On the fence (but slightly obsessed) with Talisman. Lovers/haters please convince me either way!

WSIG

I've been researching my next board game purchase and keep coming back to Talisman. People seem to either love it or HATE it, so I trying to gather some more intel.

The big negatives (old fashioned roll and move, too random) don't really bother me. I like a big crunchy Euro as much as the next cube pusher, but I have no issue with a completely random fun fest as well. The game length comes up a lot as well, which concerns me only for the fact that it may not make it to the table as frequently.

I never played it growing up so nostalgia isn't a factor in my decision making, but fun definitely is. I'll probably be mostly playing it at 2-3p if that affects your recommendation.

Have at it! And thanks in advance!

Posted Jun 3, 2016, 1:09 PM UTC

219
oppedj02•

It's definitely what I would all a "beer and pretzels" game. It's the type of game you pull out when everyone just wants the hilarity of randomness that punishes or rewards players, and see what happens.

One challenge with 2-3 players is the lack of interaction that can occur. It's fun if players occasionally run into each other and attack other players or try to steal things back and forth. More players creates greater opportunities for that interaction. Additionally, if you invest in some of the big box expansions (the ones with extra boards), what can happen is that players go into the expansion board and never leave. This further reduces any interaction, as no one is on the main board any more. I'd recommend using some of the variants suggested on BGG (including ones by Callasmar) to limit side board access.

The small box expansions, however, can add more interesting alternative endings and mechanisms to add variety to the main game.

Additionally, there are characters that are inherently better or worse - not balanced at all, although I think FFG improved on them from earlier editions. I don't think it's anything special by any means. But it can just be a wacky adventure. Additionally, if you have friends who are not gamers, the familiarity of roll and move and randomness makes this an easy one to teach and might lead people to games with more depth.

Are you considering this one over other games, or just on its own merits? If the former, what other games are you considering? If the latter, what keeps bringing you back to Talisman? You mentioned what doesn't bother you, but didn't really expound on what you like about the game.

5
DogtortedOP•

I always have a few games I'm researching so when I can't resist the lure to buy a new game I have a selection to choose from. The appeal for me is the "beer and pretzels" aspect of the game. I'm looking for something that my less gamer-y friends can enjoy, but that I'll still have fun playing with my board game obsessed friends.

1
oppedj02•

Well, I think it will meet the beer and pretzels aspect for non-gamers. But I'm not sure it will work for your board game obsessed friends. So you might find it doesn't get played much.

On the other hand, have you looked at the new edition of Runebound? That one might fit the bill better for both groups.

1
DogtortedOP•

I'll have to take another look at Runebound. I'm not sure why it didn't appeal to me at a cursory glance but I'll take another gander.

1
808duckfan•

I've only played once, and I felt that it unforgivably sucked monkey balls for the reasons you mentioned. It was like playing Mouse Trap without the titular trap. Roll the dice, move your mice. Play Tales of the Arabian Nights for fun, random wackiness; it has at least some choices and a semblance of control.

4
DogtortedOP•

I love Tales of the Arabian Nights with the right group, although it does overstay it's welcome sometimes. Hmmmm...didn't think about the overlap with Talisman. They may scratch the same itch.

1
sethsez•

Talisman feels for all the world to me like Monopoly with a nerdier veneer. It's a roll-and-move game that takes forever, offers very little in the way of meaningful choice, and doesn't end so much as it just kind of dies and everyone stops playing. I can absolutely see people having fun with it with good friends, good booze and other distractions, but almost anything is fun under those conditions so I don't really consider it much of a plus.

With all that said, we all have our trash that we love (mine's Star Realms) and Talisman fills that role for a lot of people. I'll never consider it a good game, and I'll never recommend it, but I won't begrudge someone for getting something out of it.

2
YourBrainSplendor•

I own Talisman and several expansions and I happen to really like playing it. I just make sure that everyone playing it understands that it's a pure luck fest with no real decisions. Each player's turn should be quick since you're only real choice is whether to go left or right. I definitely recommend playing by the faster rules in the rule book and the game won't take as long as most people talk about it taking. The biggest thing I like about it is that it's easy to play with my non-boardgaming friends that like the fantasy setting. I can explain the rules quickly and we can be actually playing the game while socializing due to it being a low effort game. No one has to keep up with what everyone else is doing in order to win and the player that has played it 100+ times isn't going to automatically be the winner since there is no skill.

2
DogtortedOP•

Thanks! I always forget that my non-boardgaming friends are coming over more to hang out, and the gaming is kind of secondary to them so the ability to socialize is key. I just need to wean them off of their Cosmic Encounter addiction and get them to try something else for once!

1
Cliffy73Ascension•

There's an iOS app (don't know if it's on Android) which has many of the expansions available as IAP. You might find that a good way to sample.

I played it a bunch over the last couple weeks. It's fun if you don't care who wins, and once you have a few expansions some very goofy stuff can happen. But I'm not sure on balance if the euphoria of good dice rolls makes up for the blind steaming rage of bad dice rolls.

In real life it is absolutely a beer and pretzels game, and with expansions it's pretty spendy for beer and pretzels. Conversely, if you like a game with a huge board and like 80 different decks of cards, which I do, and you've got a group of people that will approach it with the right attitude -- that it's an excuse to get together and generate crazy stories, not a contest of wits -- it might work ok.

1
DogtortedOP•

Trying out the app as we speak! Thanks!

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Pixar_Star Wars: Rebellion•

I got it on steam from a humble Bundle. Played it a few times. Its interesting and pretty neat. While I would have LOVED to play this when I was younger, the mechanics are definitely dated. Roll to move. Spaces that say "Roll 1-6, if six turn into a frog" and such. While it was cool to play a few games, I have no desire to ever play the game again.

1
banachspacecadet•

If you like the fantasy theme and don't mind heavier, longer game, Mage Knight is great for 2-3. Much more engaging, but in the opposite end of the spectrum from roll-and-move.

For silly rolling fun with friends, how about King of Tokyo, or even a game of Liar's Dice?

1
YourBrainSplendor•

I don't think Mage Knight is a fair comparison to Talisman. I have both Talisman and Mage Knight and I've played Mage Knight far less with friends due to the time it takes to explain. Mage Knight is without a doubt the better game but it's also on a whole new level when trying to explain rules. Talisman I can explain in less than 10 minutes and each person's turn takes less than 30 seconds since there are so few choices.

2
Cliffy73Ascension•

I like Talisman much more than KoT (although I've played Talisman with expansions and only the base for KoT). Weird unpredictable stuff is always happening in Talisman. In my experience, nothing particularly unexpected ever happens in KoT.

1
DogtortedOP•

KoT fell really flat for me. Probably because we weren't playing with a very big group. I've checked out Mage Knight before but I'm not sure if it would hit the table that often. I'm kind of intrigued by the Star Trek reskinning though, so I'm waiting for those reviews to start trickling in. Definitely looking for something on the lighter side though. I've been on a heavy Euro kick lately and I'm looking to mix it up with a lighter title.

1
Carrollz•

I neither hate nor love it. I also don't mind the roll and move, especially since you always have choices nor the luck factor...I always appreciate luck in board games so that I can play with all ages and skill levels. I do mind that it can go on forever and after awhile I always start to feel like -what an I doing, what's the point?!?- and the end game is especially uninteresting and interminable, maybe not quite as bad as Risk, but close. There's so much about it that I do love, I love ago the different characters and that sense of adventuring around the board and never knowing what's going to pop up, I don't like how underpowered you are at first and then overpowered towards the end so there's often no point in rolling.

I ended up getting Relic which is almost the same game but fixes, for me, all the issues I had with Talisman while mostly maintaining all the elements I love.

1
automator3000•

Fun sure ... Until the game drags on and you feel like you've been playing forever and you don't even care who wins as long as the game just ends.

1
janto98•

Get Arcadia Quest instead. Way more fun and a better game.

1