r/crossfit•
LDN2016

Furthest running you would recommend in Reebok Nano 4.0s? Considering whether I need to buy running shoes.

Mainly do lifting (powerlifting and some BB stuff). Bought the CF shoes for versatility since I play a little ball, tennis etc for funa nd urban climbing type stuff so the rope protection is great.

Now running a lot more but only 5k distance. Are the 4.0's good enough without breaking down/causing injury issues?

Posted Jun 1, 2016, 6:38 PM UTC

238
Kozinskey•

Oh god no. As a runner and a Crossfitter, please get yourself some real running shoes if you're doing 5k distance with any kind of regularity. I don't go more than a mile in my Nanos. That's partly because the toe box is so wide that it's a recipe for slippage & blisters, and partly because Nanos have a 0mm drop from the heel to the toe. Most running shoes, except for minimalist ones, will have 6-12mm drop from the heel to the toe to better cushion/support/enhance a typical running stride.

What I mean by "real running shoes:" go to your local running store, have them watch you run, and fit a shoe for you based on your stride. It's likely to be half a size to a size bigger than you think you are to accommodate your feet swelling as you run. Trust me when I say shoes that don't meet these criteria will fuck you up in the long run. Don't go to Dick's and buy whatever's on clearance. Running shoes are pricey but it's a hell of a lot better than an IT band injury.

7
LDN2016OP•

Nanos have a 0mm drop from the heel to the toe

4mm

4
Kozinskey•

TIL

2
Bill2theECrossFit FitCross•

Lack of stride efficiency is mainly what causes people to have things hurt in non-running shoes. Running shoes just put a band-aid over your bad stride and let you get away with your inefficiencies. If you run well, you can run in any shoe.

4
Kozinskey•

I still think the roomy toe box is an issue and have blisters to prove it. Also, unless you already have good form, I don't think it's a good idea to jump into running in almost-flat shoes like Nanos at the distances OP is doing. Better to work on his form in real running shoes and transition down over time.

2
Bill2theECrossFit FitCross•

Most running shoes are made with roomy toe boxes to allow the toes to more naturally splay as you run. I get blisters if the toe box is too small because my toes rub against one another. And I'm not saying he should run out to a minimal shoe either; some people that's good for, some people that's not. I'm just simply advocating that form > shoe always.

1
hosemonkey•

I had a running store do a gait analysis and put me in some shoes that correct my stride. Any time I run in them I get shooting leg pains and sore knees. I can run miles in my nanos with no pain.

I don't know what the point of my post is other than I hate my fancy running shoes.

2
Kozinskey•

Go get yourself refitted. Take in the shoes you have so they can look at the wear patterns, and explain to them the issues you're having.

Anecdotally, I ran in stability shoes for years because I have flat feet so it looks like I overpronate. I actually supinate quite a bit, based on the wear patterns on my shoes. Running got so much more comfortable for me once I realized I know more about my stride than a stranger, even a shoe expert.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Bill2theECrossFit FitCross•

Running is all about being as efficient as possible yet, for some reason, CrossFitters with all their talk about efficiency don't want to learn how to run properly. If you saw a guy with terrible snatch form at your gym you'd look at him and go, "Bro, you could lift more weight, be less tired, and not have your shoulder hurt all the time if you cleaned up your form." Yet, when shoes make your feet hurt when you run, no one ever thinks maybe it's because I'm doing something wrong. It's always the shoe's fault. Efficient strides don't hurt. Inefficient strides do. Look at most actual runners; their flats could barely be qualified as shoes but they run relatively pain free because of efficiency. Instead people go clamoring to find a shoe that will let them run inefficiently without hurting instead of getting stronger and better at running efficiently. Running shoes are a band-aid to let you get away with an inefficient stride. If you fix your stride you can run in any shoes you'd like. It takes time and effort just like learning how to do a barbell movement properly, but it's worth it. Find someone who knows running and can teach you how to run then, once you've gotten it down, you can go get some running shoes as long as you keep good, efficient form in them. I've even ran in lifters before as well as barefoot because I've been known to be dumb and forget my shoes at home. Never have I had running pain.

5
Galvanized_neoprene•

THIS!
Came into crossfit a runner, haven't tried the Nanos, but do all my strength/CF in Inov8 F-lite 195's, which are even more minimal than the Nanos (or barefoot).
I can run for hours in them as well, and have, most recently a 17.5km run on saturday.
They're my absolute favourite running shoe for paved roads and gravel!

3
LDN2016OP•

i mean people run in vibrams and barefoot so how bad could the nano 4.0s be?

i havent kept up with common knowledge but wasnt the whole padding/cushioning, orthotics based on your gait thing panned as a fraud and waste of time?

1
Bill2theECrossFit FitCross•

Running is like squatting, we have to deal with anatomical/bony structures as well as strength issues and mobility issues when building or rebuilding a squat or a running stride. You have to take the anatomical advantages and disadvantages of a person into mind when considering proper running form for that person. People with fallen arches can definitely benefit with the extra arch support of shoes built for pronation, but they can also benefit from foot strengthening, gait analysis, skill practice, and mobility to help rebuild a bit of an arch. So shoes based on gait are not fraudulent and are probably less fraudulent than Vibram saying their shoes were better for you. Foot strengthening and building an efficient stride is better for you and some people were able to do that in Vibrams but it also exacerbated a lot of injuries in other people. You have to take the individual into account when building or rebuilding a gait and some tools will work for some people that won't work for others. Ideally, you want the athlete to become "shoe agnostic" meaning it doesn't matter what shoes they're in, they always run the same way. Then, once they've built an efficient stride and can hold it in any shoe, a shoe with cushioning can do them well but they should also regularly practice (typically on speed days) running in a lighter, more minimal shoe.

As proof of concept, you all inspired me to go for a run tonight when I got home in my old, dilapidated yet still beloved Nano 3's which are in quite poor form because I wore my Spider-Man flavored Nanos everywhere all the time. 5 Kilometers down and no foot pain or any pain at all to speak of outside of the typical, "Running is the worst," BoJack Horesman monologue type pain. Here are my shoes with their "insoles" (if they can still even be called that...) removed just so you can see how terrible of a state they're in to help prove stride trumps shoe any day of the week.

http://m.imgur.com/EQAGwZ8

PS I'm 6'1" 210#, definitely not one of those tiny little runner types either.

1
Kozinskey•

People who run in vibrams transition into them over time. If you go to the vibram website it lays out how to do that, but the key is that you go really short distances in them for several months as you learn not to heel strike and to take short, quick steps. Going out for medium or long distances in minimalist shoes without that background is going to hurt, because your form will deteriorate when you get tired.

And remember, everyone's different. There are definitely people who do very well in vibrams (like my dad! Shoutout to a guy who won his age division at his last marathon) but if you watch races, they're the exception rather than the rule. I think your better bet is to get in some quality running shoes, do some research on form, and work on that for at least a year or two before going to a minimalist shoe.

1
nickiter•

Vibram/barefoot style running can be done very efficiently... There's not really a known running style that's highly efficient while wearing nanos. That's not to say you can't run in them, but given a good form they're just not an optimal shoe for any style.

1
RealNotFake•

I disagree somewhat, because the wrong shoe can interfere with the way your foot strikes. A minimalist shoe places the burden on you to have good technique but a bulky shock absorbing running shoe forces you to heel strike the second you start to fatigue. I don't have nanos but I would guess they're somewhere in between.

1
Bill2theECrossFit FitCross•

Running shoes definitely don't force you to heel strike when you start to fatigue, bad mechanics and motor memory force you to heel strike when you start to fatigue. I've seen many people who can maintain nominal stride technique while in everyday trainer type running shoes. It's just like a barbell movement once again, the more fatigued you are, the more likely you are to catch that clean goofy or round out your back. However, the people that train and stress movement patterns are the least likely to lose form under fatigue. Rowing, burpees, snatches, whatever, it's all the same. What did the announcers at Regionals say almost redundantly over the past three weeks? "They make their last rep look just as good as their first." Technique is critical and if you are losing technique for any movement while under fatigue than you've reached the point of diminishing returns and it may be time to call it quits for the day or scale down the intensity or else you risk hurting yourself.

3
nickiter•

It's not always easy to find a coach that can teach running.

1
Bill2theECrossFit FitCross•

Agreed. It's also not easy to find people who can coach gymnastics or weightlifting or swimming or pole vaulting or horseback riding or anything, but, if you want to do it and do it with efficacy, you'll look for it.

1
jahupru•

Great comments about taking the time to learn proper running form, but Nano 4s could definitely use some design improvement to be useful in running. My biggest complaint is the lack of a metatarsal joint in the sole, compare to any running shoe. I'm sure it's to make them more stable in lifting, but makes them unbearable to run with a forefoot or midfoot strike. You have to land and push off with a flat foot, or your Achilles will let you know it's not happy.

1
Jdudley13•

It has been said but to enforce how strong the opinion is, get running shoes. No more than a mile in Nanos (metcons) is my personal opinion. I honestly use my running shoes to wod most of the time unless there is a barbell in the wod.

3
nolahxcCrossFit Shoryuken•

I own the nano 4's and I personally wouldn't run a 5k in these shoes. I do, however, think the nano 4s are really good for almost everything else CrossFit has to offer.

I have a pair of Brooks Ravenna 7s that I bought exclusively for running and the fact that the pronation in my left ankle was nearly 10 degrees (yikes). Those shoes corrected that issue I had. Whenever we have a WOD that requires a fair amount of running, I pull out the running shoes and my legs are thanking me afterwards.

5k is a long distance, and feels even longer with the wrong shoes. It's not a bad idea to get some decent running shoes.

2
thedogmatrix•

From your bar to the next piece of equipment you're using max.

2
BrittainTheCommie•

To the mailbox and back.

2
AmrapPlusOne•

I ran in my Nano Pumps for a few weeks. I switched over to some real running shoes and I couldn't believe how much better I felt after the run. I would say train in your nanos, run in some good running shoes. Over time running in nanos is not a good idea. It will eventually hurt your knees and ankles.

2
misteral•

I've worn mine on a few 5k's, mainly when traveling and can't pack an assortment of shoes to chose from.

For my feet they worked fine. It's a pretty neutral shoe, so as long as it works for your running you should be fine. Take it out and see how they feel

1
LDN2016OP•

did a few longer distance runs (10 miles) and they hurt my toes but that was to be expected and i was breaking em in.

was wondering if people regularly did short-medium distances in them. i was thinking of atleast 20-25 km per week, 5k at a time

1
queenmab776•

I have also run 5ks and even a 10 miler in my nano 2 without issue

1
lumberjackd9•

I never run more than 800m in nanos.

1
Tabbychiro•

I have Nano 4s and wouldn't run more than 800m at a time in them. But I am also a very terrible runner.

1
onceuponaclick•

I won't run more than a mile in nanos. Beyond that, I switch to running shoes, and I think it's worth the investment. I got a stress fracture from running in bad shoes once upon a time (I was running about 3 miles 5 days a week), and now I just don't mess around with having proper footwear. You should definitely get some running shoes. You'll protect yourself and save a lot of wear and tear on your nanos.

1
Steveesmuyguapo•

I did murph in a pair of broken in fours and my feet were fine

1
LDN2016OP•

who's murph?

2
Steveesmuyguapo•

Sorry should have read more of your post, Murph is a hero work out in honor of Navy LT Michael Murphy, a medal of honor recipient from the war in Afghanistan.

The work out is

1 Mile run 100 pull ups 200 push ups 300 air squats 1 mile run

With a 20lbs weight vest.

The shoes were great for that, but I wouldn't recommend anything further, at least until they are very well broken in.

2
LDN2016OP•

And when they're well broken in? I have a year of general use, lifting and gym cardio with a couple of runs but no serious consistent running in them.

Issue is not of money but space. Constantly travelling so the whole point of CF shoes was just to have the one pair.

1
Steveesmuyguapo•

If they don't fuck up your feet or back, 5k probably wouldn't kill you

1
Maevearie37/F•

I did a 5K in mine once and will never again. Got some intense foot pain for about two weeks. Went out and got a pair of Newtons on sale for anything over 800m.

1
badblood44•

I ran a 5k once in my Nano 4.0's. Never, ever again. Blisters for days.

1
Nodeal_reddit•

To the bathroom and back.

1