"Sarcoplasmic Hypertrophy? Broscience at it's finest." - Your thoughts on whether strength training vs bodybuilding a bullshit dichotomy?
kropblog.dk/en/sarcoplasmic-hypertrophy/Posted Jun 5, 2016, 12:47 AM UTC
Posted Jun 5, 2016, 12:47 AM UTC
- Bodybuilders focus their exercise on other muscles than strength athletes. If you compare hypertrophy across muscle groups, bodybuilders would most likely display much more pronounced chest, shoulder and arm hypertrophy, relative to strength athletes, but lesser hypertrophy of the erectors, core muscles, glutes, hamstrings, and possibly quads relative to strength athletes.
This is key imo. I run gzcl, a powerlifting program. I get plenty of hypertrophy gains, but from a bodybuilding perspective they're way too concentrated in my lower body
i mean when you squat/dl that much you will have big legs/big arse
but I think the argument is that - anecdotally speaking - why do most bb'ers have bigger chests when most powerlifters a similar weight/training age can bench so much more than them.
aside from volume, what's causing this gulf in hypertrophy?
Well, chest/bench is a bad example, most PLers bench with dramatically different form (arched back, arms tucked, leg drive, etc.) that results in significantly less chest involvement (there's still a decent amount though). I think legs/squats would be a better example, George Leeman has twigs for legs but I'm pretty sure he had a 1000lbs+ deadlift and a 900lbs+ squat. If you were to look at his legs you definitely wouldn't guess he could move that much weight, but BBers that can move around half the weight he does have legs twice the size of his.
[removed]
Why is this downvoted? It's totally right.
No it's not. Because benching with your back arched actually activates more chest, arms tucked activates more triceps. so powerlifters should still have larger chests and triceps. And you guys forgot to factor in the fact that powerlifter and bodybuilders use different drugs
Uh, no. Arching doesn't result in less chest involvement. You guys should educate yourselves before posting.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EapVkFWiq_g
Pay attention to the pec fiber angles in relation to the bar. In a bench press, having a big ribcage or arching your upper back often results in much better chest recruitment. Going flatback does the opposite, and depending on your structure (especially if you're a smaller guy), you can wind up working mostly front delt instead of chest if you bench like this.
Neural activation, and the difference in training. It completely explains everything.
Neural activation ? Aside from getting neural gains in your first few months it becomes mandatory for your body to build actual tissue to keep on progressing.
"Neural gains"? Could you explain that?
Judging by your post, you either dont know what I meant, or you dont know what youre talking about.
TLDR
Strength Training - low reps, bigger weights, low volumes, longer rests (~2mins)
BB - high volume, lower weights, short rests (60-90 secs)
.
Supposedly strength training bodybuilding causes Sarcoplasmic hypertrophy and a swole look because the fluid inside the cell grows whereas strength training grows the myofibrils within cells and creates denser muscle which generates more power for the same space it takes up.
Lots of fitness youtubers have really pushed this concept the last few years but is it BS? I don't really know much about the science behind this.
I think you mean BB training causes sarcoplasmic hypertrophy and strength traning grows the myofibrils?
yeah, typo. fixed it.
But you just linked to an article written by one of the most knowledgable people, which not only explains the science, but straight up tells you its bullshit.
Im not sure where you could be in doubt, here.
I mean it's a very brosciencey blog post riddled with typos. Seeing if there are any arguments against the points he's making or if there have been any developments on the theory in the last 2 years.
Harnessing the power of crowdsourced knowledge and all that.
Brosciency blogpost? Holy shit.
KropBlog is Anders Nedergaard. There is not a single person in this sub who he couldnt school on anything training related. Seriously. If you dont take what he says as serious business, youre making life harder for yourself.
This is something Mike Matthews talks about in his Beyond Bigger Leaner Stronger book. He mainly has you lift in the 4-6 rep range (myofibrillar), ending in the sarcoplasmic range.
Edit: Super interesting topic OP, I'm going to bed but I want to talk more about this.
Yeah I think it really depends on your genetics. I train with mostly 5 reps and below and I'm getting good gains and most of the people I train with experience the same thing.
TL;DR
Strength is a skill and not just dependent on passive tissue properties.
Sarcoplasm makes up 0.5-2% of your muscle while myofibrils make up 75-90%
Bodybuilding trains both Type 1 and Type 2 muscle fibers, PL only trains Type 2
In normal humans glycogen is 5-10% of muscle, in endurance athletes it can be 15-20% but the number of myofibrils doesn't change.
Wasnt this bullshit disproven years ago? What the fuck man.
Relevant Greg Nuckols article:
http://strengtheory.com/sarcoplasmic-vs-myofibrillar-hypertrophy/
Shit man, TL;DR? If not I'll read this when I'm not tired and post something for y'all.
What you’re getting yourself into
6,300 words, 21-42 minute read time
Key Points
Sarcoplasmic hypertrophy – growth of the sarcoplasm that outpaces the growth of the myofibrils – does seem to happen to a significant degree.
Simple increases in glycogen storage don’t seem to be the primary driver of sarcoplasmic hypertrophy. It seems to be driven by an increase in sarcoplasmic protein content. The degree to which sarcoplasmic hypertrophy takes place may be influenced by training, but whether you can specifically train for sarcoplasmic vs. myofibrillar hypertrophy is unclear. More than anything, it seems to be a natural consequence of muscle growth itself.
Looking at strength differences between bodybuilders and powerlifters or weightlifters is not a valid way to assess degree of sarcoplasmic hypertrophy. However, dismissing sarcoplasmic hypertrophy simply because there are better explanations for the observed differences in relative strength is foolhardy.
It’s unclear whether steroids increase the amount of sarcoplasmic hypertrophy that takes place.