taking the dog out will become a trial and not enjoyment. And yes, I have been there. It will also make your dog more likely to react to other dogs, if you are projecting nervousness.

Don't go out with the expectation of trouble. Treat this as a one-off which is in the past, and go out the next time with the expectation of an enjoyable and relaxing experience, and that is what your dog will expect too.

Not going to offer relationship advice other than don't over think it and don't go over the incident in forensic detail. You will probably never understand the dog behaviour underlying the fracas because these thing happen really quickly and your priority is to nake sure everyone walks away unhurt - which you did - so congratulate yourself on responding in the right way and making sure that happened.

You will never be able to predict how every dog to dog interaction will go, so don't try. Be an aware and responsive dog owner, and it will be fine. There is no "right" way to do this other than being in the moment and focused on your dog and it sounds to me as if you did a great job in that respect.

2